New Yorker Pizza

Once again — forgot part of the order. You guys did it again. I ordered the 8 wings and fries and the menu says that they come with carrots and celery. I ordered 2 orders of the Wings and fries as well as an order of jalapeño poppers. Sure enough you guys left off the carrots and celery. I have never seen a delivery restaurant consistently forget something in my order. Your convenient, the food tastes good, but you can never get my order right. Something is always left off. I’m done.

Place is a joke my first time ever going there and didn’t even get food because they REFUSED to make me food! There was one old ass slice of cheese pizza on the tray, and I asked if I could have two slices. The worker said it’s past 9 o’clock when it was 9:08pm and we close at 10. He then proceeded to say I could buy a small pizza for triple the price or just have the one old ass slice by itself!!! Like are you serious bro!!! Do your job and make a fresh ass pizza you bum!!! You still have 50 minutes to sell the rest of the 6 slices before you close, and if you can’t then take the rest home for your family and eat the 50 cents you just lost in ingredients. Re-​Fuckin-​Diculous!!! Dude with the long beard should be fired and other two guys who were working one who looked like a manger did and said nothing. Needless to say I will not be going back there and don’t recommend you to either!!!

We went here with friends one night after bringing the kids to the Leesburg Animal Park and we were starving. My friend’s kids had pizza by the slice, my friend’s husband had wings and his wife had a salad. All great and super fresh. ! It was well worth the wait for the best spinach and cheese calzone that I’ve ever had. In fact, I cannot wait to have one again later today after I visit the park. They best have brushed the calzone with buttery garlic, which made it so flavorful. I seriously cannot wait until later!

I placed an order for our kids and my sister placed an order for her kids at the same time to the same address. These were 2 different orders with 2 different credit cards to 2 different people with 2 different phone numbers. This establishment decided to cancel my order without notifying her but still charge her. It took about 45 minutes for the pizza to be delivered 2 miles. I called the restaurant in order to replace the order. I was very calm and nice but explained that if you are going to cancel an order, at least notify the customer, and the pizzeria employee abruptly hung up. Finally, I went to the pizzeria to get things straight and found out that they had charged me for the first order, cancelled that one, and thrown the receipt in the trash. They gave me garlic knots free of charge…
Later while any the gym, I received a phone call from an employee (possibly owner) on the phone number that I used to place the order. I was offered a free 9 $ pizza if I would remove my bad Unilocal review and I declined the offer. That kind of defeats the purpose of Unilocal.
A few days later, I received an email from Unilocal that my review had been reported and removed for «3^rd party content», most likely by the Pizzeria. The pizza was ok, not worth the effort. We will NEVER order from these jerks again.
If you make a mistake or a customer has a bad experience, don’t try to hide it or bribe them to remove the bad review. Acknowledge the mistake, publicly apologize, and offer to make it right publicly. People can be forgiving…

Unfortunate 1^st and last time ordering. My brother’s kids and mine like different types of pizza and I refuse let him pay for me, so we placed two separate orders to the same address. My pizza is amazing! Try the white broccoli pizza it’s incredible, and my kids loved the Buffalo pizza. Sadly, We don’t know how my brothers pizza is, apparently they saw the same address on two orders and took the money for both then just threw his order sheet into the trash. Two separate credit cards, two completely different orders… they just tossed his in the garbage. My sister in law had to leave the house on New Years Day to go remedy the situation after they HUNG UP ON HER when she called to replace the order. They took her money. The order was PAID FOR… they just didn’t make the pizza and didn’t deliver it. Good luck.

Amazing food truly authentic New York pizza & subs
This is our first visit to our local New Yorker pizza with my wife and my three daughters we had two different kind of pizza veggies buffalo wings & chef salad .
We love the food here we definitely come back here again soon. These guys are good fellas

I love this place!!! Today was my 3^rd time there since i moved to leesburg. Authentic NY cusine. Great people work there and you cant beat the price.

5 Stars for the hands down the BEST pizza in Leesburg!
Stone ovens, authentic NYC pizza dough, the tomato sauce was REAL and the best cheese.
Best part about the whole place above all are the PRICES are CHEAP. I’m honestly impressed.

Having lived around both NYC and Buffalo, I am bringing those biases to the review. Pizza is good. Crust is crisp on the outside with some softness intnerally. Lots of options on the topings and they do a good job of not over cooking them. Would not say its exactly like getting a slice in NYC however. Wings could have been crisper. The sauce was basic and nothing special. Overall this place is good but I still prefer fireworks pizza in leesburg.

This place is legit!
Finally– a thin slice. That’s all I’ve ever wanted, ever since I was a little boy in 94, softly weeping, longing for a fucking thin slice of fucking pizza.
Thank you New Yorker, keep it up.
I’ve very emotional right now so why don’t you make like a tree, and get out of here.

This is the only true NY/​NJ style pizza I have found in the area.
Everyone else’s pies are too small, too thick or just some delivery abomination in a part of America where people will buy anything with sauce and cheese on it, labeled pizza, and be happy. What is the world coming to?
Bad pizza has been served for so long that nobody even remembers how big a slice is supposed to be or how big a pie is supposed to be. Not the New Yorker, they make it right.
Stop in for a slice, a pie, and whatever else they have cooking.
Get the largest pie they make, because that’s the only size pie you are supposed to order! You either get slices, or the big one. That’s it. Take the rest home if there is any left.
Seriously, this is good pizza.
It’s not gourmet.
It’s not brick f*cking foo foo oven.
It doesn’t have pineapple, goat cheese, and currants on it… it’s PIZZA!
Got get some.

I was a little worried by the low Unilocal review, but I wanted to try something new. I can totally forgive the awkward order taker; maybe it was his first night, on his first job ever, and the first time he’s ever taken an order, ever. Or used a phone, ever. Don’t give up, Bro! The food though, I cannot forgive. The cheese on the margarita pizza was sliced so thin it bubbled into nothing when the pizza was cooked. The sauce for the pizza and the manicotti was the same and tasted like the can it was extruded into 18 months ago. The cheesecake was only vaguely cheesecake-​esque, and made my baby cry. He knows his milkfats and cheeses. The worst thing was probably the little garlic knots. They were bland, old, dry, gross, and free, like my balls. And nobody wants them, like my balls.

Awesome pizza! I’m from up north and used to real NY pizza. This is the best I have had in a long time! Perfect crust (not too doughy) and great sauce and cheese. Will definitely make this a regular place for pizza!

The pizza is half decent, but the staff is utterly incompetent. I was over charged, and pointed this out afterward. The guy barely spoke English and had no clue what he was doing. I finally just said forget it… grabbed my food and left. May not be back because of this.

Tried to redeem my Unilocal check-​in offer of a free 12″ cheese pizza with a purchase. So I purchase a 12″ Works pizza. When I went to pick it up, I was told that I have to purchase a large pizza to claim the offer (which isn’t mentioned anywhere in the coupon, although they have made an adjustment with Unilocal after my interaction today). When I asked how am I suppose to know that l, the exact answer was «because I am telling you so.» Great! If that’s the way you would like to promote your business, good luck!

Really like this place. They have so many options. It’s a Good slice of pie. I drop in sometimes twice a week for a pepperoni or cheese slice, they use REAL pepperoni, I don’t usually like pepperoni but the stuff they use is so good and seems fresh. Even like it cold!
Other day I got a meatball sub, putting up pictures. I don’t know what they do behind the counter, but everything tastes awesome. I also took home a Hawaiian pizza once, and it was delicious. Nothing but what you should expect from a good pizza joint! Please check this place out. Conveniently located right off Rt 7 and Rt 15/​King st.

Used to work in this store front when it was the fractured prune donut shop… So it was a bit strange being back. But that being said. As far as new York style pizza. They are the go to place in Leesburg… I’ve had Giovanni, roccos, but for the price and flavor new yorker is the place to go. $ 1.99 for a huge slice can’t be beat… Dudes running it today were real nice. We talked about pizza and they know when a place is good and they admit it. Don’t say oh we’re the best everywhere else sucks. I appreciate that. I’ve had a few pies and all of them left nothing to complain about. But I’ll admit. The location sucks for people that don’t know about it. Other than that… Great place

Some places should not offer delivery. This is one of them! Like another reviewer said its always ridiculously SLOW after they tell you it won’t be long. Then more times than not they forget something…
That said, the food is Delish usually. This time they burned some of the garlic knots but even so, still tasty.

Foods alright, delivery is always painfully slow to the point that we’ve had to call to on our last two order each taking over a hour and a half

Summary:
If you’re in a rush, and they don’t have enough slices… Just take what they have and bolt! You’ll be there a awhile. The food is good quality, but location and slow service are hard to overcome.
–
It was late, and my boys were hungry. I didn’t want to go to McDonalds so I thought we’d try pizza by the slice. Normally, we’d go to la villa Roma or Giovanni’s, but it had been a long day and this place is closer to home.
We ordered three slices of pizza, one slice was part of a za still in the oven. I cut some up into bite size pieces and split it between the two boys. I had to convince Joey that Kyle would share his slice when it came out. Oh, there was a pepperoni slice and the boys still find that too spicy.
We had all finished our two slices and the they were very good. Crispy crust on the bottom with a bit if chew still under the sauce and cheese, it’s good for the price.
The other slice took so long, I picked the pepperoni off my slice and gave the boys about ¼ each. After which, I decided to order a sandwich to go. I figured it would be done after we got the third slice. Not quite how it worked out. It took a little longer than I would have liked, and they finished about the same time.
On the plus side, the boys were full after splitting the one piece and some of mine. So we packed up the slice and the sandwich and headed home.
When I finally got my chance to eat the sandwich, I had to reheat it. It was a sausage and peppers hot sub. It wasn’t as good as Zachary’s pizza (VT near St. Mike’s), the sausage was a bit under cooked on the inside and over on the outside. I was hungry so I risked it! Luckily no issues…
To the owner: Sadly, I think the location and slow service will cause this business to eventually fail. You already scrapped the kabob place and changed to pizza… By the way, the kabobs were way better than the pizza! I think a new location that is easier to get in and out of, as well as closer to the center of town would help.
As for the slow service, I understand good food takes time. But when folks come to get a slice, they expect fast… I asked how long the next slices where going to be ready and was told 5 minutes. Which was not the case it was about 20… Tell the truth, and train your staff to offer alternatives that are quick and preferably higher profit margin items for you.
The food is good… You’re great, and I hope you make it!