The Ultimate Stevi B’s Pizza Buffet

Pizza was good and served hot. Not many ingredients on pizza such as chicken fajita… one piece of chicken! Price is good. Good place to go if you have kids but if you are looking for a «loaded» pizza keep looking

Great alternative to cicis. Only place with a baked potato pizza. Wish they had one where we live.

Our 22 year old daughter first told us about yhis place. The family has gone here probably about 10 times. The pizza is very tasty and they will prepare any pizza for you fresh at any time. We have a great time in the game room. It’s usually quite empty inside when we go. I believe this could be due to location. They have a nice staff clean facility and good food. I would recommend this to anybody wanting a decent meal for a great price.
My daughter and husband love the macncheese pizza and I always get a supreme. We love the stromboli and the smores pizza for desert. If you’re happy being simple and low key you’ll be pleasantly surprised with this place.

This is my first experience at Stevie’s b’s and I definitely will not be my last the food was great and was much better than my previous pizza Buffett experiences and this service was exceptional. I recommend anyone try it especially those with children very kid friendly place. The place was very clean and sanitary as well.

Stevi B’s opened in the Grove Park Shopping Center around June 2012. It’s spacious, clean and competing with Cici’s in «style». Kids under 10 eat for about $ 3.50, you can do salad bar only for under $ 4, seniors are 55+ and eat for $ 5.49 or so, other adults are about $ 6.50. Kids eat for 99cents on Sundays after 4 pm. There is an attached game room with about 18 activities that take tokens, including 3 skeeball machines and a motorcycle simulator. The place was empty both times I’ve been there, eight months apart.
The first time, the buffet had a dozen pizzas on display, most looking like they’d been there all day. The second time, about half a dozen pizzas were available. I took tastes of everything. The fresh pizzas were great. The older pizzas had crusts of cardboard and ‘stiff” ingredients. There was a decent variety. The garlic bread, the wafer thin Greek pizza with feta, the bacon pizza and the Hawaiian pizza were good. I special ordered a bbq & black olive pizza – didn’t like the bbq flavor AT all, nor the «hot wing» pizza. The standard red sauce pizzas (cheese, pepperoni, sausage) were sorta blah the first time and tasty the second time. The white sauce pizzas were only «okay». The alfredo sauce for pasta was flavorless. The tomato sauce for pasta was yucky and crusted my first visit but tasty the second visit. The crusts of each pizza were of inconsistent thicknesses and qualities. The big folded «ends» were not edible – too chewy and dry the first visit and totally delicious and edible the second visit. Not sure why the inconsistencies between visits. (But you might read the filtered reviews for more opinions.)
The salad comes at the end of the pizza bar and was both fresh and well endowed with topping choices and six dressings, one low cal. Second visit, the salad bar was less appetizing, some foods were dried out.
The salad bar blew the competition away first visit. There were five dessert pizzas that trip, only two dessert pizzas on the second trip. Apple pie was great, rocky road-​full of marshmallows was great, mandarin orange was hard as a rock so I ate the topping off which was good and I skipped the sticky bun choice which definitely looked sticky. The employees were friendlier and more attentive second trip but I still felt like I was eating in a ghost town. They serve Pepsi beverages and have TVs.
They have private party deals that include tokens and balloons and you can get take out or special pizza orders.
Giving three stars on the first visit because there certainly was enough fresh food to eat. Tempted to head towards 4 stars on the second visit. The dried out versions and low personality of the place do not beckon my return. Floor was sticky second trip. It’s got the space and concept down, to compete with other pizza joints, but does not have the flavor and consistent quality going for it yet. (I’d choose the competition.) But it’s nice to know there’s a decent price buffet nearby and I may return for that.