Sticky Fingers Ice Cream

This has become our hands down favorite place to get ice cream. They pack it in the cones, so you get a lot for your money. It’s creamy and flavorful. We always end up stopping by unexpectedly. My go to flavor has to be cookies and cream. Somehow they manage to keep the cookie part nice crunchy. So no soggy cookies. We will be back time and time again!

Sticky Fingers is one of those rare treats when traveling; you won’t find thirty or forty flavors but what you will find is great tasting, flavorful ice cream. The vanilla is mild but sweet. The Dulce de Leche is intense. Other flavors include, but are not limited to Mint Chip, Coconut Almond Joy, Killer Chocolate, Pistachio, Peanut Butter Fudge, Rocky Road and Salty Caramel Pretzel.
If you’ve just finished lunch or dinner on Lake Kauneonga’s restaurant row, cross the street and have dessert at Sticky Fingers. They are uniquely child friendly with an outdoor play area and kid sized tables.
You want ice cream? Sticky Fingers will not disappoint. And fear not for your boyish/​girlish figure; there are plenty of places nearby to rent a kayak and burn the calories.

Just take my money! We stopped in here by accident, we were trying to find parking for another restaurant. I saw the sign and made a mental note for after dinner.
Well bust my buttons, this place is ice cream heaven. So many unique and delicious flavors, homemade cookies and pastries and great customer service. This is a place I will travel out of the way for.
It caters to families which I love! They have outdoor seating spread out all over. They have a jungle gym, an outdoor high seat, little tables and chairs and other little toys. We load up the tiny humans with sugar and then let them burn it off.
The owner is a super chill Austrailian. He has a contagious smile and a very relaxed demeanor. The like was out the door and he killed it with service, fast and efficient.
This place is one of the many reasons I love Sullivan County in the summer. I hope they’re here to stay during the warm months.

All natural ice cream (Jane’s is served here) — So far I’ve had the Coconut Almond Joy (lots of coconut flakes and really creamy), Killer Chocolate (Love this!!!), Mint Chip (It’s white with medium sized chips, no green as there is no additives/​food coloring used), and the Kahlua Cappuccino with Toffee (OMG-​really Good). My friend got 3 scoops of the fruity flavored ones and loved it. Sample any flavor you want, owner is quite friendly. Usually they have a variety of cookies, brownies, and other baked goods for sale. You can also get a cappuccino to go along with your treat! The beverage cooler has lots of natural sugar sodas, milks, juices and there is a little stand up sliding freezer with ice pops (I was really thinking about getting the coconut pop). When the wife is there, she makes her specialty, Frozen Hot Chocolate. For a specialty place with specialty ice cream, $ 8 and change is not bad for 4 scoops of ice cream plus 1 Gus (Grown Up Soda) Dry Root Beer. They are open late too, which is awesome, and there is parking behind the shop. Who is open til 10pm on a Sunday? I hope they stay here!

Incredible ice cream! The dulce de leche, killer chocolate and salty pretzel are all excellent choices. Definitely get a waffle cone, too!
For those not a fan of ice cream, they also have pops, coffee (including cappuccinos etc.) and specialty bottled soft drinks.

Unbelievable ice-​cream. Don’t miss. Had peanut butter fudge and pistachio. My husband had dulce de leche and salted caramel pretzel. All were great