Toasted Bagels & Deli

They have absolute great breakfast sandwiches, me and my sisters go there alllllll the time. Even though I live in California, when I do come visit Jersey I definitely come here for breakfast sandwiches, the guy always remembers what I order. The only cons is the parking, it’s very hard to park and also your purchase needs to be $ 7 or more to use your card. But overall I’m very happy with my breakfast sandwich!

Granted, this is the most decent bagel I’ve had in Jersey City (could be denser & chewier for my taste) but they are so stingy with the cream cheese. they only put a very small amount on just one side of the bagel. If I do go back, I’ll buy it plain & add my own cream cheese.

Great sandwich place. Toasted has a wide selection of sandwiches, wraps, a take-​out buffet, and a make your own salad station. The staff is always friendly and willing to accommodate special orders. There are a large amount of regulars who frequent Toasted at lunch time, which is a good sign. There’s enough variety at a good price to keep people coming back.

I was underwhelmed. Had the whole wheat everything with porkroll, egg and cheese. I’d say it’s a mediocre bagel. Not very flavorful and the texture is a little dry. The sandwich had one very thin slice of porkroll so I could barely taste it. For $ 4 I’d skip it next time.

Place is the worst. A few months ago I ordered and paid for a Turkey, egg and cheese, when I got to work and opened my sandwich, it was a plain bagel with butter. I called and they offered to replace my sandwich for my next order but they did not follow through with that and I just wound up paying 4 dollars for a buttered bagel. After 6 months of boycotting their business I gave them another shot. I ordered a sandwich with mustard and when I got back to my office with my lunch it had no mustard and extra mayo. In addition to this, they offer a free meal after a certain amount of purchases, which they keep track of by a stamp — only thing is they have a million reasons why they can not stamp your card. The minimum purchase order to obtain a samp is $ 7 — my order was 8, but since a portion of that was for a Snapple and not the sandwich it did not qualify. In short, the service and attention to customer is terrible. I gave them a second shot and I regret it. This place is right down the block from my job and I used to spend a decent amount of money in there every week, but I will not be going back at all and have advised the people in my office building to do the same. If I could give them no stars I would.

Great place to order lunch from. We order at least 3 times a week and can change it up each day. Sandwich, Salad, Breakfast, Wraps, Burger. This place is awesome. And they make their sandwiches with love. :)

Really like this place but I wish they used gloves!!! I move been so many times hoping they would and they never do. Ugh the bagels and the bread are so fresh I wish they would just be a little more sanitary. Sadly because of this I won’t return anytime soon :(

I typically order from them on grubhub and received my orders in 15 minutes. I decided to order from them directly (to prevent them from being hit with grubhub charges, **BIG MISTAKE) and it took them an hour to deliver.
Because of this bad experience I will not be ordering from them ever again.

This place is only good if you walk in to order. They are busy and take forever during the morning and at lunch but the food is good. NEVER order through Grubhub because they will mess up your order every time! I go back b/​c there is nothing decent to eat around here but they need to work on improving service and delivery.

This place is an awesome local bagel spot. The bagels are really fresh, crispy on the outside and doughy on the inside-​high quality north jersey bagels.
The staff is incredibly nice and welcoming and seemed to have a great relationship with many of the customers I saw rolling in.
A little pricey for bagels but not unreasonable. I didn’t have the lunch menu (I just had a whole wheat everything with lox spread and tomato), but I’d def go back and try it out.

Great sandwiches for breakfast and lunch!
I try to go here everyday. I recommend the smoked sandwich (#9) on a long roll.
I requested my favorite soda and they made sure it was in stock! So nice businesses like this still exist. Great people who make tasty food.

Okay. Third review’s a charm, right?
I’ve found this place to be rather hit-​or-​miss, as per previous reviews. But I’ve stopped in a few times since then and now it seems as if they have gotten their shit together. The breakfast sandwiches are good again, with the right ratio of meat, cheese, and egg. Got a chicken caesar salad from here for the first time the other week and, while I know it’s hard to mess up such a thing, it can be done. Thankfully, Toasted Bagels did it right. There was a very generous amount of freshly grilled chicken, crisp croutons, romaine, and parm. They added the dressing, which I usually don’t like, but didn’t realize they were going to do when I ordered. Thankfully it was just the right amount to coat all the salad components without being soggy or excessive.
There is a great selection of drinks and an even more extensive lunch menu, of which I’ve had nothing except that salad so I can’t comment.
Service is always friendly and efficient, and from the looks of it, they have regulars. The business is always consistent so things aren’t sitting around forever.
They accept credit cards and I think the minimum is only $ 7 so you will probably be able to use it more often than not.
So thankful they’ve gotten it together because it’s right up the street and super convenient.

I live really close to here and often find myself running in for a quick sandwich or wrap. Usually I just get the turkey sandwich, which I don’t think you can really mess up, but they make it great every time. They put just the right amount of meat, mustard, and other toppings on– generous amounts without it feeling like too much food.
However, I have had subpar experiences here. Their tuna wrap was tasty but also soggy, which made eating it a mess and less tasty. Their bagels are decent but not anything amazing.
I do have to say I enjoy coming here because the staff is very nice. Even when it’s busy, they have a good attitude, which makes it more appealing to go here.
The bottom line is this: if you want a simple sandwich that’s cheap, fast, and fresh from a friendly staff, this is the place for you. For me, it’s a good alternative to the Dunkin Donuts across the street where all of the food is processed. If you’re looking for anything more than this, you may have to look elsewhere.