Another Man’s Treasure Vintage Store

Pretty cool place lot of vintage clothes. Pricing is high and a little hard to find parking on the weekends. The shop isn’t very big but is very retro inside and they have a nice selection of vinyl records.

This place is awesome. Great selection of vintage items for a fair price. Wish I lived closer

Now this place is a gold mine. It’s got all kind of clothing from the sleek 40’s to the boho era of today.
–The owner is very knowledgeable on fashion and she can easily tell you anything you want to know about a certain piece. She is also planning on moving the store to a larger place so that she could combine her current store with her collection of older pieces.
–The prices are spot on for what’s in store. The older the piece, the more expensive it will be. Some rarer or higher brand pieces will also cost you an extra buck.
–The sales rack that sways outside the store is my favourite. Pieces you find there are the rejects and probably need a little fix up. bought a fantastic 80’s romper for only $ 10 and got it tailored to fix the loose back. It’s gorgeous.
It’s a great store, it truly is. Some may complain about the prices, however this is VINTAGE clothing. It’s been used and has withstood the test of time. You can be assured that what you purchase will last you a good many years with your loving care.

This is a rather cute shop with great atmosphere. Sadly however the quality of the merchandise doesn’t hold up to the quality it’s presented. I’m not saying things are in bad condition, on the contrary everything is in great condition. It’s just the selection is uninspired and all lower quality to begin with merchandise. I asked about older and higher quality pieces and the lovely sales girl told me they had what I was asking for only it was all in a different location shopable only by appointment and only available on weekdays. You know, because people who can afford quality vintage have all the time in the world and can shop on weekdays. Hearing this turned me off to the entire store and I wanted to review it with less stars. However with such friendly service and such I have to review it better. I guess I should say this is a great vintage shop for the beginner shopper. Nothing too rare nor interesting here though for us seasoned folk. A real bummer as it was quite a trek for me to get to the store. In my opinion they should at least have a few teaser pieces, some «gems» to let the shopper know that they know what they’re talking about and that coming back across the river on a weekday to set up an appointment would be worth the while. At least I tried it. Nice place for a cheap ‘50s frock and vintage Ralph Lauren for the men.

Great little vintage shop! Found some awesome earrings & a timeless chiffon top. Always love popping in to see what they have.

If you are a fan of unique and affordable vintage clothing and haven’t been to AMT yet, it will be your new favorite store. I love this place! I always get compliments on clothing I wear from here. When I tell my complimenting friends that the shirt is from AMT I feel like I’m revealing one of JC’s greatest hidden gems.
I usually go a few times a season to check out what’s new. They are always getting new stock and good items go fast! Whenever I find something that fits I get it, and I don’t often leave empty handed. (I have a collection of AMT skirts that I wear year round.) Also the owners and employees are very passionate about vintage fashion and it really shines through to make the shopping experience something special.

This is a treasure trove of amazingness (no pun intended). The owners’workers are extremely helpful — and even though we were looking for something very specific (a cigarette holder aka Audrey Hepburn style) — they were very kind to note they used to have some but they were all out.
If we werent in a hurry to get back to running errands, I probably would have spent another hour in there perusing the clothing. Luckily I live nearby so Ill definitely be back!

I’ve always wandered in here, but never purchased anything until the other day when I needed a last minute fancy-​schmany dress. I loathe the mall and Macy’s in general and really wanted a unique piece and Another Man’s Treasure Vintage Store would be a sure bet.
After picking through some teeny dress, I found it. A dazzling dress straight from the 80’s that would be perfect for my upcoming Unilocal Event. This place has the best inventory and you know what? They aren’t over priced. I know, I know. The thought of spending more than a few bucks on used clothing sometimes is a bit bewildering, but c’mon, this is far from a Salvation Army.
I ended up getting a long sleeve, to the knee sequin bluish/​purple dress that I. LOVE. I mean, I can’t wear it often, but boy, when I can, you know I will. It was $ 70 and if I checked in on my Unilocal app (the one time I forget), they offered a 10% discount, so it really should have be $ 63. Worth every penny. I felt like a million bucks, it’s one of a kind and it’s a beauty. I don’t think I would have said that about anything I would have bought at Macy’s or the likes.
Definitely head here if you’re into vintage and finding unique pieces to add a bit of glitz to that wardrobe!
** Bonuses: the very cool — old French music playing in the background.
— The employees are so nice and friendly. They are there to help, but not pushy. Definitely a genuine vibe you only get from local businesses!
— the place is small, but does carry quite a bit including bags, jewelry, hats, jackets, menswear and home goods.

I was never into buying other people’s clothes until the day came when my unemployment ran out, my good clothes from the department store had been worn to death and I couldn’t afford to go to Bloomies anymore. Not even Target. So started haunting consignment shops and going to stoop sales. This is one is top notch. I bought a pair of barn red boots made in Brazil in 1972 that had thick heels. They lasted a while. Loved them. Pained me when the heels finally gave out and they couldn’t be fixed. This shop carries many unique items plus she carries a row of Vinyl records which is pretty spiffy. Take your time in here, there is a lot to see.

I haven’t found anything here in the last three visits. No 6 or 6.5 shoes or boots but if you’re a seven and a half this is probably a good shop to hit. More than half the store is menswear. What they do have for women is not greatly curated and though it has a warm feel to the shop it’s so dark I can’t read the labels or really get a good look at something without pulling it completely out to clearly identify what the object looks like. I wouldn’t bother if I wasn’t in the neighborhood.

Great store! Reasonably priced!

Cool stuff for very good prices. If you’re into vintage you know it could be pricey. Not this place. Awesome jewelry. Always worth a look.

They have such a great vinyl selection for cheap! Everything is well laid out and the selection of clothing is fabulous. They even have some vintage home décor items. The service is friendly and attentive. Can’t wait to go back.

I’ve been shopping at Another Man’s Treasure for the past five years or so, and I’ll continue shopping there, for several good reasons: The selection is updated regularly. The prices are reasonable (and far below Manhattan vintage price levels). The clothing is all in very good to excellent condition, and is clearly labeled with decade, size, etc. The owners (Meika and Warren) are passionate about their business, and they work hard while always remaining friendly to customers (again, very unlike many Manhattan vintage shops). I love recommending AMTV to friends in Jersey City and beyond.

For all you vintage clothing lovers, this is a great place to check out. They have everything from shoes, sweaters, paints, hats, and ties etc. for us men. For you ladies, everything your heart’s desire may be found here for you.
I normally drop in often to see what they have just in case something peaks my interest. Everything is very well organized and the service is really great.
As they say, one man’s trash is another man’s treasure.

So well organized, and the girls at the store will help you shop. Trust them — even if you don’t think it’s your style; those are the clothes I ended up buying. Shivali is amazing! She set aside some cocktail & evening dresses I needed for a formal event, some that I would have never pulled off the rack for myself AND I ended up buying 5 dresses!!! Clothing and accessories range through all decades. Inexpensive and excellent quality. Plus, if you Like their Facebook page, you can see postings for incoming styles and accessories!

Awesome place for legitimate vintage clothing. Their collection is unique and does look like it was carefully selected. The clothes were in amazing shape and had reasonable prices. Plenty of stuff for the guys; plethora of boots.
They also have a small selection of vinyl records. Picked me up some old school Tom Petty for just $ 3. I’m pretty sure this is the start of my new obsession with vinyl.

Batman soundtrack on vinyl record for $ 3?
That is bad ass.
If I had disposable income, I’d buy ½ the store. When I move back to Jersey City, I probably will.

its wonderful to walk into a place like this and the employees actually love what they do
Every time I’m on grove I try to make a stop here. There always replenishing their
supply of clothes So you see it Tuesday better buy it, might not be there when you
come back.
I mainly go for the 60s shirts in there which is plentiful. Accessories are on point ties
for men and luggage too. They have everything
Instead of going to the Newport mall stop here

My wife and I absolutely love this place. Such a great addition to the neighborhood. The couple that I believe own it are really helpful, cool & couldn’t be better at what they do. They have such a great eye for stuff, and must have great connections because their inventory absolutely hits the mark. I just wish they would find some size 8.5 men’s shoes! I’ve nearly dove across the floor their a few times to grab shoes only to find that they are not my size.
Both my wife and I have found great stuff here. We outfitted ourselves and another couple we were going to a wedding with where the dress code was ‘Brooklyn Chic.’ From the response we got from other guests at the reception, we nailed it.
They always have so much fun stuff here. I found a fantastic flannel that has truly become my ‘Sunday shirt.’ My wife has found everything from every day styles to «OMG Where did you get that?!»
I almost don’t want to tell you how good this place is because my greedy side wants all the selection to be ours. hahaha.