Italian Carry Out

Great place for Pizza and Calzones. The pricing is reasonable and they deliver what more could you ask for. We also sampled the chicken parm platter that was huge with pasta and a salad. Almost right across the street from Ithaca college. We will be back.

I’m sorry I don’t live in Ithaca. .This place epitomizes the «shop small» ad age. Great Customer service… you can tell it’s family run, cause they care and know how to do bussiness. I also walked in the café next door and admired that as well, but will try tommorrow. .great meatball parm. tommorrow will try canzone or white pie. If tour in town for college (Ithaca), make a left and go up the hill a block instead of down…

great little joint, we had a fabulous greek salad and an order of wings for lunch yesterday. friendliest bunch of people you can imagine. guys, you lost one star — i’d have given you five — because no one behind the counter was wearing head gear yet i saw plenty of long hair, fortunately no hair found its way into our food. mind your health practices!

I was reluctant at first because of the look of the place and the totally boring name. But I’ll tell you what, I was so excited about this pizza that I had to write this immediately. In fact, I’m eating their pizza as i write this and it is amazing. I didn’t give this five stars because quite frankly I’m a pizza snob and it isn’t quite as good as say classic trenton style like DeLorenzo’s tomato pie in Robinsville NJ which will make your head explode. So it isn’t quite as good as that because it’ totally different but I have been living in Ithaca for over a year and I have been trying desperately to find awesome pizza and I’ve finally found it. Their sauce is on top which for some reason I think makes the texture very crispy on the outside but soft and gooey on the inside. I had a reg pizza with sausage and fresh mushrooms and all their ingredients seem quality and good, especially their sauce. Honestly it really reminds me of that really good pizza that you would find on a beach boardwalk that you go to every year when you go to the ocean.
For Ithaca I’m giving it five stars but overall I’m giving it 4 stars just because I’ve had better pizza one time or another in my life. I recommend the pizza and the ICO fries. Don’t pass this place up if you’re in Ithaca and want pizza!

I always hear about this place but never got a chance to visit until this year. After my first visit, I could not stop ordering from ICO. I love everything on the menu but so far my favorite is the Flying Squirrel hot sub. With chicken and philly cheesesteak on fresh bread, its just too good to be true. Compared to other pizza places in Ithaca, you can choose your own sauces, their blue cheese is homemade and you feel like family when you go here as the Salino family is welcoming and always get to know their customers.

It has been about 4 years since I had their pizza even though I pass by frequently. The pizza I had was pepperoni, soggy, and tasted perfumed. When I used to get the wings, they were extra crunchy (overcooked) just the way I like them. I had ordered extra crunchy wings to go with the above mentioned pizza. When I got home I found the wings to be barely cooked. The next time I stopped for wings I pointed this out to the woman I was told was the manager. She assured me the order would be extra crunchy. Again barely cooked. I haven’t been back.

It is easy to miss this jewel tucked away discretely on the side of the road. Don’t let the décor fool you, this place is family run and run right. Come here for the pizza and leave with a smile on your face. Order a slice, trust me you won’t need two. The slices are quarter pizzas themselves and a steal at two bucks a piece! Order the pepperoni and you won’t be disappointed, it is covered! And if you eat in the fountain soda is free!

Right down the road from Ithaca College (IC) lies a little Ithaca gem. The people there are very service oriented and friendly. The pizza is crunchy when you get it with eggplant. They make fresh food, salads, etc. My family and I go up there often.
In the summer you can sit outside. The prices and value are outstanding.
Unlimited soft Drinks come with the food!