Insomnia Cookies

Was wanting cookies or ice cream late one Sunday night and realized all the joints had closed down besides Insomnia. Walked in and was instantly treated by the staff and other patrons. I got ice cream and a brownie and it was DELICIOUS! The brownie was just the right amount of gooey and crisp edges.

Megan. Thank you for cheering up my friend. Your thoughtful gesture was not forsaken. I will forever support this business so long as they continue to employ people like Megan. Truly a good human.

Get the peanut butter cup
And the snickerdoodle
And the chocolate chunk.
Get any and all cookies. They are amazing.
We stopped by after dinner down the street. The ‘hot cookies delivered until 3am’ sign drew us in. They are so warm and delicious

WORST CUSTOMER SERVICE EXPERIENCE IN MY LIFE!
I entered the store for the first time, I bought a dozen of cookies, paid, then I saw the milk so I grabbed a small bottle, and went back to pay for it, then this conversation happened:
Me: I forgot to get the milk, you can’t have cookies without milk!
The terrible employee: Yes, your total is $ 3.29 (or something like that)
Me (In a positive and low tone): $ 3.29? (As if I heard it wrong, and just confirming)
The terrible employee: I’m not trying to push you to buy it.
Me (I was like WTH! but continued being polite and nice): Yes that’s ok, but you know the gallon would cost less.
The terrible employee: I know, if you were drunk I’ll be able to sell it to you easily, and go get a gallon from somewhere else.
At this point I was about to throw the bottle at his face for being such a jerk. It’s my first and last time being at this business in all its other locations. I would go spend my money somewhere else. Circle City Sweets (E Market St) have better cookies though!
Ok, let’s go back to their cookies and review them … They’re terrible too! They taste just like any other cheap cookies, or maybe worse.

Snickerdoodles. All things Snickerdoodles…
but before I say more — let me give proper and due respect to those chocolate chip amaze-​pan cookies. I use the made up combo of ‘amaze-​pan’ because the pan that held these cookies as they baked themselves into perfect is surely worth a mention, and dang for sure amazing !! I love chocolate chip cookies as much as the next person but I also don’t love chocolate THAT much, so I have a love/​hate relationship w/​CCC. They need to be made right and not over-​done with chocolate (for me). These cookies are full of chocolate but that didn’t stop them from making a date with my tastebuds as we drove home. No milk necessary although milk would only make it a dream come true. The cookies are warm so once in teh bag together, they begin to melt into one bag of chocolate chip cookie stuff. Just take bites of it as if it’s a whole cookie. You shouldn’t be able to tell the difference.
Now,
back to snickerdoodle heaven. Once upon a time there was a girl named Januarie. She really wanted to have her own handful of snickerdoodle cookies. She went to the grocery store and bought a pack but to her dismay, they were hard in the middle and a little too sweet. She tried the bakery but they specialize in donuts; not cookies. #Fail. Finally, just before she gave up her quest to find the perfectly cooked snickerdoodle cookie with the right pizazz and the perfect amount of snicker for the doodle and the softness in the middle that lets out a sigh of love when broken in half, she stumbled upon Insomnia Cookies. Listen when I say they have perfected the art of a great snickerdoodle cookie. I want a dozen but I would eat them all in one sitting so I will never do that to myself.
I first had Insomnia at an event thrown by IndyFringe and since have gone on to become a fan. Also, who wouldn’t be a fan of a place that only serves piping hot, fresh cookies, particularly delicately made flowers-​of-​fun such as snickerdoodles, in the middle of the early morning wee hours? I can get cookies delivered to me at 1am and they will be hot? And soft? And gooooood???
OH!
Sign me up !!! What in the world is there to complain about when this is all things so right? This is all things Snickerdoodles!!!

Walking in, the place is clean, has a small eating bar at the window, but otherwise, relatively plain.
I was really looking forward to trying this place because I’ve hears so much about it from friends. Unfortunately, they were out of several flavors. I did try the snicker doodle cookie and it was warm, gooey, and tasted like delicious snicker doodle.
A pretty small establishment, not a ton of choices, but at least the ones they did have were really tasty.

Our junk food craving was at an all time high so we didn’t hesitate to order from Insomnia Cookies for the first time.
We ordered a dozen cookies, a variety of flavors, and the special of the day of 3 free chocolate chip cookies, and of course milk. 2 people + 15 cookies= Don’t Judge!
Anyway, I really liked the ease of ordering online BUT there was a blip in the system or something because when I checked out and reviewed our order everything was there. But when the delivery came it was missing our 3 free cookies and our milk. I went back to look at the final order and neither of those items were showing up.
But lets get to the good part: THE COOKIES. They are big, warm, chewy, and seriously tasty. The husband is a cookie connoisseur and he raved about them.
Delivery was prompt but the cookies were not as warm as expected and they had slid to one side of the box in a big pile.
Still, I give them 4 stars because the cookies are just that good. I’m going to brush off the technical glitch and poor delivery as a fluke and won’t let it inhibit my desire to order from them again.

I don’t eat cookies a lot. But if I am craving for some cookies, this place is on the top of my list.

Tried to make an order online. Tried multiple different times with multiple different devices and forms of payment, still failed to work. Called to make an order, waited OVER 15 Minutes with no response whatsoever! After working at it for over 40 minutes I gave up, no cookie is worth that much.

Sometimes you just have to say yes. Purchased a six pack because you can’t stop at one. One cookie is anywhere from 160 to 240 calories which makes them sinful. I say run an extra mile and dig in.

Cookie Monster approved!
On the rare occasion my boyfriend and friends want to go out to Broad Ripple for a night on the town, while the fellas grab a tall one, you can usually find me and my girlfriends between Insomnia cookies and Hubbard and Cravens getting our cookie and coffee fix.
The six pack is the way to go. We’ll definitely be back on warmer months to try our cookies al a mode!

My wife and I needed a sugar fix on Saturday night. Open the Unilocal!app, search for desserts near me and Insomnia Cookies pops up. We went for it. I drove on college to broad ripple ave an parked in the parking garage next to Hop Cat (you can park 20 minutes for free). Walked to the cookie store and purchased Chocolate Chunk, Oatmeal Raisin, Peanut Butter, and Snicker-​doodle.
The cookies came out of a warming drawer so they were nice and melty. They were served in a pizza box and were nicely organized. I was back to my car in 10 minutes and they were still warm when I got home.
Over all, it was a good treat. I got 6 cookies — 3 for each. 2 was all we could eat and it was a bit much. They are dense! I would say they are a good cookie, but not a «OMG! cookie.» I’d rather have the ones we make at home, but that is a time consuming project when you need a quick fix.

Excellent Snickerdoodles. Great Chocolate chip and m&m cookies too. Love they deliver love even more i can order onn line and grab on my way home.

Can I say… best cookies hands down.
When you walk in, the smell of oven baked cookies is just amazing. They have a great selection and they always serve it warm. They also offer ice cream and you can whip up your culinary skills and make your own ice cream sandwich.
You’re hungry at 1 am? They’re open! You’re in your dorm, hungry, been playing video games and in pj’s? They deliver! Not just that… they deliver Til 3 AM!!! How awesome is that?
I just wish they offer milkshakes. It could have been more awesome.

The cookies are always served warm, but have never tasted fresh, let alone worth the cost. I’ll stick to making Pillsbury cookies at home.

Yuuuuum! Ooozzie warm melty goodness of delicious cookies!
And friendly service too!

I was so looking forward to this treat. But was highly disappointed…
We had driven by earlier and finally stopped in.
There were several girls in line in front of me.
It must have been a night of I dont want to be at work… because everyone working looked upset.
My husband watched as the cookie baker let many of cookies touch his dirty sweaty shirt as he boxed them or moved them to a warmer.
The cashier was not helpful at all and just slopped my cookie a la mode together. I was shocked when she handed me a personal sized pizza box with my cookie and ice cream in it.
The warm cookie immediately melting the ice cream which would have great it the container was plastic or leak proof. IT WAS NOT!!!
It made a complete mess on me in the car. The ice cream pouring out of any opening. Gross, sticky mess…
The cookie was ok… Pilsbury and my oven taste better and I could have wat more cookies. The mint chocolate ice cream was delicious.
I won’t be back… there are plently of 24 hour grocery stores that sell cookie dough and I will make my own.

First week of college, I hear the words «insomnia» a lot so I was like «oh great, guess I won’t get much sleep the next few years» (which is partially true), but nope, Insomnia takes on a whole new meaning. Because insomnia = cookies, cookies so good you may lose sleep over them.
I’ve never been in the store but they deliver (yasss) BUT you need a minimum order of 12 :/​However, not hard to accomplish when you enlist the help of some amigos.
Best flavors: double chocolate chunk, snickerdoodle, peanut butter, white macadamia… really, you can’t go wrong!
They are delivered to you hot and gooey and delicious. They’re addictive and you will never eat a better cookie in your life.

Wow, warm cookies delivered, how cool is that?! Amazing really. Nice staff and quick service. I didn’t even care how much each cookie was… just give me more please!
I tired the chocolate chunk and the oatmeal raisin, both great, flavorful and warm. If this isn’t comfort food nothing is!

I have to say I loved the cookies– but hated the service! The woman behind the counter scowled the entire time! I asked her what she recommended… «uhhh I don’t know… A cookie maybe?» Super snarky! I also was checking the ice creams out and she was standing there sighing really loudly the whole time, there was nobody behind me or anything though I swear!
The white chocolate macadamia was my favourite. We tried mint, which I didn’t like but my boyfriend did– it tastes like an Andes mint. The chocolate chunk was exactly what you would expect it to be. I do think they are a little bit expensive for small sized cookies. Their prices for milk are outrageous– we just got our cookies in a box and took them home. That being said, they are very good. I would recommend this place if you have a late night sweet tooth– I guess try to ignore the grouchy staff!