Katie’s Ice Cream

They were unfortunately out of black raspberry, but we got cape cod sand and cape cod mud, both of which were excellent. They’re a little too sweet — nobody could finish their ice cream because the sugar was so heavy. Still, the flavors are great. Personally, I think cape cod sand is the best one — it’s creamy and delicious — but if you’re more into chocolate try the cape cod mud :).

This was a major stop and what fabulous ice cream they had. I had a cape cod styled butterscotch and the smoothness was just outstanding, it had a taste of real homemade butter underneath. A slight taste but it was there and it made the ice cream alive for me.

Very good ice cream. Various different flavored and they have non dairy ice cream too. The small can have 2 different scoops and it was only 3.48. Can be shareable. I had their cape cod mud flavor.

Great ice cream here! I love that they have a really big selection of different flavors and they let you try as many as you want. I loved the cape cod sand and the brown butter pecan, but you really can’t go wrong with anything.

I went with a small cup $ 3.25 of their secret Cape Cod Sand and the Toasted Coconut Caramel and ate while the sweet smell of fresh waffle cones being made in the corner wafted through the air — yum!
While making my choice, I sampled a few of their more intriguing sounding flavors before I finally settled on my picks. Coconut flavored ice cream is often disappointingly artificial tasting — not so here! I like that most of their products are made in house.

Hmhmhm YUMMY!!! I ate a lot of ice cream n Gelato in my life, all over the world.
This one is definetly one of my favorite!
Pumpkin Oreo omg!!!
Coconut with almond hhmmh
And
Lavender with honeycomb
In housemade waffles.
I tried some others as well.
Each one tasted great.

One woman’s guess on the super-​secret «Sand» flavor: Brown butter ice cream, with chocolate corn flakes. It was good, but I would try something new next time.

I’m just not finding good ice cream, or in general good service on the Cape. The place was empty on a lazy Tuesday, and the servers are very uninterested. I sampled a butter toffee, and I couldn’t order a cone for myself, the taste was coyingly fake. I cleaned my palate with my son’s cookie dough ice cream. Meh. Not feeling it.

Katie’s is hopping!
We stopped by one hot evening and the line was out the door and down to the corner. There’s a good reason for that, Katies is amazing!!! I love the selection of flavors to choose from! Butter Brittle, Peppermint, Mocha Chip, Cape Cod Mud (?), and Cape Cod Sand (??) We were feeling creative so we chose the Cape Cod Sand, it was the flavor of the month for August. My wife chose the peppermint and was very pleased too. I think it’s pretty difficult to find a flavor you wouldn’t like in this place.
As for the line, the staff behind the counter were very organized. The line moved very quickly. My kids quickly spotted some familiar servers behind the counter we served us breakfast earlier in the day at The Daily Paper just down the road. These kids hustle it and work very hard. The line moved fast and we took a seat at one of the tables to enjoy our treats. I went for a full blown sundae with mint chip ice cream and strawberry topping, highly recommended. My son opted for a waffle cone with the Cape Cod Sand and was very pleased too.
We actually had dinner at another restaurant that evening on Main Street and wisely saved room for our walk to Katie’s for dessert. This place is well worth the trip!
If your travelling by car they also have parking behind the building, very helpful on busy Main Street!

I was really blown away by how great this place was. I was a little iffy waiting in line and reading some of the flavors they had because they didn’t look like normal known flavors but the sever who waited on us was great and very helpful she answered questions we had about flavors and even let us sample the one flavor they had called Cape Cod Sand it’s a secret recipe so they can’t tell you what’s in it but you may sample and I’m so happy I did! My boyfriend and I both ended up getting this in their warm freshly made waffle cones! Oooooo it was so tasty and I can’t wait to stop in again next year! PS: pricing was average not outrageously for ice cream at all!

OMG please do not leave here without the chocolate coated waffle cone! They’re fresh and amazing! I never get waffle cones because they are usually a waste of calories but this was worth every last one! The dark chocolate ice cream was fantastic.
My friend has a severe gluten allergy and they gave her ice cream from a fresh batch instead of the existing tub just to avoid any chance of contamination with gluten. That’s excellent service. The salted caramel and vanilla are also incredible. I don’t think there is one bad flavor here!

My girlfriend and I stopped in last night and we were pleasantly surprised by this place. They had a huge variety of homemade ice cream. it was almost overwhelming. There was a long line but they powered through it really quickly. Our server was great no issues there. Don’t bother asking what’s in the cape cod sand because they won’t tell you. It’s their secret recipe. I’m not exactly sure what it is but I would recommend it. Both my girlfriend and I got it was it was incredible. What was even more delicious was the waffle cone. They were served to us freshly made and still warm. The ice cream is slightly above average for the area. The waffle cone was probably one of the best I’ve ever had. I will definitely be coming back next time I’m in Hyannis.

I usually don’t go crazy over ice cream shops because I’m not a fan of ice cream, but I decided to come in here and ordered a snicker’s ice cream. Hands down BEST ice cream ever. The ice cream here is so creamy and so refreshing. I never finish my ice cream, but this was so good. The snickers ice cream had the perfect amounts of peanut butter, chocolate fudge, and caramel. I cannot wait to come back here to try their other flavors. I love that they have a huge selection — lots of original and creative flavors too! They also have a lot of outside seating as well as inside. Perfect summer spot!

I was compelled to write a review because I think the «on site made» ice cream was the best ice cream I have ever tasted. The line was out the door but it was worth the wait! Check it out

Great selection of ice creams. Love that they have dairy free options and gluten free cones! Very cute atmosphere and everything is made in house. Even the whip cream!

AMAZING! The ice cream here is outrageously delicious! The salted caramel tastes like pure caramel, and the twisted tracks is stellar! The décor is adorable too!

The whole family loved it. It was simply delicious and the service was fast and friendly. We will def go back if we are in Hyannis again.

One bite and it was easy to see why Katie’s Ice Cream counter had a line while the neighboring ice cream shops were nearly empty. Sure, there are lots of places in Hyannis offering homemade ice cream, but Katie’s is something special. Possibly the best ice cream I have ever had. EVER. And this is coming from a pregnant lady who eats more than her fair share of ice cream these days. I ordered a scoop of ginger on a sugar cone and my husband ordered a waffled cone filled with sea salt caramel that was on the verge of being something magical.

Cookie dough. Cookies and cream. Combined into one ice cream called the ‘green monster.’ Perfect concoction and wish that more places did this.
Great local spot in Hyannis– stick with the hard ice cream. The frozen yogurt size is trendy, but it’s not what they do best.
Plenty of nice outdoor seats in Main Street.
And don’t be afraid to ask for a sample– I had three before finding my new favorite Green Monster.

DELICIOUS ice cream in a cute shop on Main Street in Hyannis. This appears to be the town favorite, too. There’s a spot right across the street, but no one was there.
Katie’s ice cream (got the salted caramel) is delicious, and the bright pink building lures you in. The outdoor seating begs for you to sit and stay a while as you enjoy your treat.
Everything at Katie’s is made in-​house fresh everyday and tastes like it. Can’t beat that!