Schlabach’s Bakery

All of their products are stellar. Little hole in the wall place but its worth the drive!

I went here two days ago and I make the 45 minute drive every couple of months and every thing is always fresh and DELICIOUS! A younger guy greeted us and answered all of my questions and he had a smile on his face and was very friendly! He made small talk with us and while we were paying the elderly lady baking in the back waved and smiled. Take it from someone who has been coming here for years it will be worth a trip… you will not be disappointed!

stopped by Sat Mar 8(afternoon), great fried pies, good caramel rolls and got a couple loaves of bread that were just ok. Big pie selection that looked great as did the cinnamon rolls.!! Will stop again next time in the area!

Came here no one talked to us or said hi~ that being said the pastries here are some of the best I have ever had. A must if in the country side of Tennessee.

I just finished the zucchini bread that we got on Saturday. It’s a ways down from Country Pantry and without the aid of phone GPS the couple miles seems to stretch out forever but it’s well worth it. We came in about an hour before closing time so a lot of the shelves were pretty bare but we came away with some lemon squares and oatmeal sandwich cookies as well as the zucchini bread. The lemon square was a cool, tart treat that I ate with abandon while driving afraid that it would melt in the high heat. My girlfriend’s oatmeal cookie did in fact start to disintegrate so she managed about half before she put it away. I ate the leftover after I chilled it in the fridge and it was still so tasty, especially after its firmness returned. The zucchini bread though, a combo I never really thought would be good but after having such a delicious piece I didn’t really object when my girlfriend decided to leave it at my apartment. Fresh items like bread from here and cheeses and milk from the Country Pantry up the road is definitely worth the drive.

This Mennonnite-​owned bakery is a must visit whenever we’re in the area. The cinnamon rolls are to die for, as is the homemade bread.

Went for the first time today, we went kinda late though. They were sold out of a lot, that says a lot about the store. Bought the italian cream cake, yummy. We also bought pumpkin cream roll, cherry filled cinnamon rolls, pecan carmel roll. Eating some of that tomorrow. Should go they are closed on saturdays and sundays and the whole month of January also next door is hand built outdoor furniture. We are going back for more when we get our tax returns. Please go won’t be disappointed.

I think that the previous reviewer who gave 2 stars must be a bit unreasonable if they think that this small bakery is able to keep everything sitting out and 100% fresh all of the time. For a smaller place like this, they are doing a great job. I am sure that they make some things ahead of time to make things easier for them and to keep the public happy. Also, the people working today seemed very pleasant and were very welcoming.
Today– 90% of the items were fresh. Some of the pies and cakes were in the cooler, but they all seemed to be custard based (which you would want to be refrigerated).
I bought a nice batch of apple cinnamon rolls for $ 4.95. There was whoopie pies, fried pies, fresh bread, pumpkin rolls, honey, preserves, and a bunch more (the peach bars looked really tempting at .89 each!)
I was impressed that there was a section for day old goods– there were some really tempting bread loaves for $ 1. You can’t beat fresh bread for that price.

My family and I go to this bakery every year during the Holidays. This year we got there right as the store opened. They were taking the cakes out of the freezer and putting them on the shelves. Usually the cakes are fresh. The selection was very poor also. When we asked if there were any fresher cakes the girls working there answered very rudely. They were not nice and friendly like you would expect for a home town bakery.
We did end up buying the cinnamon rolls. The apple filled ones were delicious. The pecans filled ones were ok. Not worth the drive for just the rolls though. Very disappointed in the cake selection and customer service.

Fresh breads, cakes, pies, cookies, cinnamon rolls, pastries, fried pies. We missed the last farmers market and so when we stopped by this tiny bakery, we were very excited to find fresh sourdough bread. We also got a plate of dinner rolls and they were excellent. They have a price list available and the people working there are kind and friendly.
Here’s what we got and the prices we paid:
Apple Butter for $ 3.95
Sourdough Bread $ 2.05
Dinner Rolls $ 2.75
Not taxed either!
We’ll definitely be back.