Gino’s Real New York Pizza

Actually 3.5. Decent but forgettable. Clean and friendly place. Mr PizzaMan says, probably wont return.

This hand tossed pizza crust was light, airy, and crispy. Perfect! We had half pepperoni and half margherita.

We ordered a 20″ with pepperoni mushroom onion and sausage, chef salad. Great food! Definitely very good and good service!

From an original Jersey girl, the pizza here is just like home! The kids loved their calzones, I highly recommend the pizza and overall we give it a 10!

Great NY Style Pizza especially for Myrtle Beach. They also had excellent buffalo wings, the wings were Xlarge not the tiny wings that the chains try to serve you. We are from Central NY and are definitely tough critics. I would highly recommend Gino’s Real NY Pizza.

This is a good pizza place, better than the commercial pizza places and better than most other smaller places. My only big complaint is they use canned mushrooms for their toppings. Ewwww! The dough is good but eat it there unless you want limp moist dough when you get home. The sauce is a good tomato base and the toppings plentiful if you go away hungry then it’s your fault…
I have had the Stromboli which is not consistent between store locations, the one at forest-​brook is huge while the one in garden city is mediocre… I don’t know why the discrepancy but there is… I have not had anything else, so I cannot comment, but if you wanna piece of good not great pizza try Gino’s…

Great NY style pizza, asked them to make it extra thin and extra crispy, we got to watch them hand toss it right then and he got it extra thin and the crust was nice and crispy. We got 5 toppings and it was really good. Made all 4 of us happy, we shared an 18″ pizza and we were all stuffed.

Awesome food and awesome service! Been there a few times now and every time we left stuffed and very satisfied, very good food no matter if you get the pizza or pasta you can’t go wrong awesome service as well

Great pizza overall. Have been looking for true NY style pizza since moving down here and have found it, finally. The pies are normal size for me, 18″. I don’t understand this 16″ nonsense everywhere else. You can also get house size 20″ pies, good for a crowd. Still not as NY as I would like — miss the buffalo chicken pizza, Cajun buffalo chicken, eggplant Parm, salad slices and more I used to get at Carnival and Caffe Amici in NY. Made this a 3 star review because they close relatively early even on weekends, 10pm. And one time after flying back home from a visit to NY I tried to call and order a late dinner at 845 and they told me they closed Bc orders were a bit slow. If you’re going to start practices like that you’re going to lose more customers and I guarantee orders will be even slower! Geesh.

Got a whole Margherita pizza 16′ (small $ 17) and it was great. It had a thin crust with fresh plumped tomatoes, huge patches of mozzarella and spinach.

Awesome pizza! One of the best that I have ever had! Will never order pizza from one of those fast food chains ever again! Love the red sauce!

Great Pizza and sandwiches. Have visited twice while on vacation here and they have not disappointed and the service is great too!

Good, not great, pizza. Did not find the prices reasonable at all, pretty expensive. Delivery was very expensive as well. Coupons once in a while would be nice.
Can’t recommend.

Great food at really reasonable prices. Large portions that will not leave you hungry! This was the best meal deal we had all week on vacation.

Decent pies. Not over priced. New York style pizza which is hard to find around these parts. Staff is friendly no complaints

Pizza was delicious! Tastes like board walk pizza. No leftovers i would recommend this pizza!

Good pizza. We stopped by and ordered a pizza to go. Half pepperoni, half cheese. It was tasty and the sauce was smooth, not chunky. I would get pizza there again.

Ordered the two pizza special but asked to order additional toppings. No problem they said, it is extra 50 cents a slice. The part they left out was that I would loose the special price. Mushrooms were right out of a can but the sausage was good.
My husband ordered a sub and it was good. He asked for fries. They were $ 1.99 extra. He got a small handful of fries for that cost. See picture.