Pudge Bros Pizza

WOW! Crazy to think that this kind of food comes from a pizza joint! Spaghetti, cheeseburgers, wings, calzones, desserts, and of course THE BEST pizza in town! The pizza is so tasty and they have so many great creative options (I’ve come up with my own as well). Nothing but smiles and courtesy with staff on the phone and in person. This is my go to pizza, food, delivery, take out, everything and more place!!!

VERY VERY TASTY!!! I tried Pudge Bros for the first time and was happily surprised at the quality of the food and service! The pizza tasted great and the desserts were awesome, I’m a sucker for cinnamon sticks and cannolies! My order arrived in a timely fashion and more importantly, within the time frame they estimated. Really great selection of menu items and decent pricing for the serving size. I will be ordering Pudge Bros again soon! This place is a can’t miss pizza joint!!!

The food is amazing. Decided to order a few things to try out, everything was delicious and exceeded my expectations. I ordered wings, a pizza, pudgie sticks, the cinnamon sticks, and a calzone and everything was great.
The sticks were hand made and had the best flavor of any side I’ve ordered from a pizza place. The wings certainly contend for the best wings I’ve ordered from any restaurant, including wing specific restaurants. They were cooked well and the flavor was exceptional. The pizza was also very good which also had a very flavorful and well spiced base sauce.
Overall I would rate Pudge Bros as the best pizza place in Fort Collins, even above places like Krazy Karl’s and Pizza Casbah.

Amazing pizza! I have never had cream cheese on a pizza but let me tell you, it’s the best thing ever! I highly recommend a pizza with ranch instead of regular sauce, cream cheese, bacon and jalapeños. You won’t be disappointed. Also had the double bacon cheeseburger which had great flavor, lots of bacon and fresh veggies. Will for sure return for both of these items!

Pudge Brothers… what a name for a smaller pie franchise. It sure seems like a classic stoner go-​to. Perhaps one asks «Hey man, what do you want right now? I’ve got a major case of the munchies.», to which his friend responds: «Pudgies.»
The storefront is pretty old-​school, classic, throwback, pretty much Domino’s-through and through. What I mean is that there are 2 seats to wait for your take-​out. Yet they have a huge kitchen space, almost excessive if you ask me. But they are able to crank out all sorts of dishes – wings, salads, and assorted combinations of dough, cheese, and sauce. But you know what reminds me most of childhood? The 2 liters of coke in the large fridge.
The spinach calzone floored my wife and me. Yeah, the ingredients were simple: tons of butter and spices slathered and dumped onto a thin folded crust, stuffed with salty cheese and some wilted spinach. But the salty cheese made the dish whole. Who doesn’t like a stringy, cheesy, crispy, salty pocket?
No-​frills at Pudge Brothers when it comes to service, food, and pricing… but they seem to be holding their ground in quite the pizza-​centric college scene.

Food was great! new ownership doing a great job, care and passion shows in the presentation. Definitely a great step up for the Fort Collins store. Welcome back pudge bros!!!

Great new owners — we normally pick up. The order is always ready. We tried the New Mediterranean pizza — yummy :)

So I am reviewing all of the pizzerias in Ft. Collins one at a time. This is my first review in this series. All of the other pizzerias I have rated before start with a clean slate and now I will try them all again. I ordered a monster pizza with peperoni and mushroom last night for dinner. I have had Pudge Brothers before in Greeley and Longmont and liked it so thought I would try the Ft. Collins location out. It arrived quicker than promised so that was nice, but I soon realized it was because the crust wasn’t cooked all the way through. The pizza was soggy and blah. The toppings were sparse and not very high quality. Not much sauce either. Overall I would say this was not worth the money. Stay tuned for more pizza reviews coming up soon!

This was the first time I had given Pudge Bros. in Fort Collins a try (I tried them once in Seattle long ago), and aside from a long delivery wait (or at least it felt like it), the food was solid. I’m picky about pizza, having spent most of this life around Chicago, but was pretty happy with the Mediterranean. I’d go to them again.

This is darn good pizza. The best I’ve found in FC that will deliver. The delivery guys are very quick and courteous. The online ordering works great. We’ve only ever had one glitch with it and that was due to the process, not Pudge Bros, but even still the manager gave us some extras to make up for it. I’d say there’s only one other place in town with better pies, but they don’t deliver. Get the deep dish with the original zesty sauce. It’s pretty killer, and will fill you up fast! Pudgie sticks are a good price. My only complaint would be that I’d like to see more topping choices.

Worst pizza I have ever had. After two hours of waiting and calling them 4 times before anyone answered, we finally got the pizza. Thinnest crust I have ever seen, terrible, burnt, thin cheese, by far the worst food I have ever had in my life.

Hardly any toppings and the crust was not good. Stay away.

I decided to try Pudge Bros. after years of not having it. Ordered Blue Cheese for the sauce by accident for the pizza and LOVED IT! Deep dish as well, it was fantastic! Pudge Bros. is my new pizza place from now on.

We ordered Pudge Bros Pizza and were completely disappointed in the service we received. After an hour of not receiving our pizza we called and asked if it had left yet. The person there said it was just coming out of the oven, and would be there shortly. Needless to say, the pizza arrived after 2 hours and was not only cold, but was all squished up in one side of the box.
We called the store back, and they refused to answer (caller id?) so we were forced to call the next day and talk to someone else. The manager the next day said he would talk to the employee that was there at the time, then call us back. He never did call us back.
I then called the corporate number and left a message, and had nobody return my call. Last, I sent an email that is listed on their website and again received no response.
So we spent close to 20 bucks on a pizza that we couldn’t eat, and were offered no compensation and were unable to get our money back.
Avoid like the plague.

Pretty good pizza for its type. That thick-​crusted, delivery style that we all love at reasonable prices (think Dominos, Godfather’s, Little Caesars, etc, but better). Home of the 18″ Monster, this is a great thing to have once in a while. There may be better pizza out there, but this one is still pretty good.