Gigi’s Cupcakes of Fishers

Cake was one thing I was devastated to give up when my doctor told me I had to become gluten free. However, I heard that GiGi’s offered gluten free options and I had to try. The peanut butter chocolate GF cupcake is the BEST cupcake I’ve ever had, even before I was GF! It’s so moist and creamy, I’m hooked! I also love their rewards program — you just use your phone number. 1 point per dollar spent, $ 5 off for every 50 you spend. If you register online, you also get 25 bonus points AND a free cupcake! I would give 5 stars, but sadly when I came on Monday, my cashier was not very nice and I didn’t learn about the rewards program (which would have been nice since I bought several cupcakes!). However, staff was very sweet today!

Cupcakes are okay. I’ve actually gotten ones that at still frozen… I’m also not a fan of the massive amount of icing they use on the cupcakes.
The cheesecakes are yummy for the most part.

Convenient stop to pick up cupcakes for friends. Popular chain with a rotating list of flavors. Cookie dough is my favorite!

Gigi’s has the best cupcakes! We love their cupcakes. I have revised a previous 5 star review that I had placed on this location though because one of the female owners that was working was extraordinarily rude and completely inappropriate as a business owner.
My husband and I had stopped in on a Saturday at approximately 2 in the afternoon to buy 6 cupcakes, a couple for us and some for family as a present. They were almost completely out of all the flavors for the day and had no turtle cheesecake left either. This is not the first or second time we have been in and found they were out of the flavor we went in for. Since we were trying to get enough sweets for several people and they could not accommodate us I decided to speak up this time and suggest they carry more product since they are habitually out of certain cupcakes early in the day on a saturday. The owner that was working at the time was very rude and snapped at me that I should call ahead to place an order and they would try and have it ready. Seriously? I don’t call ahead to the grocery store and ask them to carry milk! I mean if you are a cupcake shop, you should have cupcakes. I told her that wasn’t good customer service and we left. The other female owner though is very nice and has actually went to the back and made a turtle cheesecake when they were out previously. She is super nice and accommodating. Too bad she has to partner with someone who clearly needs to take lessons from her in customer service!
I decided after that encounter to revise my previous review because she was so rude. Well, beware if you post an honest review about this business! She posted back that we should never come in again and shop elsewhere. All because I asked for more cupcakes! lol Talk about moody! Apparently that wasn’t enough because she also private messaged me a rude and nasty message which I wasn’t going to respond to. Well she has since removed her nasty comments which is why I am updating this review.
It’s too bad that business owners have forgotten to be polite and friendly to the people that keep you in business. I am the type of person that would pay more to go somewhere where the environment is appealing rather than save a dime and have poor customer service. We drove 20 minutes and went in to another bakery to get what we needed and they were super nice and friendly!
One of the funny things is that she ranted and raved about how they bake fresh daily and when they are out they are out. Well, according to another review that isn’t true or people wouldn’t be getting partially frozen cupcakes!

Tiny cupcakes, mile-​high frosting. Sort of the McDonald’s of the whole cupcake trend. Pretty forgettable.

Do you like icing? If not, stop reading immediately. Gigi’s cupcakes are piled high with icing, and that is not a bad thing (unless you’re one of those freaks of nature who are all «Oh nooooo, my cake has TOO MUCH FROSTING!»). My fave is the White Chocolate Midnight Magic cupcake — chocolate cake, cream cheese icing and a metric ton of mini chocolate chips. Gigi’s is definitely on the «sometimes food» list (TM Cookie Monster), but if you’re up for a caloric splurge, you can’t go wrong here.

Delicious cupcakes in a variety of exciting flavors! Every cupcake I have purchased from Gigi’s has been delicious. The location is sometimes hard to get in and out of during rush hour, so I suggest mom peak times. However, the cute store makes up for it! Come in, try a cupcake and have a seat! I’m sure you’ll want more before you leave.

Gigiiiiiiiiii!!! The guilty pleasure of my family, their cupcakes are huge and filling. Great Gluten-​Free options, making this one of our only available options for baked treats. Worth the treat with a glass of milk if a cupcake is what you’re craving, sad to see that the cupcake industry is a fading fast.

The place is always clean, but as far as the cupcakes go, I prefer The Flying Cupcake to Gigi’s. Staff here is super friendly, though. More stars for less icing.

The place over all is really cute, staff member was fairly nice. As far as the cupcakes themselves… nothing special in my opinion. They «look» cute and pretty but there is a massive amount of frosting that is entirely way to sweet and over powers the entire cupcake. Not to mention the 3 cupcakes we purchased to try were all very dry and kind of lacking over all flavor. Was really excited to try this place because I have a sweet tooth every once in awhile, but was disappointed. My search continues!

I love cupcakes and Gigi’s is the nearest cupcake shop to where I live. I would have to say that the cupcakes can be hit or miss, but when it’s a hit, it’s really good. The icing usually tastes better than the cake, and there is no shortage of icing on these cakes! However it’s not overly sweet. There are several flavors and the menu is different each day. The hubby and I will often get one each and split them in order to try different flavors. I think it’s about finding the flavor (s) that you like.
I recommend: strawberry shortcake, double stuff, wedding cake, banana pudding
Do not recommend: salted carmel, red velvet, carrot cake and the chocolates (midnight magic and white midnight magic) are nothing special

The décor was quite cute. I tried the cheesecake, a bit dry and the icing was very sweet. I rarely do care for icing on my cakes… I also tried the chocolate cake cupcake… The cake was pretty good, to me had a taste of maybe gingerbread/​chocolate… I did like it. Funny my kids are icing experts and they told me they did not like the icing. This is coming from a 5 year old boy… but you could not tell by the way he was licking the hell out of the icing. I was surprised to how busy the place became. Would I come back? I don’t know.

The cupcakes are tasty. However, I have been to this location twice… and both times they are out of the cupcake I want. And, they usually have one or two left of other varieties. It’s usually mid afternoon when I go and they don’t close until later so I think it’s ridiculous that they don’t have a few of each kind on their menu. Reduce the menu if you aren’t going to offer them all day. At 3.25 a cupcake, I just think it better be darn good. I’d say they are good but I’m going to try a different place next time… or make my own for a lot cheaper!

SELECTION: I went with a group of 8 people at 6pm, they’re open until 8pm. They had *very* little selection and surely were sold out before 8pm. Mainly they had wedding cake (vanilla) and midnight magic (chocolate). There were two red velvet and two cookies and cream, we knocked those out. There was no cheesecake. Selection was very slim.
DECOR: sparse — others describe it as girly, but it’s really quite plain. There is a fair amount of pink., but that’s the end of girly. The cupcakes are all nice looking.
SERVICE: The employees working did not seem happy to see us. They moved us through reasonably well. Another large group came in behind us and several more singles or couple while we were eating. A long line developed and there was limited selection. We saw people wait for a bit and leave without buying anything.
PRODUCT: Everything was good, but nothing was exceptional. The cakes are small, dry, and unexceptional. There is an enormous amount of icing and the icing is tastier than the cake.

Not impressed. The cake itself is bland, and they cover it up with a ridiculous amount of frosting. No thanks.

Yum is an understatement. If these treats don’t entice you at first glance – highly doubtful, the smell will definitely take you captive. Gigi’s Cupcakes is the perfect place to treat yourself, friend or loved one for Valentine’s Day. Or heck, who needs an excuse to snack on a cupcake? Just go get one!
You may have spotted Gigi’s Cupcakes Trucks, Scarlet and Pinky, cruising on the road. I know I have! Turns out they cater events and deliver too. Gigi’s also bakes various, fresh cupcakes everyday. How pleasant! So if you are itching for your favorite you may want to call first to make sure your treat is in stock. You can also order online.
Oh, and don’t plan on biting your cupcake first. You definitely need a fork for those babies. For those you who don’t like tons of icing they also have mini cupcakes. Or just scrap it off, either way you won’t be disappointed. Gigi’s also has Gluten-​Free Fridays! Each Friday they serve three gluten-​free cupcakes including Birthday Surprise, White Hot Chocolate and Wedding Cake. Many of their stores are offering other gluten-​free cupcakes regularly too. Neat! OMG it was so delicious I want to go back for more.

Awwww, the cupcake trend. It’s not going away is it? They just keep popping up! And they are even chains! Did you know that Gigi’s is a chain? I had no idea until very recently and for some reason, this turns me off.
Anyway…besides that they are definitely A-​OK. They are WAY (and I mean WAY) over-​iced. The balance is way off. The cake is good, moist and delish (even a day later) but the icing is just too much for one person to bear (IMO).
The price is also a bit high for my liking… although I think anything over $ 2.00 is a bit much for a two inch by two inch dessert.
However, I am a big fan of cupcakes as a perfect gift for a new mama and will get these again if I am in a pinch. They are beautiful and overall, very tasty.
I do agree that service is on the slower, casual side. They are not in a hurry at all and usually do not help more than one person at a time even if there are two people working.

I LOVE a good cupcake. I DREAM about cupcakes.
I tried Gigis at Keystone years ago and claimed that the amount of frosting to cupcake ratio was disgusting. So I didn’t go back… Until they came to Fishers.
And I still think that the amount of frosting is a little over the top, but I just scrape some off and they are delicious! They have about a dozen flavors everyday. Many interesting combinations and different daily special cupcakes, but I love the everyday ones best. The midnight magic has the best chocolate icing that I’ve ever had. The wedding cake and chocolate mint are delicious. The cake is fresh and moist — baked daily.
The owner is often there and is very friendly.
They do have trouble keeping the cupcakes in stock all day. I brought my son for his 1^st bday, only to find out that they were out of any/​all kid friendly cupcakes. At 6:00pm… I guess it’s best to go before 4pm if you want selection. And they close so early. They would easily have customers until 9 if they were open, but they close at 7pm on weeknights & 8pm!!! on weekends, and rarely have many cupcakes that late anyway.
And they don’t have any highchairs. Maybe they think children under 3 aren’t interested in cupcakes, but I really don’t like to hold my 1 yr old while he eats a cupcake and smears it all over my clothing. Seriously!!! GET SOME HIGHCHAIRS!!!

I walked into Gigi’s colorful store and gazed into the display cases full of delicious and beautifully decorated cupcakes. Unfortunately, despite being 3^rd out of 3 in line, after a wait of 15 minutes, I was ONE person closer to getting a cupcake. This was with TWO people working! The person working the counter was helping a customer and, as a line formed, she called someone from the back. They both then proceeded to socialize with the same one customer! After 15 minutes, we walked out. I should also note, four more customers came in, saw the wait and poor service, and left.
I am sure Gigi’s Cupcakes are good. they looked great. it is too bad they have no interest in actually selling them.

The staff is always helpful and friendly.
The store is «girly,» cute.
The cupcake variety is fun and worth the try but the icing is a bit much. I recommend sharing with a friend!