Casa Pizza Italian and Greek Cuisine

Ok, a bit confused on the high ratings on this place. I always love to give a place the benefit of the doubt, to experience the service/​food and see for myself what it’s like. Upon arrival, the cashier just looked at me, no greeting, and at that moment of split second stare down, the phone rang, which she picked up. Ok, no excuse me, whatever. Call must have been personal because she spoke in Spanish but ended with an English «I love you.» Now off the phone, still no acknowledgement, so I SAY, «Good afternoon» and placed my order. Needless to say, the wait time was decent (15 minutes), the small 2 topping pepperoni pizza with pineapple was mediocre, and the $ 3 Baklava was unfortunately stale. I’ve actually had better pizza from Little Caesar’s. Perhaps this was an off day for them…

One of my favorite pizza places in El Paso. The pizza is delicious and the prices are fair. The salads are huge and the pastrami subs are delicious.

I have been to Casa Pizza five times and ordered delivery once.
The house red wine by the glass is sweet table wine.
The first time we had dinner here we ordered off menu items for our pizza. They kindly obliged with a vegi pizza that included Spinach, feta, fresh garlic and Greek olives.
This is always the best place for pizza in EP.
Inexpensive. Unpretentious. Better food than Grimaldi’s at half the price!

Tried this place last night for dinner we shared a small pepperoni and mushroom pizza & lasagna my husband heard alot of good things about this place and
he was a little disappointed that is wasnt how it was described, but the food was good we are looking forward to going back to try the rest of their dishes. The only complaint i have is not getting a refill in a timely mannor but not a deal breaker.

I LUV Casa Pizza. It’s the only restaurant where I have a hard time deciding what to order. Everything is delicious. Salads, subs, pizza, gyros and more. Their house dressing is one of a kind. Highly recommend it.

Do not order here if your are hungry. The deliver time is completely outrageous. And when you call after an hour to check on the status don’t expect to be greeted kindly. She was rude and told me the ‘delivery guy left a long time ago’. NEVER AGAIN! And the house special pizza came cold and the crust was soggy. Talk about disappointment. We had to re-​cook the pizza.

My wife and I are picky about pizza. I tend to like a thicker crust and she likes a thinner crust, so we do a lot of searching for a good pie that is somewhere in between. This place is it.
We ordered a pepperoni and mushroom for me and a plain for her. Both pies were great. The thickness was right where it appeased both of us. Their sauce was flavorful but not overwhelming, it was again delicious and perfect. They put a good amount of toppings on the pies and I felt I got my money’s worth.
We stayed at a local hotel so we didn’t see the actual restaurant and simply ordered delivery. My wife called to place the order and the young girl who answered was a little snotty and the phone connection was somehow lost. We thought that maybe some of the poor reviews about service were true. My wife called back and a gentleman answered and was a true professional. He promised the order in 45 minutes. Being that it was dinner time and there was weekday rush hour traffic we understood. We were totally surprised when the order arrived in 25 minutes and the pizza was so hot we couldn’t eat it right away.
I will definitely without a doubt use this pizzeria again.

Best antipasto salad I’ve ever had! It was big, the lettuce was fresh, and there was PLENTY of meat and cheese all the way to the bottom.

I just ordered a corned beef sandwich and the recommendation of another Unilocaler along with a Greek salad. When they delivered, they didn’t bring the salad. The driver said he left it in the car and took off. I called and whoever answered said that he didn’t bring it at all and it would be a while. It is going on 2 hours. The sandwich was cold and all the melted cheese stuck to the aluminum foil. I would not recommend this place!!!

Terrible service! Stopped in on my lunch hour. No one welcomes or acknowledges you when you enter. A worker in the back looks right at me, then goes on doing whatever she was doing. No one comes to seat me or to let me know if I should seat myself. I finally decided to go sit at a table and waited for someone to give me a menu and take my order. No one ever showed up. I got up and left, hoping I had enough time to go somewhere else ro pick up lunch. And, no, it was not very busy at the time. They obviously don’t care about their customers. Never again!

Just left the restaurant… it’s very small and not in the best shape needs some upgrades for sure. The pizza was ok it had good amount of ingredients for the price and the salad was large enough to be split by us a family of four. Unfortunately the service was terrible!!! Our server gave us our beer. unopened so we had to use a lighter to pop the top… once we got our food she sat at the booth next to us to eat her meal and talk on the phone !!! I actually heard her blow kisses to whoever she was talking to. Extremely rude and unprofessional. We will Never be back there again. Save your money it’s not worth it.

The meatball sub and chef salad are delicious! We ordered our food to go and still had a lady and gentleman ask if we would like anything to drink and what not while we waited.

Good pizza, nice people, but call ahead, we waited almost 45 mins for our pizza after we walked in and ordered… on a Tuesday night.

When I worked nearby I ate here 3 times a week. Now 24 years later I made the trip back. To my joy it has not changed a bit. The cozy place with delicious food. My all time favorite was and is still the hot pastrami. The gyro is as good as I remember. I didn’t have chance to try another fave — the spaghetti with Italian sausage. Like everything else prices are a bit higher but still reasonable. This is a truly great lunch stop so make the effort. It is highly recommended. Worth a trip next door or across town.

I am always weary of any restaurant that combines the cuisine of different nations under one roof. However I’m lazy and this place is close to my apartment. So I decided to give it a try. So glad that I did. The veggie pizza is amazeballs. It was hot, fresh and perfect. I’ve found my first favourite restaurant in El Paso.

Place sucks ordered delivery, got meat lovers, and spaghetti and meatballs. Came with two small meatballs, sucks sauce and the pizza was ok just ok. Never ordering there again

Had a pizza special and it was delicious! Can’t wait to go back to try something else.

Holy bejeezus — that was the best veggie pizza I’ve ever had in my life. The freshness and quality of the ingredients were evident on the trip home when the smell was making me salivate.
It was a big hit with the family — picking the cheese off the box. Gourmet quality pizza.
Note: as of 9÷6÷14 the prices on the website are incorrect. Call for details, I suppose.

Everything was very good. They brought it to my hotel within the time frame and it was a very good meal. The Greek plate is a good amount of food. The pizza that was delivered was just as good with ingredients that were fresh and not old like some other places. If I’m in El Paso again I would order from there again.

Best pizza in town hands down. I’m from Boston and this is as good as it gets here in El Paso. Has lots of cheese and oil. Yum! They have great salads as well. I love the Greek salad!