Two Brothers Bar

I was in Edgerton this morning (Sat Jan 16) for business and brought along my wife and daughter. After concluding the business venture, we shopped at a few places (despite the cold) and ended up at Two Brothers for lunch.
My daughter, the vegetarian ordered a grilled cheese. My wife ordered the Portabella burger and a cup of vegetable beef soup, while I ordered the Gyro with extra meat (I’m still no carbing). Oh and we ordered the fried green beans as a starter.
Fried green beans came out right away and were very good — not overly battered and very tasty.
The soup arrived next but didn’t have any meat in it (vegetable beef). My wife mentioned it to the waitress who brought out another bowl filled with beef (prime rib at that). The ‘cup’ of soup is huge BTW.
The grilled cheese got a big thumbs up as it has plenty of cheese and the bread was grilled with a good amount of butter.
The Portabella burger was outstanding featuring two large mushrooms.
Now for the Gyro. First off, they cut it from a spit so it’s nice and fresh (no frozen lamb here). The pieces they cut for me were the largest, thickest pieces of gyro meat I have ever eaten.. And it was cooked to perfection — nice and juicy.
I did not need to order extra meat but since I did, I had a ton left over (and I had it for dinner this evening during the Packer-​Cardinal playoff game).
The bathrooms were nice and clean as well.
I was very impressed with this bar/​restaurant and will definitely be back.

prime rib sandwich fries and curds all great. Good service, good food cold beer. You can’t beat it.

We were just passing through the area on a road trip and needed a good dinner. It was 8:30pm and several places I looked at closed by 9. 2 Brothers had good reviews and stayed open late so we stopped in. The waitress/​bartender was so very friendly.
Food was good, we had a group of 4 people. Two had burgers, one had the fish sandwich, and I had the fajita steak wrap. My wrap had tons of tender steak chunks in it, the fries were fresh and hand cut. Tons of beer on tap so hubby was pleased. No complaints here. The prices were also very reasonable.

Great place for a beer and burger! Love the fresh cut fries. Great location. Great place to watch a game.

Very good fish fry. Gotta get there early or you’ll be waiting. It’s worth the wait though. Not many seats and the old people in town get there early. You get 2 very large pieces of cod. Worth the time and money.

My favorite bar in Edgerton. The Friday fish fry is the best, the fish comes out looking like a churro but it is awesome! Plus the cole slaw is to die for.

Best Friday night fish fry in the area (and I am particular). They serve the walleye filet whole, the batter is light and crispy, not greasy at all. I would like to see a larger variety of fish on their menu, like perch and bluegill, but after being served the best walleye I’ve ever had, I’m not sure I’d order anything else anyway. Great service and clean bar.

Best bar in downtown Edgerton for food. I personally love the nachos. Used to be second best til Emigail’s stopped doing nachos, now Two Brothers owns the nacho market. The Steak sandwiches are huge, and usually they have them on special one of the days of the week which makes them an absolutely steal. Very solid.

Good tasty burger. Decent selection of craft brews. Cheese curds were good and squeaky just like they should be. The star of the show was the prime rib sandwich ordered by another member of the party.
Oh. My. Lawd.
I was really wanting a tasty burger at the time and a steak sandwich just didn’t sound good. Then I saw it. I was expecting some thin slices of steak on a roll with an au jus. I was NOT expecting a slab of meat twice the size of the roll served with an au jus, and this wasn’t exactly a small roll.
Service was a bit on the slow side. May have only been the one server on duty on Saturday mid-​afternoon, because she was always moving. The beer garden was also a nice place to sit on the gorgeous day we were there.

Best burgers in Edgerton — maybe in Southern WI! Fresh cut fries that are hot, crisp and delicious. The atmosphere is pretty good too — typical bar atmosphere with bar seating and tables in a partially separated room. The only drawback for us is that all of the seats are pub height which makes it tough for some of our older family members.
Everything we have gotten here has been great, the salads are big with large fresh peices; the fish is good too. Service is great, it can be slow at times due to being busy.

Do yourself and favor and try their BLT Wrap or the Brooklyn Burger. Yum! Quick service, friendly waitresses and good food!

Excellent service & fabulous food! Highly recommend this pub! Portions are generous. If you enjoy sports, this is the place to go, tons of flat screens all over.

I just moved to Edgerton about a year ago and I don’t know too many people. This is the only bar in town that I don’t feel weird going to. I“ve tried others, but I swear I don’t get very good service because I am not one of «the regulars.» Their wraps are really good, especially the buffalo chicken. They usually have at least a few microbrews on tap, which I like. There can be a lot of Bears and Cubs fans there for some reason.

Very cool place to hang out! The waitstaff was friendly! Best bar in town… They have karaōke, DJ’s, and bands play throughout the week. They also have a Juke box if there’s no one playing. Small dance floor but do-​able. The manager is always running around trying to say hi to friends. The food is delicious!!! Diverse menu… Drinks are fantastic!!! good prices!!!

Best bar in Edgerton, hands down. Great food, tiki bar, 2 pool tables, and plenty of big screens to watch the game!