Papa Stelio’s Pizza House

When «that’ll be 20 – 25 minutes» becomes an hour and a half is ok, I’ll go back. Hint, when you forget an order, don’t tell me I must have called the other location even after I show you my call history. Good thing there are a dozen other pizza places around.

Me and my boyfriend have always gone to Vikings, since I love Greek pizza places and we live in the center of town. My friend always told me to go to Stelios but I had heard bad things and, like an idiot, I never ate there. THEN I DID. Best chicken salad sub around. The bread is so freaking fresh I could sleep on it. Curly fries you can bring home to your little sister. I intend to be a regular.
They did forget the lettuce on my boyfriend’s sub but I order things super complicated style and talk like a freak so I can understand making a mistake here and there. I hold no grudge.

I’ve eaten here a few times recently. The food is fairly good, pizza is similar to the style of Papa Gino’s, Greek salad is great — though I received a different dressing each time I ordered (the creamy greek is better).
I docked this review two stars because when I ordered from the online menu and came into the store, I was informed that the menu prices online were at least 8 years old and that they should be disregarded. Why a business in this day and age can disregard updating their website, when it would take minutes, is frustrating and poor business practice.

I have never had a bad meal from Papa Stelios. We discovered it the first day we moved to East Bridgewater and it has been at the top of our places to eat when we want pizza or subs.
Everyone who is there is always so nice and accommodating. I have never had any issues and I always get my good rather quickly.
This place will continue to be one of my favorite places to eat from and will be my go to place!

I work down the street from Papa Stelio’s in East Bridgewater. I love their Greek Salad, it’s so good. Also their pita bread seems better and fresher than I am ever able to find in a grocery store, so I’m assuming they have someone make it. The staff is very friendly and Rita’s baked goods are so delicious. She made a sponge type cake one time, that was to die for. Thankfully she doesn’t make that every day or I would be addicted to it.

I have eaten here multiple times. Have always gotten good service, and they usually have it quick, no matter how little time I give them to make it. I’ve had subs, pizzas, and other such stuff in the past. It is a pizza shop after all!!! :-) I would definitely go back.

Papa Stelio’s in East Bridgewater is the ONLY «Greek style» pizza place that I will eat at. Actually, when our family wants «pizza shop» takeout– this is it. Their pizzas are an art form, and their ingredients are incredibly fresh. The owners, Rita and Michael, and their family, are dedicated to their business. Right down to the way each ingredient is cut and prepared, and for whatever dish they are preparing. Most of the produce is organic… Unbelievable!
Nothing is processed food. Everything is made from scratch, and with love. Homemade Baklava sits atop the counter, staring you in the face! It is amazing and delicious, and Rita often will make different Greek pastries depending on the season or holiday. Right down to the sub rolls, which come fresh from a small local bakery, everything is fresh, and you can taste it. I would encourage everyone to come to East Bridgewater and befriend Rita and her staff while having delicious food made from the heart!