Tony’s Pizza

Bad pizza. Bad service. Ashley is a train wreck. Pizza was soggy and floppy. I’ve never seen such a poorly managed pizza place.

There’s only one other pizzeria in the world I’ve ever given 5-​stars to and that place is the standard by which I judge all other pizzas. That’s a Brooklyn thin crust on the Lower East Side. Tony’s does it. Congratulations my friend!

Stopped in for two slices while a big event was going on in downtown. A slice of Pepperoni and a slice of cheese with a bottle of water to go. Service was quick and with in minutes of placing our order two hot and delicious pizza slices were ready.
I have to say again, the service at Tony’s was super fast even though downtown was packed by the time we ordered. Prime time lunch crowd was gathering tempted by the smell of garlic, melted mozzarella cheese and dough.
We took our slices to-​go and walked down the street. Stopping at some park benches, we sat down to enjoy our slices of pizza. If I could eat pizza every day, it would be Tony’s pizza. They serve their pizza thin crust New York style and we wouldn’t have it any other way!
Fast and friendly service with awesome New York style pizza, Tony’s is the best pizza joint in Dunedin without a doubt!

Excellent food! Excellent service. It’s a very small place with not many tables, we have always been lucky enough to get a table. We have eaten in and taken out pizza, calzone, fried mozzarella, garlic knots, and draft beer. Everything has been outstanding. They are pretty quick for made to order food, everything is always fresh and so delicious. We love many places in Dunedin, but this is one of our favorites. It’s like a NY style pizza joint located in a beachfront paradise and at a very reasonable price.

Grabbed a slice today while strolling through Dunedin. Pretty standard fare, not bad, not great. Pretty average.

Tiny storefront pizzeria with classic NY style pizza. Prices are super reasonable and this place can’t be beat for a quick bite. You can sit in the window and people watch tpurists.
Thileir white pizza is sauce less and has ricotta and mozzarella. I like a cheese slice best but would order a white again too.

This is the second time we’ve ordered takeout from Tony’s pizza, and both times, they have been spot on.
The pizza is delicious, perfectly baked and good proportions of topping to pizza. We also got the Greek Salad which was exactly what you’d expect and nice and refreshing and the Chicken Wings, which were perfectly crispy on the outside and juicy on the inside.
Overall, this is EXACTLY what we look for in a takeout pizza place. And it was perfect.

The key here is to stay the hell away from the joint when the bars are closing because it’s a shitshow! During regular daytime hours, this place is calm and mild-​mannered in comparison to the rambunctious and raucous 2 – 3 AM crowd. So if you enjoy good NY style pizzer and wanna enjoy it in peace, then heed my word.
Tony’s serves us proper slices from a yuuuge 18″ pie, the way it outta be. Nothing worse than these so-​called NY style pizzerias out here serving slices from 16″ pies. That shit is wack, son.
Enough on that though. My favorite feature is that they use Grande cheese, which for the one or two Unilocal stalkers I have know, is very important. How do I know? Because places who use Grande do not conceal the brand of their cheese. They mount a big-​ass Grande Cheese 100 Percenter plaque on their wall for folks like me, who recognize the real shit.
Downsides to Tony’s? The don’t deliver and they bake their pizzas on screens. totally not necessary with Baker’s Pride ovens.

Went there on Tuesday two weeks ago around 7pm. We knew the pizza was always good. Walked in and waiter up front was on his cell phone squeezing in our order with his cell conversation.
Sat down in the restaurant and noticed numerous tables were still dirty and the floor was unswept. It took a little bit to get our slices. Waiter brought our food while still on his cell phone. By the end of our meal, the tables still were not cleaned up nor floor swept. We were never offered refills or asked how the pizza was.
We’ve ate there quite often and this was probably the worst experience we’ve ever had. The help was not focused on customer service or taking care of the restaurant. Guess they had other things in their mind.

Horrible! Selling to the walk-​in crowd with no focus in quality. Dry and only a few scattered mushrooms w/​dirt-​dry crust. Unless desperate, move on!

It’s like a little slice of New York right on Dunedin’s Main Street. It’s a tiny storefront with pizza by the slice, fresh out of the oven. Can’t go wrong here.

The floor was dirty, I had to clean the table myself, and the trash can was full… looks like management must not be around. I have had better experiences here look tonight just was bad. The pizza was greasy the fries seemed like they were made with old oil and nobody seems to be picking up the trash on the floor or clearing off the tables.
Overall I have noticed in a lot of places that I visit that the people working there don’t really bust axx. This is no exception. Good before training, could before management, we could be that management is gone so everybody is not giving a darn.

Good pizza in a prime location for an after drinking fix. I want to give a 3.5 star but since that’s not an option…
I like the pizza, I really do, but I just like other pizza places better. Nothing wrong here though — a good heart slice from the oven is hard to beat, and super fast to boot!
Always good service and friendly banter while we wait.

Best pizza by the slice in town! So good I talked myself into a second slice! It’s a great place to stop in for a quick bite when walking around downtown if you dont want to wait for any of the surrounding restaurants.

A step above most places of this genre. I’m from the NYC metro area, and this pie is quite at home on my palate.
I ordered two slices of the meatlover’s which was fresh out if the oven.
Mangia!

Came in for a quick bite on Halloween after hanging out at the bar across the street and I was very impressed with the pizza here. My only complaint would be the tables aren’t checked and cleaned in between customers (bc God forbid a customer actually cleans up after themselves) and there isn’t a lot of seating. Other than that, the pizza was very good & I would drive from Holiday to Dunedin just to eat pizza from this restaurant.

This pizza place is exceptional! A great mix of fresh everything seasoned just right. My wife had the veggie and meat lovers pizza and I the garlic ricotta and mozzarella, also meat lovers and found this to be of five star quality! We will frequent this establishment! Great waitstaff
And chefs! A hidden jewel! Don’t pass up this delectable family restaurant!

Gone to this place with friends after bar hopping around Dunedin area. The staff were all smile and amazing. Very knowledgeable with there stuff.
And there’s arts hanging around the wall for the costumers to see and if they want, they can purchased this arts.
Nice combination of local dining and art gallery!

Staff are super friendly and fast to help with what you need. I tried te plain cheese but I’m going to go back for white! The toppings and napkins are preset on the table and the food is absolutely fresh and delicious. I always enjoy coming here for a hot and fresh slice while bar hopping! Come check it out!

Located in Downtown Dunedin.
Walked the main drag. Came back to Tony’s in order to get a quick bite.
Pizza was very good. It’s a small joint. Not much seating. But we did manage to find a seat for 4 in the back.
Service was very friendly.