The Sweet Tooth Fairy

I had a bogo cupcake coupon, so I decided to give them a try, and I’m glad I did! I usually don’t but cupcakes, because I prefer to make them at home, but if my cravings are ever too impatient, I wouldn’t hesitate to drop by the Sweet Tooth Fairy for that quick fix. The store is adorable, but I wasn’t expecting much as the presentation of the baked goods was not very impressive. I got the Oreo and the peanut butter cupcake, and I loved them both! The cakes were perfectly moist and the frosting was deep flavor but light in texture. I liked that the frosting fluffy enough to compliment the soft texture of the cake. These cupcakes are not the most extraordinary cupcakes you’ll ever have, but they’re simple cupcakes done well.

Yummmm cupcakes here are so good! They have a great selection, and yummy bars and cookies as well! I was definitely impressed with the quality and price! Will definitely be coming back. Red velvet is great, strawberry shortcake is alright, carrot cake cupcake is delicious! Can’t wait to go back for more :)

The cupcakes from here are so amazing!!!
My favorite one is the peanut butter cup. The cake is so moist and the frosting is to die for. Love this place!
Also, they won cupcake wars which is a pretty big deal if you ask me. Highly recommended

I am not usually a great cupcake person but when my wife wanted a cupcake today I obliged of course but in my mind I was still skeptical. Being a foodie, I watch food network channel quite a bit and little did I know that on a lazy Saturday afternoon, that I would actually be stepping into a food network’s cupcake show winner’s shop and the place did not disappoint and actually ended up changing my perception of cupcakes to point that I actually ended up liking it and cleaned my cupcake faster than my wife. The ambience was light and airy and very easy on eye visually and makes one feel very welcome and to add to that their bright and vivid cupcake displays seemed to give the place a sort of fun feel. The cupcakes were top notch especially their Oreo as well as chocolate chip cookie dough cupcakes and I would also recommend getting their cake bites which were light and airy as well as delicious.
Definitely go here and you won’t be disappointed
Definitely a 5 star rating from me for this cupcake place.

I LOVE this place. Their cake bites are one of the yummiest things I have ever tasted. Ever. The coconut, lemon, and fairy-​fetti are especially delicious! Great service-​friendly and efficient employees who truly have customer satisfaction as a priority. I have been going to Sweet Tooth Fairy since it opened and have always been satisfied.

Great food! Darling atmosphere! I just wish the prices were more reasonable. They don’t update their website, so you never know what the cupcake of the month is — which is important because if what you crave isn’t on that list, you have to have a minimum order of a dozen, and then you’re back to the price problem.

I went here for some dessert after eating lunch at zuppa’s next-​door. I got the Samoa cookie, a sugar cookie, and a free vanilla cupcake filled with Bavarian cream that they offer on Fridays if you mention America first credit union. The Samoa cookie wasn’t amazing around the edges but the center portions were pretty tasty. The sugar cookie was great, especially if you like amaretto. The vanilla cupcake was divine. The prices are okay for what you get. A great stop after lunch or dinner!

This little shop is quaint and has a decent selection of cupcakes and cake bites. The presentation of their award winning cupcakes are nice and everything is frosted to perfection. For me, however, I just think they are too sweet for my taste. I can only take a couple bites before I feel like I’ve reached my sugar intake levels for the week. The cake portion is very moist which I like, but I rarely ever eat the frosting as its too overpowering for me.

Sweet Tooth Fairy honestly isn’t my favorite bakery but it’s really close to where I live. The cupcakes are OK, the cake is a little dry and too much frosting for my taste.
They have monthly flavors which is nice to change up their regular menu. My favorite item is the cakebites which come in a ton of flavors.
They also have cinnamon rolls during the fall which are good.
Service is always great.

I’ve been once and got a box of them as presents before so this is going to be a review based on those. So far, the cake bites are my favorite, especially the oreo and red velvet ones. Mmmm! I will say that they’re pretty pricey at $ 1 a pop but try making them at home and you’ll realize these pops are hard to make.
I also had a chance to try the apple one which I didn’t like the flavor so much. Overall, the décor and inside is very nice and fancy like. It reminds me of a french kitchen and there’s little chairs to sit at to hang. Just don’t go in droves with a group because you’ll be sitting far away from each other.

Had coupon that’s why I went. First impression, everything looked very yummy and well displayed. Got a strawberry shortcake and salted Carmel cupcake. Strawberry one tasted doughy like it was under baked. Frosting was thick and too much on the sweet side. It wasn’t a fluffy moist cake like I was hoping for, haven’t ate the Carmel one but I’m sure it has the same issue. good thing it only costed me $ 2 I wouldn’t pay more unless quality improves. Definetly looked better than it tasted.

My coworkers would kill for a cupcake from Sweet Tooth Fairy but they would probably do the same for a Snickers bar. Anyhow, STF is a great place to visit for dessert but I wish they had a better beverage selection to accompany their sweets. Fridays are «America First» days so mention their name and you get a free simple America First cupcake regardless of whether you purchase anything or not.

Love this place. We have never had a bad cupcake flavor yet. Some of our favorites are fairyfetti, rootbeer, chocolate mint, we could go on and on. They are so moist and filling. The décor in these shops are so cute and adorable, I simply love the mini chandaliers. the gals behind the counters are always friendly and patient. Great for a birthday dessert or just any old day. :)

Delicious! I was going to buy 4, but got talked into a half dozen. There was a special, making it cost the same… basically like getting 2 for free. We got 5 flavors: (1) red velvet — delicious with very fresh and tasty icing, (2) salted caramel — moist cake, but the icing was almost too sweet… like hurt your teeth sweet, (3) peanut butter cup — chocolate cake (probably the same as for the salted caramel) with a delicious peanut buttery icing. This was my personal favorite. And (5) root beer float. I have no idea how it was done, but this cupcake seriously tasted just like root beer! The icing was a creamy/​root beer-​cream cheese hybrid. This was my husbands favorite. In all, we were not disappointed. And for gourmet cupcakes, you can’t beat the price! We paid $ 10 for 6 with the special they had. We don’t live in the area, and it’s a good thing, because if we did I can see how swinging by the Sweet Tooth Fairy could easily become a near-​daily tradition! Too delicious!

I’ve tried their cupcakes a few times, thinking that each time it might be better… but no. For example, the lemon cupcake I had was extremely dense & wet. The frosting was good, but cupcakes are about the cake as well as the frosting!

Came here on a HOT day after work with my classmate/​roommate for a sweet treat. The girl behind the counter was so friendly and patient with us as we stared at the vast array of choices! I had a sample of their cinnamon cake bite and it was yummy but those littel things are overpriced! $ 1 each isn’t worth it since they are so small. They’re cute and might look nice in a box as a gift for someone with a sweet tooth, but I wouldn’t buy it for myself.
My friend got the ice cream sandwich — you get to pick any 2 cookies and they put a bit of vanilla ice cream in between (not enough in my opinion… it was more like 2 cookies with a tiny layer of ice cream in the middle than a true ice cream sandwich).
I ordered a small oreo cheesecake (my weakness!!!) to go, $ 3. I wanted to savor it after dinner at home. It looked small but it’s so rich that you only need a few bites to feel satisfied. So delish! They had SO many other flavors of cupcakes too, it was hard to decide! The cupcakes themselves are are so beautiful and pleasing to the eye.

I really must be a slow learner because I keep occasionally returning to the Draper location and every time I do, I am smacked in the face with horrible customer service. We arrived at the draper location right before close, and yes I know that is not the nicest thing on our part, but we were quick. So we get in the store and we were moderately welcomed, but then a different girl started helping us… she was terrible. Never in my life have I been made to feel so rushed to get out of a store. She was rude and so very pushy. I get it, its Friday night and you want to close up shop and go home, but that does not justify you in treating your customers like trash. Moreover, to top off this already poor visit… we paid for our goods and almost immediately after, they shut off the bloody lights. We were re not even to the door yet and they shut off the bloody lights off on us… Are you kidding me? Who in the hell does this? To whomever is the manager of the Draper location you need to put yourself and all your employees through some rigorous customer service training. I will never recommend your location to another person. I think the Draper store needs to emulate the customer service of the Murray location. The Murray location has always provided amazing goods, and awesome customer service.
I rarely write bad reviews, but I have written 3 bad reviews for the draper location since 2009. Get your crap together Draper!

Cupcakes are apparently very trendy. I approve of this trend, although I actually wish there were pie places on every corner instead. I digress.
If you like cupcakes, you’ll like this place. Apparently the people who give this place negative reviews are looking for cupcakes made by unicorns and packaged with four-​leaf clovers, because the cupcakes and cookies are pretty good. It’s cupcakes, for crying out loud. How can they be bad? It’s a good place to pick up a few fancy-​ish treats for friends and family.
Also, people who complain about the price crack me up. If it’s too spendy … don’t buy any?
My faves: toasted coconut and German chocolate. Oh, plus the chocolate-​dipped macaroons are pretty damned good. OH. Plus the cake bites.

STF now stands for Shit.Tooth.Fairy.
I used to be a huge STF fan, but then the quality started to disappear. Every time I go back, they never have the flavor I want, or it tastes horrible. I’ve noticed that they have started to taste like store bought cake mix. The workers here aren’t friendly, and aren’t willing to check the back for anything that you want.
They advertise flavors of the month, but this location never seems to have them! I’ve gone many many times to try new flavors, and left empty handed. They always advertise deals on Facebook, but never make good on them. This company is getting too big to handle.
When you request a flavor that they don’t have, they say «Our store didn’t get that one»
This makes be believe that they aren’t baked fresh at every location.

This visit was worse. This was your last chance Sweet Tooth Fairy. You blew it.
We stopped in to get a box of treats for our ailing Uncle to deliver to him in the hospital.
I explained how I got jipped out of my chocolate truffle cookie on my last visit and returned home to find some oatmeal-​y thing instead. The girl behind the counter said, «Oh. Was it oatmeal chocolate chip?» That’s it. Nothing else. I was expecting an «OMG! I’m so sorry. Here, have a chocolate truffle cookie to replace the one that you SHOULD HAVE received, since you paid for it, last time.» But it was not to be. So, we bought a half-​dozen cookies and I said to my wife on the way out, «that’s my last visit to this place.» And I meant it!
There are plenty of places to get better treats, better service and better value.