Wicked Good Pizzeria

Tried this place. Ordered pizza and chicken parm sub. The crust is horrible. The sauce is so sweet and the pizza over all was sloppy and greasy. The chicken parm sub roll was ok but the chicken was like frozen pattys and there was barely any sauce with maybe a tsp of shredded cheese. Was hoping this place would be good but we would never go back

I had seen good reviews here and on other websites so I wanted to give Wicked Good Pizza a try. If the 3 crust styles mentioned in another review are true, I wasn’t offered any crust options. Granted I did all in a pick-​up order on a Friday night, they said 40 minutes which seemed like a long wait to me. When I got there and said I was there to pick up an order under my name he said someone was just in and took that order. Then he smiled and I realized he was joking, but it wasn’t funny at all. He proceeded to make other jokes during the checkout process that I didn’t understand and was making negative comments about the President (the news was on the TV). Not very professional at all and the pizza and wings were awful! I will definitely not be a returning customer!

I think maybe the health department needs to make a stop by this place. Although they are much friendlier than the previous establishment, Trio’s, I watched as the cooks handled wraps and subs without gloves. My steak caesar wrap had an inch long hair (goatee?) in it. ugh! When I brought it back they were quite apologetic but said «well it happens sometimes.»

It was okay-​not my kind of pizza but my son said it was in his top 3. The crust edge was like a salty pretzel, which is not for me but I am sure other people would like it. Also it wasn’t the sweeter sauce that I go for. I also ordered wings, and the skin didn’t have any crispiness to it, so next time I will ask them if they can sear them up or put in the oven longer for me. As for the staff, they were incredibly friendly and welcoming and will let you sample as many sauces as you want since they offer so many. I would go back for the service alone, and I would love to try their subs.

NOTE: Wicked Good Pizzeria is no more. The Happy Hippy boutique (moved from Windham) now occupies this location.
— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — –
Wicked Good Pizzeria opened up in the former Trio’s Pizzeria location. At first, I was reluctant to stop in here since the previous pizzas I’ve had here when it was Trio’s were not all that great (thin crust and way too chewy). I finally decided to try out this new pizza shop very recently. Like before, this pizza shop is an order at the counter place with a few tables for eating in.
Under new management, Wicked Good Pizzeria serves up a variety of traditional and gourmet pizzas with 3 kinds of crust (traditional, thin, & heavy weight), hot & cold subs, calzones, salads, fried appetizers, 30 flavors of wings (bone-​in, boneless, nuggets), fried desserts (Twinkies, Snickers, Oreos, Milky Ways), fried dough, and cinnamon sticks. Bottled Pepsi products in the cooler. The food prices here seem reasonable.
For takeout. I ordered a Large 14″ Meatball Pizza ($ 8.24 plus tax), which was baked in the brick oven and ready in about 15 minutes. Before leaving in my ride, I enjoyed a couple pizza slices in the parking lot. The pizza had a thin «pastry style» dough soft crust (rolled along edges (slightly salted), topped with a sweet tomato sauce, melted mozzarella cheese and thin slices of soft meatballs (not too much topping).
The pizza I had IMO was «wicked good» and very tasty! I enjoyed more of the pizza as soon as I arrived at my house for dinner. I had to force myself to stop eating the very tasty pizza (at 4 slices) to keep with my self imposed wellness program.
I’m definitely returning to Wicked Good Pizza very soon for another pizza along with some Asian sweet chili wings too!
NOTE: This review is credible IMHO and Wicked Good Pizzeria has rightfully earned this rating. I DO NOT need the «local competition» sending me condescending messages and so called «compliments.»