Maggie and Molly’s Sweet Life

We ordered some kitty cupcakes for a new kitten shower. They were clever and adorable and so delicious. You all are simply the best. Everyone raved at your creativity. They looked just like the new kittens.

They did such a wonderful job on our gender-​reveal cake! We were so surprised and the Owls were just too cute! The taste was good, but the buttercream frosting was more like whipped cream & not as tasty as a result. Other than that, I am a fan of this bakery now!

These folks did a great job with a last-​minute gift order of a fresh pie and even a Sunday delivery. They took the time to make sure they had the ingredients for the pie. They bake from scratch, so you are not going to get something left on the shelf. I am out of town, so the order was in their hands completely. The delivery was on-​time and cheerful according to the recipient and the pie was, «as good as it looks». We appreciate Maggie and Molly’s!

I came across Maggie and Molly’s looking for a local bakery for my boyfriends birthday in Denver. He was there working on a project and I wanted to make sure he still had a great birthday despite being on a business trip.
I ordered the cookie cake to be delivered. I was told it was delicious, rich, and very much homemade. It was thicker than an normal cookie cake you get at other places as well. Everyone enjoyed it!
I had read the comments on deliveries gone bad before I ordered. I made sure to call the day of the delivery to verify the order and delivery. They called both myself and my boyfriend when they couldn’t find the suite and made sure he got the deliver, much appreciated!
It cost $ 15 to deliver 2 miles from their bakery to the office, which seems like the standard price for them all around but in my opinion is bit extreme.
All around, good experience. Thank you, Maggie and Molly’s!

I wanted to find a local, independent bakery to make the cake for my husband’s 70^th birthday party… so I really wanted to like this place. The service was fine, the cookies I tried when I went to place my order were tasty, the design on the cake was clever… but the cake itself was really disappointing. The icing was bland and kind of waxy and the cake was really dry. I prefer to go local/​independent but sadly I ended up wishing I’d ordered from Costco or King Soopers.

they completely forgot my order of a birthday cake for my daughters office. in the late afternoon they contacted her and left the cake at a resturant. her first birthday away from home was ruined because they don’t pay attention to detail!

Decided to finally check out this cute small bakery after walking by many times in the past. The smell alone on the sidewalk is enough to draw you in. While the space is really tiny, there is a varied selection of cookies, biscotti, quick breads, cake pops, etc. It was nice to see three workers right in the middle of preparing more goodies rather than just bringing everything in from a hidden kitchen. At the same time, I wish the employees would have been a bit more attentive rather than having to catch their attention to get what I wanted and pay. The baked goodies were good so definitely want to try more things at another time.

Absolutely the worst cupcakes I have ever had. Literally. My mother in law brought home a box of four assorted cupcakes. The frosting was pure butter, very little flavor. The cake was dry and tasteless. Honestly, I am amazed they sell things. We looked forward to them all day to celebrate my husbands birthday and were so disappointed. Ick.

My weekly routine is to stop by and restock on their decorated sugar cookies. They are always yummy and never hard
I have ordered from 7 different bakeries in Denver (for decorated sugar cookie) and by far M&M’s does it the best!

I have had Maggie and Molly’s deliver birthday cakes and cupcakes to my son, who lives in Denver, for years. During most of this time, we lived out of state and I couldn’t provide a birthday cake in person. Now, we live in Colorado, and I still have Maggie and Molly’s deliver cakes or cupcakes because they are *so delicious* and the staff has been so great about contacting me. I have had a chance to sample the carrot cake and the assorted cupcakes and they are delicious. I just ordered the Nutella cupcakes for our son’s birthday this Friday and know they will be just exquisite!

Thank you for the awesome job making my sis-in-law’s custom birthday cake. It came out exactly as I envisioned. Plus it was very delicious!

Darling bakery! I needed a cake for the next day’s improve baby reveal party. Mary took my order and had my special cake ready in less than 24 hours. It turned out so cute and it tasted delicious. Love the bakery, it’s so fun

This review is regarding delivery, I’ve never visited the store itself.
I had ordered my boyfriend a dozen of the Peanut Butter & Jelly cupcakes to be delivered to his work for his birthday. I had considered Edible Arrangements but thought this would be a little more fun and more easily shared among his co-​workers.
I ordered online and left very specific instructions with a name and number of who to call if the delivery person was in any way confused when they arrived. I also called the bakery itself explaining the ideal time frame for the cupcakes to me delivered.
The cupcakes arrived within my requested time frame which was great BUT it goes downhill from there. My boyfriend’s work has a buzzer, you have to buzz in, announce yourself and someone will be right with you. The delivery person buzzed in, stated that they had a package for my boyfriend who was notified immediately and went down right away to meet the person — but they had already left. But don’t worry, they left the cupcakes. On the RAILING of a STAIRWELL. This building holds several businesses within it and after paying $ 65 dollars which includes $ 25 for delivery alone I am expecting a LITTLE MORE professionalism.
Lets talk about the cupcakes. Obviously not made the same day. They were hard and very dry and I’m sad to say lacked flavor. I went out of my way to order locally but ended up being so disappointed. I wouldn’t recommend this bakery to anyone.

Who needs cupcakes when you can get big, luscious, moist cookie bars?! You gotta try the bars. I am not a huge cupcake person and honestly don’t know that they are Maggie and Molly’s forte but Lime bars, lemon bars, peanut butter bars… MMMMMMMMMMMMMMM Big enough to share but delicious enough you don’t want to.
And did I mention the out of this world angel food cake? Get it with the lime curd filling…

Do NOT order from this bakery’s website if you want your sister to receive her birthday cupcakes ON her birthday… or at all. Not only will your sister not receive her cupcakes, but when you call to check the status of your delivery, you will get ZERO compassion and no offer to make things right. What you will get is a woman with a flat affect say, «uh, I don’t know what happened.» Wow. Thanks. Now your sister’s birthday has passed, she has no gift and you aren’t sure you’ll get your money back. The only thing Maggie and Molly made sure happened was for the $ 54 to be deducted from my checking account.
Ridiculous.

Based on Delivery Service**
Maggie and Molly’s went above and beyond to deliver an order for me. One that I didn’t plan on being difficult but ended up being that way. I ordered cookies for my boyfriend, who just started a new job. Unbeknownst to me, I ordered to have them delivered on Veteran’s Day, a day when his office was closed (but was to be the second day at his new job). They called to tell me they would deliver the following day. The following day (today) was a blizzard of a day, with highs in the single digits. Nobody wants to be driving around any more than they need to. They tried to deliver at lunch and the receptionist refused to take their delivery because she didn’t recognize my boyfriend’s name as someone who worked there. I called my boyfriend (and had to ruin the surprise, stupid office lady) and tell them he needed to let her know he was an employee so that the delivery could take place. He did, and Maggie and Molly’s tried for THIRD time to deliver my paltry box of treats. This time they were successful. That kind of service is above and beyond. I think it would’ve almost been in their right to tell me they were un-​deliverable. I will (probably much to their chagrin!!) be using their service again. Hopefully I will be a better customer next time. I haven’t heard how the product has tasted yet, so the word is still out on that aspect.

I found this bakery online when I decided my girlfriend in Denver needed some cheering up. I chose the bakery because they were willing to deliver my order and it appeared they could be delivered same day. I got a call late in the afternoon saying the cookies would not be delivered same day. I was upset but agreed to have them delivered the next day. Still upset, I sent the owner an email. She agreed to refund my money. At the end of the day, I ordered from another bakery and I was happy to be getting a refund.
The next day my girlfriend sends me a picture of the cookies. Completely frustrated and annoyed I called the bakery and made sure I was still getting a refund. I did not want those cookies delivered, I wanted my money back. The owner agreed.
Two days later the charge posts to my credit card and when I ask for a refund the owner refuses. I tried disputing the charge with my credit card company and I can’t because I can’t return the cookies.
I am flabbergasted at this bakery and their complete disregard for customer service.
Had there been any question as to whether or not I still wanted the cookies delivered, they should have called me.
If you are looking for courtesy and professionalism, avoid Maggie and Molly’s.

The smell was enticing as I was leaving a neighboring store so I decided that I need to swing in. There were two women inside, I barely got a hello at first. I figured they’d be more friendly perhaps? I mentioned that the smells outside were what pulled me inside and that it all looked good. Still not much of a response. I bought two cookies. Neither blew me away. Neither made me think that I need to come back.
At least I gave it a shot! I’ve driven by for years. I’ll keep purchasing my baked goods elsewhere. Oh well…

Tasty cookies! The chocolate and the chocolate chip were both really good.

I stumbled in this afternoon and now I remember why I have been avoiding this adorable bakery across the street. Everything looks amazing and tastes even better! Friendly smiles behind the counter were patiently waiting for me to make my selections. It took a while to make up my mind. I walked home with a blueberry scone, a peach crumble bar, a piece of sour cream crumb cake and a salted nutella cookie. Oh my!
Biscotti, cupcakes, cookies galore. .. even gluten free! Muffins, cinnamon rolls (reasonably sized), quiche and more.
Now, if only someone would open up a coffee shop next door I’d be all set!

Our last stop on our UYE-​cupcake tour, this place gave us a free cupcake for checking in. The shop is tiny — don’t expect to be able to sit down for a long time, although there are benches outside if the weather is nice.
I got the vanilla-​vanilla cupcake, and wow was the frosting rich! The cake is dense and the frosting tastes almost like cristo or butter as in — it’s not super sweet but is is super rich.
There are not many flavors (6, I believe) but the cupcakes are a good size and they also have cookies and other goodies available.
I gave this a 3 but it really is a good place, it’s just not my favorite and I probably won’t return as the frosting isn’t to my style. If you like a heavy frosting though, give them a shot.

I was shopping next door at the Truffle Cheese Shop when I noticed this cute little bakery! Wow, talk about never judging a book by its cover…
When we walked in the shop was empty. I noticed the girl behind the counter, but she never bothered to look up, let alone greet us. At that point we should’ve just walked out, but I have no discipline when it comes to sweets.
After scoping out the desserts, I had to ASK for help.
The cupcakes are aesthetically pleasing, but again, never judge a book by its cover… these cupcakes were dry and lacked flavor. I purchased two cupcakes, took a bite of one and dumped the rest. What a waste and disappointment…