Bilotti’s Pizza

This place is a disgrace to Italian food. I have had Italian food at many other places in the world including in other Italian restaurants in Green Bay and Appleton areas but never experienced such a bad quality of tasteless food and the horrible service. My daughter loves Italian food and binges on it.
I do not understand how can a restaurant serve under cook salmon and do nothing when you tell the server after the first tiny bite that it is uncooked. Both my daughter and I left entire food on the table. Neither we were able to eat or felt like taking home for the first time in my life. The server, manager and cook were unaffected by two customer leave the entire food on the table.

Should be a «no star» rating. I have been here a few times only because I received gift certificates from a neighbor. Obviously he is either easy to please or has lost his sense of taste.
The food always leaves something to be desired. Usually arrives after a lengthy wait and is lukewarm. Expect to send it back to be warmed. The pizza is bland and overpriced.
On our last, and final, visit we were told to seat ourselves anywhere. We did just that and were never acknowledged by the waitress. She was obviously overwhelmed by three other tables of customers, more than I have ever seen here before. After fifteen minutes of waiting, we got up and left. I suspect others followed suit after seeing three other employees chatting it up at the bar.
The local food pantry receives any future gift certificates.

Pizza crust was burnt and dough was not cooked all the way through. My wife got a hamburger and it was burnt. A burger. Burnt. How hard is it to make a burger?
For how much it cost to eat there. Not worth it.

We were here for a rehearsal dinner. The pizza was very good! I’d recommend the pepperoni, but the BBQ chicken was also very good as well!

I had the Italian Beef sandwich. It was TINY! I was expecting a much bigger sandwich at $ 9.25. It doesn’t come with anything. Christianos in Oshkosh charges $ 1 less for this sandwich. It is twice the size and comes with homemade chips!

I was in Green Bay the other day and ordered a personal pizza for delivery. I had their special with anchovies and crabs. Best pizza ever! I also had a cheesecake for dessert. That was so good! Not too rich for me…

Let me say I love pizza. It is one of those foods that I do not believe people who say it is not good or they do not like it. That being said there are 10 to 15 pizza places that are better than this restaurant. The service is an absolute joke. No idea about the menu, specials, or what they suggest. How can you work at a restaurant and not have one thing on the menu that you can suggest? The décor is dirty and out dated. It is easily one of best buildings in Depere but it is not worth stopping in. I honestly was going to ask for my money back.

Ok I may be the biggest pizza snob on the planet, so when I tell you Bilotti pizza rocks you can take it to the bank. the crust is thin and crisp and the toppings are top quality. the cheese is just Devine! Bilotti’s pizza blows all east coast pizza I’ve had out of the water.
Bravisimo bilotti’s. I’ll be back every time I’m in town. (I drive truck for a living so I’ve had pizza everywhere.)

Fail. Ordered crumbly blue cheese with Italian for my salad. Got blue cheese dressing and Italian with a $ 0.50 up charge for having 2 dressings. Salad was nothing more than iceberg lettuce. Expensive, and not good. As much as I absolutely hate to say this, you’d be waaay better off at Olive Garden.

It was Tuesday but the fact that only 1 other group came in the entire time that me and my girlfriend were there should have been a clue. The prices were very high for the generic Olive Garden food (and not generic in a good way). The noodles were cooked alright, the «garlic» bread was rock hard and the chicken was flavorless… oh and the salads… I guess the pizza was good (based on past visits) but the chicken olivette and lasagna (and dinners?) I would stay away from.

Used to work here. Still crave the pizza every now and then.
Called to get a pizza and was quoted 1 hour for delivery. 1:45 minutes later still no pizza. Called the store and my pizza was JUST COMING OUT OF THE OVEN! (A. its thin crust. B. I used to work there and know it takes 10 – 15 minutes.) 2 hours after ordering my $ 25 thin curst pizza finally arrived.
It’s good pizza, but not worth a 2 hour wait and $ 25 when other delivery pizza will take half the time and cost half the price.

We love this style of pizza… Thin crust, cooked toppings. Wonderful. I didn’t feel like the food was overpriced. We sat at the bar close to closing time on a rare night out from our new baby. James really took care of us as we quizzed him on the comedian statuettes behind the bar, even hustling to get our food when we got «the call» from the sitters. First experience was excellent…

Definitely not the place to go after a Packer game. Totally understaffed food came cold one server, one bartender, management clearly failed to plan. Disappointed to know I’ll never return to this institution, but there’s simply too much competition that cares more.

stopped in the other night and had a pizza. it was very good. Quite expensive, but good. Service was ok, but not very attentive. Will return.

Loved the pizza! Thin crust, crispy and nice amount of toppings. Old-​time family feel to the place.

WHAT happened to this place??? Twenty years ago, this was a great place, always jammed packed and good food. A few months ago, my son and I were shopping in De Pere and decided stopped in for lunch. The place looked exactly how I remembered but it was kinda creepy that we were the only customers. Our pizza crust was doughy and under cooked but not terrible, the fried bread sticks were perfect. So last night, my son wanted to go to Bilotti’s for his birthday. I thought that a Friday on Memorial Day weekend with the carnival going on a block a way would be a problem but no, at 7 pm supper time there was only 2 other tables seated. The bartender waved us in, the waitress was kinda creepy and she forgot our appetizer order. We waited 45 minutes for our food and we were not impressed. The pizza we ordered was good. My husband’s calzone was cold, burned on one side and soggy on the other, and was hidden under a flavorless sauce. My pasta primavera was cold, bland, and drowning in oil. The bread served with our dinners was a dry and stale sandwich bun. Unfortunate, truly sad to see this place decline. Definitly a candidate for Robert Irvine’s «Restaurant Impossible»!!!

Longtime customer– No Longer — found a 2″ long metal wire in my meatball bomber sandwich — no response from management — shame on you! Now I know they don’t even make their meatballs in house :(

It’s been a couple of years since we last ate a Bilottis, and nothing seems to have changed.
First, the good. The atmosphere and décor are decent. The place was clean and inviting, as usual. As for food, their sauce is always a crowd pleaser. That’s about where the positive items end.
The waitress was unprofessional and mildly insulting to our group. We all ordered different pasta dishes, but they all ended up being spaghetti and sauce with a different ingredient slapped on top (a little chicken to make it chicken parm, etc.). Worst of all everything was completely overpriced. $ 15 for a spaghetti dinner? $ 6 rail mixer? No thanks.
Every time we go here we say that it should be featured on Kitchen Nightmares. That’s the best way to describe it, which is too bad. It has such great potential.

This place has prime real estate in De Pere and does nothing with it. I hope this place goes away soon and something cool moves into it. For pizza in De pere, go to Politios’ or Sgambatis, for italian in De Pere go to pasquale’s international café.

Bilott’s is not a 5-​star restaurant. They have a huge amount of space that usually isn’t very busy (are you complaining you were seated and served and ate immediately?), the music is a teeny bit creepy, and the waitresses are hit or miss.
The pizza is amazing — super thin and plenty of cheese. Get the pizza Bianca. They have great beer on tap. And it’s so dang cheap! It’s open til like 1 or 2 am, so it’s perfect for a late night place to grab some good sit down food for not a lot of money. Whenever I’m visiting friends and family home in Green Bay, we always make at least one stop here.