The Good Pie Company

I must wholeheartedly agree with Navene S. and everything she wrote regarding the blueberry pie. I, too, had high expectations based on other reviews. There aren’t many real bakeries around town and I was so excited to try Good Pie Company. Very disappointing. Their pies are extremely pricey. $ 12 for a small 6′ pie is very pricey, but if it was the best pie I’ve ever eaten, I wouldn’t even care about the price. Sadly, that was NOT the case.
I purchased the apple and blueberry pies, both 6′. The crust was very thick, too thick. The fruit filling was not enough to fill the crust to the top and there was a large gap inside of both pies on the top of the fruit filling, above /​between it and the top crust. The taste of the pies was fine, nothing spectacular. For them to justify the price, one should eat the pies and say «that was fantastic! Best pie ever!», not «that was mediocre, Publix average pies have more filling and I just totally got ripped off.». I’ll spend my $ 24 at the farmer’s market on their baked goods or make a pie myself for that price. Wha-​wha :(

All I have to say about this place is WOW! I am not a pie person and have tried many pot pies and never like any that is until I tried their chicken pot pie. It is probably one of the most delicious meals I have had. I also tried that mac & cheese pie and it was also delicious. The only downfall is that I wish they opened just a bit later. Definitely a must try for everyone.

Feliz de haberlos visitado de nuevo, tienen unos Pies riquisimos!
Tanto dulces como salados… el Chicken Pot Pie es delicioso y el Manzana estaba buenisimo!
El sitio es pequeno, tienen los distintos pies exhibidos. Puedes ver el area de produccion, todo es impecable
Vale la pena acercarse y consentirse con estas ricuras!

It’s located in a plaza and if you blink you can miss it. They do have signs up in the parking lot for pies so that was good. It’s like 2 companies in the one kind of. One side is all pies and the other is cookies. I ordered the mini/​small pies and what a mistake that was. I had to share it between 4 people and we all stayed wanting more. The pies were so delicious that I cant wait to go back for more. We did order from the other side bread pudding and macaroons which were also really good. If you are in the area you must stop by.

My wife and I found The Good Pie Company online and figured we’d give it a shot. Walking into the shop is an experience, so many different pies to choose, savory, sweet and different other assorted desserts. The owners are super friendly, and were happy to answer my million questions about the different menu items. If their passion about their food didn’t come through just talking to them, wait until you see them box up your pie. The pies are really a work of art. The lemon meringue pie was something out of a magazine or food network show, really just stunning.
The reuben pie was our favorite. There are caraway seeds so it you taste the rye, sauerkraut and the thousand island dressing in every bite. This was 100% the best thing I’ve eaten so in a long time. The prices of the pies are really worth it considering they are stuffed to the brim with meat. There is very little filler, its all so well balanced. I would certainly recommend this to anyone who is looking for good eats, and wants something a little different. Five stars!

Delicious pecan pie! Lighter than most, maybe made with apples? Not sure but I ate the whole large pie. The dough was great!

The Good Pie Company is a welcome addition to our community. All their pies and cakes are delicious. They are all made from scratch and taste delicious. My family’s favorites are chocolate cream, any of the apple varieties, and all the savory selections.

We tried them out for the first time this last week and they were AWESOME!
We got the lattice top apple pie, the pumpkin ganache and the butter cookies.
The ingredients are simple and the taste is fantastic. Their customer service is great — super friendly and helpful.
Will definitely be back!

AMAZING desserts! do yourself a favor and try their key lime pie. As a matter of fact do your self another favor and buy yourself the bigger pie lol. Best pie I’ve had in my entire 28 years of life. Their cherry pie is really good also crust and all not just the fruit filling. Had a chance to chat with the owner and her daughters they were so nice and happy to answer all my questions. I was happy to hear they use fresh fruit on all their wonderful desserts.

Let’s talk pie. Not the kind of pie you order at a restaurant that arrived frozen in a box three days ago. Not the mediocre, stick it in the microwave and finish with vanilla ice cream pie. Let’s talk REAL pie. The kind of pie that melts in your mouth. The kind you don’t want to finish because you aren’t ready for the moment to be over yet. The kind that tastes like love, heart and soul was poured in to each bite. Now we’re talking pie… The Good Pie Company that is!
I had the pleasure of experiencing four flavors: Blueberry, Apple, Cherry & Spinach.
I started with Apple because that was always my favorite pie that my Grandma used to make. Scoot over Grandma, there’s a new pie in town! No need for «a la mode» with these apples.
Then to the cherry. The sweet, tart, gooey, cherry pie, with a flaky crust that makes it very hard to share.
I was skeptical about the spinach pie, especially with all the sweets I had already indulged in that had set the bar pretty high, but WHOA. I was amazed at how flavorful the hearty pie was.
Last, but trust me, not least, let me tell you about the Blueberry Pie. I already miss this pie. I feel like we didn’t get to spend enough time together. Each sweet bite brought me back to my childhood, when my Grandma would serve us blueberry pie at just the right temperature. I wanted each bite to last forever.
Truly delicious and amazing! The world needs more foods like this. Food that is made by an actual person with ingredients that were actually grown locally. Thank you, The Good Pie Company, for bringing me back to my sweet childhood memories, one bite at a time!

I saw this place while on a run to AC Supplies… it was closed because of «vacation». I researched the company online and for a while have had them on my mind… I decided to stop by today and pick up some pie and unfortunately. They had none (Wednesday)!!! How disappointing?!? They have pie signs advertised all over the plaza… The very nice attendant said that they come in on Thursdays… What do they mean by that?! They have a whole kitchen behind the counter!
Anyway, I’m giving them 2 stars because I love the store’s look. It’s so «homey» — mom and pops. They did have a lot of cookies, pastries, and breads available… I ended up having an apple tart with a little bit of strawberry and it was very fresh and delicious. I also bought French Sables (cookies with vanilla and lemon flavoring) which were very good, as well. They would go great with afternoon tea or coffee.
I’ll update my review when I try the pies, since that’s what their specialty is and what people will stop by for.

I came in here with an appetite and ended up getting 3 different pies! I got a key lime pie, banana cream, and blueberry. Out of all three the banana cream is by far my favorite. It had actual banana pieces inside and she whipped up fresh whip cream for the pie while I was there which tasted great!
I am giving this place 3 stars because of the blueberry and key lime and the prices. I had very high expectations from the key lime but I had better. It came out a little too tart. My advice is to let the pie thaw a little before eating or else you won’t taste the goodness of the crust. Also the blueberry pies wasnt that great. To not be able to make an outstanding traditional blueberry pie made me a little sad.
Also, the pies were pricey. I got a large key lime, a med banana crm pie, and a sm blueberry and it came out to be around $ 45.

I love this small family owned business. I went in after work to get a key lime pie for my partner’s birthday and they made the whipped cream fresh right in front of me. Everyone is always so friendly and I LOVE that they have small options for pies because sometimes, you just want a small piece. Love!

I had The Good Pie Company on my bookmarked list for a couple of months, Ive finally had the chance to see what they are all about. I have tried the Cherry Pie and Key Lime Pie and i must say that the Key Lime is a must try for all those who are fans. The prices are a little out of my budget for pie, but with the understanding that they are homemade and fresh I can splurge once in a while.

I love this little gem. The pies are homemade deliciousness that can get addictive. The staff are all friendly and very helpful.

Had an apple crumb (best I’ve ever had) and a strawberry rhubarb that was really good as well. Will for sure be going back to try others.

I’ve been here before in search of the perfect Key Lime Pie, but that particular day they had run out so I had to settle for a peanut butter chocolate pie which was very delicious. Everything is made fresh and you will notice when you walk in the front doors.
Today I was successful in trying their KLP and I was very pleased with the taste! Not so much with the price or the size, but hey you can’t have it all. I would most likely return whenever I have my KLP craving.

I haven’t tried their pies from their store, YET, but I did pick up a medium blueberry pie yesterday from their stand at the Parkland Farmers Market.
I bought it for my husband, as I am not a pie fan at ALL… but oh did that change after taking one bite.
I loved it so much I ate almost all if it.
I will definetly stop by their shop to try more pies.
While the price was a little higher than «normal» pies, I feel it was very much worth it.
I think the only thing close to it would be if I made the pies myself and I don’t see that happening anytime soon.
I never eat pie and now I am looking forward to when I am in Davie just to get some pie!

I had to check this place out!!! I went for 1 pie… left with 3!!! The apple strawberry pie its amazing!!! I also had the berry mix it was delicious and a apple pie!!! Took the pies to a family event and everyone keep on asking me where i got them!!! Highly recommend this place!!! And this come from a fat guy!!!

Mmmm… flakey, buttery crust. Big chunks of chicken, creamy gravy and fresh vegetables. Top it all off with beautiful cut-​out pastry leaves decorating the top. I just scarfed down (no, I mean seriously inhaled) one of the best chicken pot pies I’ve ever had. And for dessert, a mini apple crumb tart… the perfect blend of tangy apples, more buttery crust (do you sense a theme here?), and sweet crumb topping.
DO NOT listen to the naysayers! This is really yummy, hand-​made, fresh, and yes, I can’t resist, buttery pie. I’m staying in Pembroke Pines, but it’s worth a drive. Get your butts down there and enjoy some super yummy sweet and savory pies.
I should add that one of my most favorite places in the world is The Little Pie Shop in NYC. Best sour cream apple pie in the universe. After today, The Good Pie Company is my second go-​to pie shop. Worth the trip! Go! You’ll love it!

Apple Pie
The apples were delicious in cinnamon and
natural juices. Spectacular! Flaky crust and it was so good.
Pecan Pie
Flaky, fully cooked crust that began my adventure. Toasted whole pecans over a filling made with the same ingredients I use! This pie is Sooooo Good! I ate it at room temperature. They also have choc/​pecan pie. I enjoy it, but too rich for my bunch. These smaller pies are excellent out of the box thinking!
Chicken Pot Pie
Did not care for the sauce of veges and chicken inside. It was sweet potato cream like. What happened to creamy white sauce?
The crust was just like others very yum
Amazing find shared by fellow Unilocalers! :
This is a small shop but easy to see when looking for it. They carry I think 25 types of pies. Creams, savory and fruit.