Anthony’s Coal Fired Pizza

Food is great but the service left something to be desired. Typically, I feel welcomed in when dining out. This place, the waitress we had seemed to care less if we ordered or were there or not. Too bad really.
Had the wings based and a number of other recommendations and they were top notch. Great flavor. The pizza was done perfectly as well.
Other than the staff, it was a great place.

That was the worst service I’ve ever had. Anywhere. For anything. I’d leave the name of my server but she never gave it. After sitting at the table for 7 minutes I wanted to leave but my wife is way more patient then I am. She finally came over to ask for drinks and our order. After she got them we got our drinks about 5 minutes later. People have bad days. No doubt. But she couldn’t have been worse. We waited even longer for our check. No thanks. No sorry for the wait. No how was everything. Nothing. I think she said 7 words in total. We were there for 57 minutes. The food wasnt bad and didnt take exceptionally long. But she was terrible. I wouldn’t come back if our food was free for life.

Pizza and wings were great, BUT ordered a lemon drop martini and it turns out that they charge 9.50 for a martini and which make it with Banker’s Club vodka! I spoke with the manager and told her that I expected more from a restaurant that charges 35.00 for a pizza, but she was not particularly swayed by my complaints. This isn’t south side or a college bar. Banker’s Club vodka is unacceptable when it comes to martini’s.

One time visit — yesterday. Pizza, thin crust, excellent. Nice layout. Efficient staffing. Plenty of TV’s for game watching. Excellent beer selections. This would make a fun «game day» place.
We consider this the best Pizza in the Cranberry area. Thin crust, well done and presented.

Coal fired pizza is really good, all specialty though. I don’t believe you can even order a pizza by choice of toppings. It’s very different, but very good. Their wings are coal fire grilled also, and are excellent. Every time in I ask for bleu cheese just to be a dick, because their staff is trained to act surprised and say «when wings are done right, you don’t need bleu cheese». They’re somewhat right with these… they are exceptionally good.

the service is fantastic everyone is extremely friendly but the for the food it is just food. Nothing remarkable. The meatballs are meatballs the pizza is odd. The eggplant resembles a dogs raw hide and probably taste similar (as i have never had a raw hide) i can only guess. Thank goodness gor the large salad it has a nice zippy vinaigrette that satisfied when everything else was lacking. 5 stars for the service and atmosphere 1 sQ1tar for tastyness of the food.

Been here many times… first review, though. We love this place. Great beer list, but I recommend the management team has a paper copy available, if requested. The chalk boards aren’t the easiest to read from certain areas of the floor.
Their wings with caramelized onions are very good.
The most important thing is the pizza. It really is very good. The crust is light and multi textured. Soft underneath and crunchy on the crust. Maybe the best pizza sauce around. Toppings are great. The banana peppers may be the hottest I’ve ever eaten. That’s a good thing.
Price if the pizzas knocks the rating down a little, especially the price of toppings. If I recall correctly, its around $ 2 – 3 per pie per topping. If you’re not careful, the price of a pie could easily be over $ 20 for a light meal.
Service is normally good and the food seems to be served very quickly.

The best pizza in Cranberry, thin crust and crispy. Service is very good behind the bar and routinely consistent at the table.
The wings are covered with caramelized onions which I personally don’t prefer since I like extra crispy wings and the onions moistened the wings.
However, the caramelized onions are tasty alone so you could get them in the side.
The meatballs are very good, large tasty and with plenty of rich sauce.
Salads are large and can be a small can be split between two people. Great house dressing; bought a bottle for home.

I’ve dined in and ordered take out here many times. The service has always been great! This place has a decent atmosphere… I’d rather have a bit more privacy though, the tables are pretty close together. Maybe that’s the vibe they want, it’s alright, I guess I just prefer booths. Sometimes I find the music to be a bit loud, and it’s hard to have a conversation. However, it never seems to bother anyone else, so it could just be me.
The salad is really good for a basic Italian salad… I always add the Gorgonzola for a little extra, it’s worth it! The house dressing is awesome. Their pizza is delicious. I only eat thin crust pizza, and I’m a huge pizza snob. This does the trick when I’m in the pizza mood (which is often) …Anthony’s is great pizza for Pittsburgh area. I love the white pizza, it’s definitely one to try.
It’s my go to pizza spot for cranberry area for sure.

This place was so good. We ordered a few items to split — the wings, a small traditional pizza, and a meatball sandwich. We weren’t offered a lunch menu, but I wish we had been (my friend tried to order two meatballs, but the girl suggested a sandwich that wasn’t on the menu, if I had had the lunch menu I might have ordered that myself!). The meatball sandwich was really on pita bread and had caramelized onions and was so good. The caramelized onions on the wings were amazing — we never thought they would be as good as they were thinking they would be all soggy, but trust me, you want to try them! The pizza was ok, but not as good as I expected after having the other food at the table.

Expensive greasy over priced pizza.
Service was good. Pizza is extremely thin. It was pretty good, but I probably won’t return since there are better take out alternatives.
Had the price reflect value… ie thicker/​larger pizza, I probably would rate higher,

It is pretty good but 60 dollars for two small pizzas and a salad is obnoxious.

Way overpriced, pizza and wings were burned. They aren’t lying, their pizza is well done, [burned]. Look behind counter, there are piles of dough laying out in the open waiting to be used, absorbing any contamination that is in the air, very disgusting. Way overpriced and overrated. Don’t waste your time or money.

Not impressed and felt that it was way over priced. I did not like the taste of the pizza crust at all. I was disappointed.

The salad was excellent and the pizza was very tasty too… the only downfall… the price… $ 19 for a 6 slice pepperoni pizza?!? Sorry but that is ridiculous.

The bartenders and draft selection were great… unfortunately that’s all that was.
I like the concepts of the wings… they just needed a little more flavor. The texture, onions and focaccia were good. The wings needed more. perhaps a good dry rub.
The pizza was so disappointing. I got the broccoli rabe and sausage. It was completely smothered In broccoli rabe. It is a strong ingredient and a little would go a long way it had way to much. The sausage was bland and the tomatoes/​sauce non existent. No where near worth the $ 18.99 price for a 6 slice pizza.

I love the cauliflower pizza!
I keep wanting to order something else (other than the killer wings (and I don’t eat wings) with caramelized onions) but I can’t.
My taste buds take control of my tongue and out comes large cauliflower pizza every time.
One day…

The pizza here was OK. Very acceptable pizza, but nothing to write home about. Not good enough to come again, but not bad enough to tell my friends not to waste their time here. It could very well be good pizza to someone else. I should mention, that it was good for suburban pizza. Up in the burbs we don’t have many authentic or non-​chain style pizza options, so in that regard, this place is good. But when you compare it to some of the authentic pizza places downtown, it doesn’t stand much of a chance.
I found it strange that if you order a beverage, they give you a bottle… they don’t serve fountain beverages, even though they have a fountain at their large bar. I just don’t get why you serve bottles if you’re already paying to have fountain service for your bar. Since there are bottles only, that means no free refills.
For an appetizer, we ordered some wings. There were no choices for flavorings or sauces, just straight up wings. They were lightly seasoned and charred (coal-​fired), but mostly flavorless. They are served in a heaping pile with wilted cooked onions.
We also ordered an appetizer of meatballs. They were served covered in sauce and garnished with basil, a dollop of ricotta, and a few wedges of pita. The meatballs were good, but just like the pizza, nothing fantastic.

Great pizza, got one with sausage, hot peppers and ricotta. Three people could eat from a large, so worth the price. Left full and happy. The service is amazing and I will absolutely go back, will be great location when the Penguins new facility is up and running.

I wish I could give this place more stars. The people here are just awesome. The greet staff and the fantastic servers and bartenders make this place a stand out.
They have a first rate craft beer selection. The bar staff is very knowledgeable and make recommendations to suit your tastes.
The wings are amazing and the pizza toppings are spilling off of the pie. The meatball and ricotta pizza is my favorite.
Fantastic service, drinks, and food!