Schneider’s Bakery

We come to cooperstown at least twice a year and no matter what we stop here. We LOVE the cinnamon and cinnamon raisin rolls. The sugar cookies are fantastic and the donut holes are loved by our kids. We only wish we lived closer!!!

Not very friendly and $ 5 minimum on cc purchases. What is this a Chinese restaurant in 1997?

Came here for a snack after that boozey spin in Coopertown Distillery. Got a beautiful rose petal frosted cookie and a donut. The cookie was just enough to hit the spot, not too sweet or too cloying, and it was a work of beauty you ate.
The donut I tried just because it was a vanilla cream, over a regular Bavarian crème. That was pretty thick and cloying. Glad I had my cookie.
They ran out of bagels when we got there, but it looks like the Stagecoach sells those in their delicious sandwiches.

Bought several different kinds of cookies, they tasted bland. The supermarket cookies at Price Chopper tasted a lot better but not as decorated as nice.

Fresh coffee anyone? How about some biscotti? Or perhaps a delicious, homemade muffin filled with blueberries? Well, if that’s what you crave, you are in luck. This is just the right spot for your sweet tooth.
I ate the baseball themed sugar cookies, they were delectable. My family said the coffee was very good, and as a former coffee drinker who used to live among them, I know if they’re satisfied with it, then there’s no doubt it’s made fresh. However, we brought home bread that didn’t impress us much, so stick with the sweets & treats.

We got here right at 7am. The bakery smells like mom is baking with fresh ingredients. Small bakery with old fashion donuts, croissant, bagels. The coffee is so fresh, you can smell outside. They are getting ready for the holidays. Feels very cozy.
Must go.

Whenever we make the trip to Cooperstown, we plan out our mornings around Schneider’s! I haven’t had any of their cookies, but love their cinnamon rolls, turnovers, fritters, and donuts — especially their apple filled donuts (I believe it is FRESH filling). We bring home extras to share with family and even have their old fashion donuts shipped for special occasions. Service has always been exceptional.

This place was not very good. Had no cream cheese for bagels. Coffee was weak. Pastries very sweet.

There’s a lot of good reasons why this bakery has been around for so long, their doughnuts, and cinnamon rolls! They are heavenly! The best doughnut I have ever had!

Great spot for delicious donuts, hot coffee and a friendly smile. The donuts even taste great the next day! Worth a stop when you’re in town.

I just moved to Cooperstown back in June, so I’m still finding all the hidden gems in town. You would think this place isn’t exactly hidden since it’s on Main St and next to the only stoplight in town, but there you go. I was sent to pick up some donuts for my boss one morning and I learned one very important fact — that their donuts are really, really good. The prices are really good as well and aren’t inflated like some other small bakeries. I’ve had the chance so far of trying some of their donuts, a cinnamon roll, and a black and white cookie and they are all exceptional. The staff have been very kind all the times I’ve stopped in and it’s reflective of Cooperstown in general (nice people in a beautiful town). I’m really glad there’s such a great little shop in town and I definitely recommend it to anyone who’s in the area!

A very quaint little bakery on the corner. It’s got all the charm of an old-​fashioned bakery, and all the glory of wonderful baked goods. I had a cinnamon roll, which was large and covered in icing. My husband had a Bavarian cream donut, which was a-​freaking-​mazing. I also bought a pumpkin spice cookie, which I just realized I haven’t consumed yet… pretty excited about that! All of our goodies (three baked treats and two bottles beverages) was under $ 10, which I thought was very reasonable.
Only downside — don’t expect to find a seat! There were two smallish tables, each with 4 seats, but very close together. With the steady stream of folks coming in, it was a little uncomfortable!
All things considered, we’d definitely stop by again!
**Edited to add — the pumpkin spice cookie was delicious! Dense, pumpkin flavor with a generous smattering of chocolate chips… mmm…**

Very average. Not bad considering you can buy just 1 of an item, but nothing will make you crave it or come back.

Not what it used to be, overpriced and stale. Very disappointed. Never going back.

I was walking around the town with my friend, and we passed this place about 4 times, and we finally said, let’s get some stuff. We felt like being fat, so he ordered a ½ pound of cookies, and I ordered 1 of about 5 things. First off, if you’re going to get the cinnamon role, besides it being good cold, they will heat it up for you if you ask, and it’s worth it. Every other cookie I ordered, macaroon, choc chip cookie, peanut butter cookie, etc was very, very good. My friends rainbow cookie depends on how you prefer it. It was more ‘cakey’ then I like, I prefer it more ‘cookie-​ish’.

Schneider’s doughnuts, which I discovered more than 20 years ago, are simply the best I’ve ever had, anywhere, anytime.
Get the plain doughnut. You don’t need icing or sprinkles or jelly or coconut or any of that stuff that may enhance — but won’t improve — the best doughnut in the world.
That’s right. .. the best doughnut in the world.

The Cinnamon roles and donuts looked GREAT, but we got the Pumpkin Spice and Chocolate Chip Cookies. they were just OK I thought they would be better for a bakery. It has a good ol bakery feel and decent selection we just were not overly impressed with the cookies… You cant get lunch here either, just sweets.

Today I went to the bakery with my boyfriend. I’ve had their «black & white» cookies (half-​moons) before, but this was my first trip into the bakery. We got 2 cannolis, 4 coconut macaroons, and 1 peanut butter cookie. All this cost exactly $ 10.00. My boyfriend and I just had the cannolis and they were great! The macaroons seem nice and moist like they should be, and the peanut butter cookie is good size. I really like the half-​price rack of items from the day before — they had some nice rolls and things like that. I definitely will be going again over 4^th of July weekend when we go back to Cooperstown.
Erin says… you rock!

This review is based solely on the Schneider’s Bakery Cinnamon Rolls.
My boss was in Cooperstown a few weeks before I was, both of us for work. Someone introduced him to the wonderment that is a cinnamon roll from Schneider’s. I don’t know how many he had that weekend, but they lingered in his mind. Shortly before I went, he made a request. He told me that I had to have one when I went up there… and then bring back a dozen.
So, on Friday morning, I made the quick walk to this little mecca on the corner and purchased three for friends and me. They were still warm in the bag. Yummy, cinnamon-​y, heaven about the size of my head greeted my quickly expanding stomach. I ate a whole one. The next day, a friend and I split the last one, heating it for just a bit in the microwave to bring back the sticky texture. Yum again.
A friend placed the order for a dozen for me to pick up the day I departed. He had asked that they be individually wrapped (for ease in freezing when we got back to the city). They didn’t do this (but it’s OK. We put them in individual ziplock bags today. after splitting another in the office), but they were ready and packed up at the appointed time.
And the price is right. A dozen was $ 20. In NYC, each massive roll of yumminess of this size would have been a minimum of $ 3 each.
Did I mention yum?

Cute little bakery on Cooperstown’s wonderfully nostagic Main Street. We stopped by for a sweet treet. Their cookies are awesome and the prices are dirt cheap.