Paradise Pizza of Commack

Pleasantly surprised! Small shop but good flow of customers during snowy President’s Day lunch. We were hungry from shopping across the street (Consumer’s Kitchens & Bath) and gave this pizzeria a try. 4 stars for the soft, buttery-​garlicky knots and 3.75 stars for the very good regular pizza. Thin, light crust and good sauce/​cheese ratio.

Never had a bad dinner or pie from Paradise. The sauce is super delicious and the portions are huge! Such nice people too. We have a ton of pizza places in our town, but prefer to head over to Commack because of Paradise!

Paradise pizza is absolutely out of this world! Everything they make is spectacular– from their pizza to the pasta, chicken dishes and dessert! The staff is extremely friendly and personable, they are attentive and make sure you have everything you need. I live 20 minutes away and I try to get there as much as possible for Grace’s food– made with a mothers love! You can’t beat it!

Very friendly people who work there, as well as having quick, quality food. Their white pizza is top 5 I’ve ever had in my life. If I could eat it every day, I would!

Always fresh and always arrives fast. Can’t complain :)

This is the place to go if you want the best pizza in Commack! The stuffed meat pizza is fantastic. It has in it pepperoni, sausage, & sliced meatball, and is layered with mozzarella and their homemade sauce. The slice is thick, crisp, & covered with sesame seeds. The size of the slice makes it a meal in itself. Their heroes are number one in quality & taste. Their chicken parm dinner special on Thursdays for $ 12.99 is a real value. This a family friendly business that has been here for many years. The family treats you like your family. Take time to visit Paradise Pizza. You will enjoy great Italian food.

Nice owners, delicious pizza and chicken rolls. Great place for a bite. Not trendy or big. Just a nice, squeaky clean neighborhood family owned pizza place.

The best pizza in town, possibly on Long Island. I don’t know what they do to the pizza, but it’s fantastic. The crust is thin, but not too thin (I definitely prefer thin crust) and the pizza is flavorful. Possibly Long Island’s best kept secret.

In all honesty, I am not a fan of paradise pizza. Nothing really jumps out at me here. There are better pizza places around Commack.

Lol this place is terrible full of greddy degenerates. I go in Saturday order 2 slices and the price 5.00 dollars and the guy gave it to me In the box gave me a receipt it was literally full service without my words. I go in Sunday another guy whose there charged me 5.45 for the same 2 slices I bought yesterday for 5.00 then I ask it went up in a matter of a day? He goes «prices on flower went up and so did cheese» yea I’m sure they went up in the 24 hours I’ve been gone. As I paid he gave me my food in a paper bag. Who will be able to out of a paper bag especially on the go? The mess was outrageous. Won’t ever go back here again, they don’t know the first thing about running a business as customer satisfaction is the most important key. Good bye.

Excellent pizza! We always order a large pie with pepperoni, mushrooms, and olives, and it is always cooked to perfection. The staff is so friendly and they always remember us and make us feel welcome. My perfect Friday night is our usual pie from Paradise and a glass of Blackstone merlot. As a regular, I am happy to give Paradise 5 stars on Unilocal!!!

This place is the best. I have been coming here since high school, and still come with the family usually once per week. They have awesome dinner and hero deals during the week (Mon-​Thursday) for $ 5. FIVE DOLLARS. You can’t top that. Eggplant parm for less than a Starbucks latte. Plus, when you dine in you get a basket of bread. And not just any bread, actual bread that is homemade on premises.
The service is great too, Joe, Moe and the gang will treat you like family. They will remember that your sister likes her pizza undercooked, that your mom likes her salad chopped and that you (Mandi) likes a side of sauce with the house bread. And their sauce is on point. Mmmmm. I love sauce.
If you live in the Commack area, you know Paradise. And while you are eating here, you may or may not have the lyrics running through your head, «Ohhhohhh Paradise! We’re knocking on heaven’s door!»
The six degrees of Kevin Bacon, Unilocal style.

Feel like I’ve been on a role lately with bad dining experiences, unfortunately. Came to this pizza shop for lunch and had gotten a meatball hero. First of all, hope this doesn’t sound racist, but I don’t trust an Italian restaurant that doesn’t have any Italians behind the counter. Should have went with my gut, but this had to be one of the worst hero’s I’ve ever had. I won’t be coming back.

This is where my family always takes me when I come to visit. This is the best Pizza I have ever had. Plus they have garlic knots. They sell pizza by the slice so if you can’t eat a whole pie it is nice. The staff seems to know my family so they are super awesome. I think they are nice to strangers too because it feels like a friendly environment to everyone who walks in. Good prices, good food, good people. what else can I say?

Pleasantly surprised with their pizza quality. They sell the pizza by the slice so if you are interested in sampling a real authentic N.Y. pizza then this is a cheap way to go and still get a great flavor. Delivery was fast and hot. Also ordered the baked ziti. The pasta was overcooked but, the sauce flavor was excellent.

I had a meat stuffed pizza delivered last night and it was delicious. My arteries may not agree but I will certainly be back. The staff is friendly and the delivery was quick.

The pizza is classic NY and the staff is friendly and they are efficient. Honestly, we order there every week and get the same thing — PIZZA! So I’m not sure about the rest of the menu. Still though as a neighborhood goto place, this is IT. We are a Paradise family for life!

Pizza /​Pasta.
Having volunteered to help my buddy shovel 2 tons of mulch on a sunny Saturday we had the dire need for food about halfway through.
Since this was right down the road, off we went.
The pizza was pretty good and the service was fine as well. Probably one of the better slices I have had lately.
Prices were average.
I’d go back for sure.

Not a bad slice.. . and doesn’t seem to pretend to be anything else. It was formerly owned by the same guy who ran East Northport’s Paradise Pizza (
), though this place has apparently been independent of them and under current ownership for the past 15 years. They do crispy Neapolitan, grandma’s, and whole wheat pies (@$ 2.50/ slice) and he’s running the ovens a good temperature.. . Paradise Pizza also offers a Italian lunch specials from the back kitchen. Your choice of bottled or fountain sodas.. . Seems to be a family place, kid-​friendly and involved with the community.