Bella Pizzeria

No idea how the food is. Ordered on grub hub. I called 90 minutes later and was told they do not deliver they far. No call. No email. Nothing. The scumbag who answered the phone could not have cared less that I was obviously angry.

Tried to place an order for Delivery, received an notification that the restaurant closed early.

Awful. When it was «Belleria» and owned by other people, it was the best. Now it’s awful. I think the cardboard box would’ve had more taste. Very disappointed.

Eh at best.
I would have given it 3 stars but the pizza was severely under cooked. We got a half sheet and were only able to eat the outer most edges because the rest was way too doughy.
The pieces we were able to eat were nothing remarkable.
On a side note, we incorrectly assumed cheese sticks would be cheese bread sticks but they were your standard mozzarella sticks. Straight out of the frozen food bag dumped into the fryer. Our mistake but I would certainly not recommend.
I highly doubt we order again but if we do I would def ask for the pizza well done.

Called to order since we have ate here once, and not the same place… thumbs down

New ownership and the pizza is not the same. Does anyone know if the real Belleria’s moved to a different location or just shut down all together?

There is a review that calls this pizza amazing, and that is plain CRAZY. If there were Unilocaling credentials, hers should be revoked for sheer silliness bordering on hyperbole.
It’s decent pizza, kinda like Little Caesars is decent. In a neighborhood with so many GREAT pizzas, I’m not really sure how these guys will make it.

Really great pizza! Sauce/​Crust has good seasoning, pizza is cooked thoroughly and hot, good cheese. Not much more to say. Would definitely recommend. They have some pretty good coupons on their website.

Three stars because this place is good, not great.
I ordered take out. 12 inch pizza with three toppings and extra cheese. The toppings are sparse, and I had to pay $ 1.50 per extra topping (I got one free). The cheesiness is great! When you pull a slice away, you get that wonderful string of gooey cheese that you have to grab a hold of, love it! Like I said, the other toppings aren’t really there. They definitely don’t spread them like Donatos. (Not that I prefer Donatos lol) But they seem like fresh ingredients.
The crust is nothing special. It reminds me of the kind you get at the grocery store that says, «Just add water!» I actually didn’t eat the crust for this reason. (After the first slice I tried, that is.) It’s not greasy at all though, so that’s a plus!
There was only one person working, that I could see, and he was super nice and smiley. Gave me some coupons too. Pizza was ready when I got there.
Overall, I would eat it again. But I wouldn’t say that I prefer it over all of the other pizza places near me.

I’ve tried a lot of pizza places in Columbus. None of them have been anything more than mediocre by my standards — lots of greasy pizzas, pizzas that clearly had low-​quality ingredients, or just weird, unappetizing flavor combinations. Finally tried this place last night on a whim (it’s in the same complex where we go grocery shopping). It was AMAZING. Best pizza place in Columbus so far. We had two Stromboli (the Meat and the Bella) plus the garlic cheese sticks. All of the ingredients were flavorful and fresh, plenty of melty cheese, amazing crust — two different types for the two Stromboli and both were fantastic (the Bella was a bit more crisp and firm while the Meat was softer). The garlic cheese sticks were loaded with mozzarella, the bread was crisp and fluffy, and the marinara sauce was clearly homemade — tastes like it has some real tomatoes in it, instead of the ketchup knock-​offs that a lot of places try to pass off as «pizza sauce». The place was small and homey and had some nice décor. Service was fast and friendly, and prices were very reasonable ($ 9 for a small Stromboli that could easily feed two people).

Me and my wife just ordered a couple of subs, delivery was fast and friendly, food tasted great.

Tried to order lunch for our office today and met with a terrible attitude on the other end of the phone. The pizza is good, but it’s not worth dealing with someone who was very put out to have to answer the phone.