Angelina’s Restaurant & Pizzeria

Walked about a half mile further to go eat here based on reviews. Totally worth it!
Great pizza and service. A bit pricey, but I would pay it again for the quality. Ordered a decent draft IPA. Again, pricey at $ 8 for a craft beer at a pizza joint.

I am just seeing this nice reply you left me 2 years Ago… Thank you! I have recently moved again… But frequented all of your places in my two years there… food was always great! And staff really great!!! Wishing you continued success and looking forward to coming for a visit!

Although this is basically a pizza place, they took very good care of me with my gluten free and dairy free needs. They do have a full menu to choose from, even for me. And the staff could not have been nicer. So thank you. And the veggies were great!

If you asked me 2 or 3 years ago for a good pizza spot in cold spring, Angelinas would be my one and only answer. But lately I feel like they are very inconsistent. One day you order and get a great pizza, the next you get a burned crust, or soggy crust.
I still love Angelinas, unlike others, I think their staff is great. Always super friendly and outgoing. But the lack of consistency is frustrating. I have found myself cheating on them with other pizzarias.

I stand by 3 stars, however since the owner called me out for not giving a well thought out review, I will do him a solid and expand on my previous statement.
We were headed to a show at HVSF and stopped in for a quick bite along the way. We indicated during the ordering process that we had limited time. Hence why we stopped at a pizzeria, and not elsewhere. We ordered an Italian combo sub and 2 slices of pizza. The sandwich was sub par. The meat was sliced too thick for my husband’s liking. Thick sliced deli ham is typically not something you find on a sub. The pizza was ok. Unremarkable. Certainly nothing special.
The location is convenient, but the service is hap hazard. We patiently waited while our credit card sat at the front while the waitress rushed back and forth to serve slices from a whole pie to a family that assured her that they wanted to do it themselves. We waited again while she individually served salad from a larger platter to individual plates, while again that same family assured her they wanted to serve themselves. While her above and beyond service was unwanted by that family, our table, along with another, simply wanted to be checked on during the course of our meal and allowed to leave and free up space for other diners. Perhaps on a Friday night additional servers (or perhaps the guy behind the counter) could step in for the assist.
This was not our first visit to Angelina’s, but it will be our last, as we have experience similar service related issues on a past visit.

Updating this review with an explanation for the formerly nice Mr Jamal. The former review was a draft I was working on for a while but had not posted. I was trying to give a fair assessment of my experience dining at Angelina’s over numerous visits, not just based upon one order. Consistency is a problem in most areas here-​the food quality, the service and dining experience. Mr. Jamal’s insulting response and insistence that everything is always perfect at his establishments shows that not only is he a megalomaniac, but a blind one as well. Removing one star for the toolish response.

Quite excellent… The tiny storefront in a strip mall is a misleading indicator of the quality of this restaurant. My family of four shared a Pizza from Mars and a calamari appetizer and left quite satisfied. The pizza was delicious and the presentation very appealing. We will likely eat here again during this visit to West Point, and make this a regular stop during future trips.

I would recommend their pizza from mars, it’s so good! And im really not a pizza person but I have not had anything from there that I didn’t like.(Even the different kinds of pizza) and i am so picky when it comes to pizza so that says a lot about how good it is! I have had their teramesu maybe 5 or 6 times and i loved it, except the last time I got it it tasted strange to me but that’s the only time I didn’t like something from there! I would definitely recommend for anyone to go there, they really do have great food! And the people who work there are very nice!

Angelina pizza joint has great pie. We ordered a half –half tree hugger and bbq chicken, both the pies were fresh made to order and found to be very delicious. We also ordered a beet salad– which also turned out to be great. We have also tried margarita pizza — which is nice too. The service was very attentive and friendly.

Over-​rated. Pasta was not homemade, pizza was ok but not special, salad was reasonable price but not special. Coffee was like water.

I wish this place had better service. As a local I frequent Angelina’s quite often, but this is mainly since there are not many places that deliver in town. Actually they are the only place that delivers sometimes. I don’t understand that system but … The food is always yummy, but I have had to wait almost 2 hours for a chicken wrap and side of meatballs. Please get it together.

Very disappointed in their takeout food. We have been trying them out for a few weekends over the winter as a result of local comments about the quality and value.
Last week my husband and I ordered a few slices of «specialty pizza» and an eggplant hero and the slices came with the wrong toppings and very little toppings for the extra $$. The eggplant hero was so bad we threw it out.
Before posting here, I sent the restaurant an email from their site explaining the situation and asking for a refund. No response. Well, no more Angelina’s .
We have a lot of wonderful choices in our area, Angelina’s is not one of them.

Finally got the chance to go to Angelina’s on my day off. What really brought me in that day was the picture of their garlic knots. When we got there we were greeted by the owner, Kamel and a basket of knots on the house. We love his other two locations Beacon Bread Company & Tito’s Taqueria. I ordered a plain slice, to get a feel of the place. Of course it was DELISHHHH. My boyfriend had a BACON EGG & CHESSE SLICE. Thats right, a bacon egg and cheese slice lol. You know I had a bite or two of that. Very yummy. The little one loved her plain slice as well as a beautiful chocolate cupcake that of course she ate all the icing off first. (On the house AGAIN). Definitely going back for a slice when I’m in cold spring again.

Have been coming here basically since it opened — so for years — and cannot recall a single sub-​par experience. The recipes, freshness of the ingredients and friendliness of the staff are all so consistent that it’s the perfect go-​to spot in the area for a great lunch or dinner.
The owner, one of the most hospitable people you’ll meet, has a done a lot to bring an elevated dining experience to a classic Italian restaurant while maintaining a casual ambiance. The eggplant rollatini are fluffy and delicious, while the pizzas have an elegant thin crust and are never too greasy. The pastas are also fantastic — the farfalle a la mascarpone is so decadent yet not nauseatingly rich, and the chicken bruschetta is perfectly paired with angel hair. Overall NYC-​quality food with upstate New York prices… what’s not to like?
Don’t forget to ask about the baked goods — the owner’s wife is a master baker!

Food is awesome. We got the lunch special. The spicy chicken tortilla soup was amazing, the pizza was above average, and the chicken roll was good. Will definitely come back when I hike around the area.

We’ve been eating at Angelina’s since 2010 on our way to hike the nearby mountains. We’ve always enjoy the cool relaxed vibe & the good food here. They have craft beer — doc’s cider!!! lagunitas IPA! and Feltiman’s Ginger Beer for minors. Their pizza has paper thin crust which turns crispy when heated. I’ve eaten eggplants with marinara & basil, mushroom with spinach & cheese, and my bf BBQ chicken and we were very satisfied with the quality of food, the service of friendly & prompt teenage waiter, and the price: 4 pizza & ginger beer rings up to $ 16. Can’t beat it! On a crisp October Sunday afternoon we were in & out in less than 30 min with full stomach & satisfied taste palette. I highly recommend this place to anyone grabbing a quick bite!

Super friendly service, the waitress was really patient with us and our «animated» 3 month old. M-​Th you can get 2 pies for $ 20. The pizza is pretty good with a decent amount of cheese and tangy sauce. The crust is just right and crispy.

First time in Cold Spring. Loved this restaurant. Welcoming & friendly server. Ordered the Mars Pizza everyone writes about and they were correct. It’s delicious. Good for sharing with a friend. Also shared the mixed green salad. The food was plenty for us. We also bought two orders of tiramisu to go. Which is made by the owners wife. When I return to Cold Spring next time I will definitely plan to dine here again.

I had Sorgente Fredda Pizza after 7 hour hike in Breakneck Ridge. I chose this place because this place had the highest Unilocal rating in Cold Spring.
The pizza was amazing — I was able to taste the sauce, cheese, and all the little ingredients on the pizza. The pizza had a good balance of texture between crust and rest of the pie.
In addition, they had some amazing root beer from Sprecher. I’ve never had it until I was at this place, and I would recommend it to anyone who’s a fan of a good root beer.

Can’t attest to much more than the pizza slices and tortilla soup both of which were excellent. The pizza is thinner than NY style, I didn’t think physics allowed for this but it has a nice chewy crunch, sauce is perfectly herbed and you can add whatever you want to any slice before they serve it steaming hot. Best slice in Cold Spring.