I’ve had Donnagio’s a few times(called ahead of time and picked up), and enjoyed a quick bite each time. We like their buffalo chicken pizza, which is quite filling. Pretty standard as far as pizza goes but it’s a convenient walk from my boyfriend’s place, so that makes it easier.
Michael B.
Tu valoración: 4 Cliffside Park, NJ
Y’all out there are way too hard on this place. Instead of kvetching about this and that, why not put the nit-pickyness aside and realize this place for what it is, a perfectly good basic pizza place(also somebody’s business where they’re trying to make a living). They make a good, chewy-crusted pizza with just the right amount of sauce and it gets delivered HOT. So all y’all need to get down off your high horses, shut up and have a slice, m’kay? I think Stephen Baldwin had a line in a movie that went something like«pizza is like sex, even when it’s bad, it’s still pretty good». Well this pizza is pretty damn good, and it hits the g-spot. Period.
Daniel C.
Tu valoración: 5 Edgewater, NJ
We have been ordering from This restaurant for around five years. By far, they have the best pizza around. You asked for it well done– It comes well done. Their delivery is fast, and the delivery guys are all good guys. Try their sausage and Pepper hero, with the bread toasted. The chicken marsala dinner is very good too. Try the garlic bread also. u
Vivian L.
Tu valoración: 1 Cresskill, NJ
I want to give this place zero stars. Ordered from grubhub for a delivery of mere distance of 0.6 miles. As I’m writing this review I am STILL waiting for my pizza that I ordered 90 minutes ago. I dont know whether they are harvesting the wheat for the dough or something but this is unacceptable. When I called their only explanation was that the delivery guy has already left. Don’t order from here if you want to eat your food on time. — — — - Update: called back after waiting another 30 minutes and no one is picking up and it says that they are now closed. I’ve never even heard of this and i am appalled. This place should NOT be in business and this is so ridiculous and rude. If I could I would give you negative million stars. Seriously disgusted.
David B.
Tu valoración: 4 Elmwood Park, NJ
I always order from here becuase its good pizza, and close to my house. It’s your usual pizza place, Delivery person is usually polite. Food is still hot when it arrives. I don’t really have anything bad to say about this place. Price is average compared to other pizza shops.
Billy V.
Tu valoración: 3 Cliffside Park, NJ
walking down the street saw donnagio’s pizzeria oh baby I am hungry decent looking slices for sale give me a slice buddy no, no give me a sicilian yes, yes a sicilian corner it said eat me that baby was in the oven i knew it had all the food groups oh yeah i am ready guy serves slice i knew it was cold in center cheese not melted corner not crispy took first bite yup i was right but i was so hungry just demolished this poor baby what behooves me why can i see this dude who works there does not com’on man warm pizza is cold pizza bummer hot pizza yum, yum ownership train, train, train can’t pay your winter home with cold pizza i must admit pizza slice was good just warm one thing make sure my next baby is hot, hot, hot just like my women till we meet again…
George M.
Tu valoración: 4 Ridgefield, NJ
I’m a regular customer of the Cliffside Park pizzeria. As the previous reviews mention, this is not a gourmet or all organic pizzeria, but they don’t claim to be. They are a solid neighborhood pizzeria that I think is reasonably priced. They are almost always open(even during some of last year’s really bad snow storms) and I’ve never had any issues with the quality or service here. I would like the pizza’s a little crispier, but I also know that’s tough to accomplish for pies that are boxed and delivered. The wings are always good, though. If you live in the area and are looking for a solid pizzeria, I would recommend them.
John L.
Tu valoración: 1 Cliffside Park, NJ
This place is way too cheap on the cheese for the amount of dough plus pizza was overcooked. The whole pizza tasted like the crust. It’s also too overpriced for less than mediocre pizza. $ 40 for 2 orders, which I wouldn’t mind if it tasted good. To put it simply, even the dollar pizza joints in the city taste better than this. First and LAST time ordering from here!
Sammiie M.
Tu valoración: 2 Cliffside Park, NJ
I, personally, would not order from here again. Firstly, their prices are really expensive especially since their products are not all that great. It’s not like their food is organic or even«gourmet». They’re just a regular pizzeria with the same food as anyone else. One of the few times I ordered from here, I got delivered. When coming out, I caught the delivery driver cursing under his breath saying«this f*cking b*tch.» Of course, he lightened up right when he saw me and took my payment, but still! That’s really bad to hear from someone delivering your food… It had me wondering if he wiped his ass with my pizza before he put it in the car.
Dean C.
Tu valoración: 1 Brooklyn, NY
Completely incompetent. Walked in to order a couple slices. Manager was on the phone and didn’t even glance at me. Guy from the back took my order. Not sure what happened after this, as my pizza never came out and both employees stayed as far in the back as possible. They need someone else to be making the pizza, so that the manager can handle the phone and in-person customers. Walked out after 25 minutes of being neglected.
Christopher D.
Tu valoración: 4 Lodi, NJ
Just came through with the kids spur of the moment cause they wanted pizza and this is some of the best pizza we have ever had. My pizza(Chicken Parm Slice And Buffalo Chicken Slice) were flawless full of flavor. Kids go plain and Mozzarella slices and they loved it. Only complaint is that place is real small not good for groups
Donald J.
Tu valoración: 2 Fairview, NJ
The food is decent, but overpriced. Unfortunately They take no pride in their work. As my photo shows my pizza was delivered with two slices folded over so the pie would fit in the box.
M P.
Tu valoración: 4 Lodi, NJ
Food is good, quick and reliable. I order from them a few times a month and never have any problems. Their subs and bread are particularly awesome!
Graham G.
Tu valoración: 1 Cliffside Park, NJ
Seriously? I ordered a pizza and a salad two hours ago, and here I am still waiting for it. When I called to check on the order(half an hour ago mind you) the staff have me the usual b.s. that it would be here any minute, that the driver left five minutes ago. I could have walked there to pick up my food in half an hour easily. Never order from this place, always takes forever for mediocre food at best.
Taline B.
Tu valoración: 4 Cliffside Park, NJ
I ordered catering for my sons first birthday party. I ordered a ton of trays, salads, lasagna, chicken parm & Marsala and a 6ft sub. I have no complaints. Everything was amazing and super easy. Set up, sternos, condiments, paper good we’re all included. The price was great a little above the average for the area but so worth it!!! Only because of how great they are at providing customer service and making sure everything is was superb. I order my pies from them now just because I can trust their quality and services.
Charlie M.
Tu valoración: 1 Cliffside Park, NJ
As of now I am officially done with this place. Had a horribly undercooked pizza about two months ago, now picked up a calzone that was 15 mins late, walked the block and a half home to an almost frozen middle. Clearly it didn’t cook for 35 mins so they obviously didn’t put it in the oven till I arrived and it never cooked through. was easier to walk here but I’ll be going to Sarges in Ridgefield for now on.
Billy C.
Tu valoración: 3 Fort Lee, NJ
Always get the Sicilian slice. Better of its kind in the area. But the prices seem to be high for regular or specialty pies.
Ellis H.
Tu valoración: 4 Fort Lee, NJ
I come here all the time with my friends to get a bite to eat, but this place never disappoints. Their garlic twists are great, and my favorite thing to get is the white slice, which always tastes amazing. The prices aren’t bad. The place is a little small but it’s comfortable. The staff is very nice, and there is a decent amount of options to choose from. Great place to get something to eat if you’re in the area.
Lynn B.
Tu valoración: 3 Cliffside Park, NJ
Donnagio’s pizza is pretty good. The shop is small. I’ve gone in for slices, but have never ordered delivery. The shop is small, with only about 3 tables. The staff is nice. It’s a good place to grab a nice, warm slice. The selection of slices is less than a lot of other places, but it’s also a smaller restaurant. The pizza is very yummy, but I’d like a bit more of a selection. Soda is served in cans, so it’s always good. They offer both Diet Coke and Coke Zero, so you get two diet selections. That’s always nice. I live very close and, on the upside, their drivers seem WAY more courteous than the Papa John’s drivers. Papa John’s drivers seem so hung up getting the deliveries out that they’ll mow you(and your small dog) down while you are crossing the street.
Michael Z.
Tu valoración: 3 Cliffside Park, NJ
Every time I’m in Cliffside I somehow manage to end up here. Most likely because it’s the ONLY place my boyfriend and his father will order from. I digress… Donnagio’s is decent. The pizza is pretty good. It’s hot and cheesy so there’s no real complaint. I like that their dough isn’t overly doughy. Their salads are great, especially the Greek one. The prices are reasonable.