Carmino’s Pizza

For the price, the pizza is not worth it. Overall, the pizza is mediocre to below mediocre. There are many other better options in the area. I recommend looking elsewhere.

Let me begin with the fact that I have ordered delivery dozens of times and the response to what I am about to impart was amazing… Ordered $ 50.00 worth of delivery and received sour cream that was expired a month ago. I called and told them that my son’s fiancé had taken a bite without realizing and it was bad. They offered me a $ 2.00 credit. I was incensed. I demanded to speak to an owner and met no better result. Needless to say the patronage is over and I will tell many as I can of my experience.

Always seems to be open late nights when noone else is, good specials pricing, and great wings and pizza.
Been going here for years and will continue to.
Thanks Carmino’s

No idea what the pizza is like, as we have yet to order it.
Got 8pc of chicken (~$ 12), a dozen JoJos ($ 3.25), jalapeño poppers (~$ 5), side of potato salad ($ 1.25), cheesecake ($ 2.49) and a peanut butter brownie ($ 1.99). Order was delivered and received in the quoted time. Not easy to do when the Cavs are on.
The food was just ok. The real issue here is seasoning, which there is none. The chicken has plain breading and could benefit from adding pepper or anything to it. Potato salad was bland. Poppers were ok, as it’s hard to mess up distributor-​made ones.
My guess is their distributor is GFS, because of the desserts. The cheesecake is good, but too small to warrant the price. The brownie however was excellent. Seriously, this would have been a 2 star review otherwise if not for that and the on-​time delivery.

Carmino’s is probably the best Pizza in the Brooklyn/​Old Brooklyn area. Their delivery times are inconsistent, and they are a bit expensive — but they use top shelf ingredients and that makes up for a lot.

Prices are ridiculous for what little food they give you. Tonight I got a large pizza for 9 $ the size of half of a normal little ceasers pizza, a 9 $ spaghetti «dinner» the size of my hand and aide salad the size of my palm and a dressing in the tiniest most absurd container ever!!! The food tastes great but for that price you’re better off going somewhere where you get your monies worth! Dongis, cleats, George’s shoot even little ceasers! Awful customer service as well, just completely rude and inconsiderate. I’m never going back.

Yummy yummy Carmino’s! First of all we just moved from Oregon and received a coupon for a free coupon … Not a buy 1 get 1 free coupon but just a Free pizza coupon Which is weird and AWESOME! I called the pizza in and they were über friendly on the phone but that’s cool. They were quick and to the point I arrived 20mins later when they asked me to, I wish it had been a little hotter kept. The man was sweet and secretly asked if he could offer my son a sucker which I said yes to and my son was very satisfied with his tootsie pop. We got home and hubby and I indulged!
Fresh cheese, meats (pepperoni and sausage), fresh sauce and the best pizza crust I have ever tasted! It was so good!
A few weeks later we ordered another pizza and it was $ 10 for a large and it tasted just as good! Can’t wait to go back!
I wish the parking was better. The back area looks super shady. :-(

If I can do zero stars I would. This place is not only rude and don’t know their own menu, their large pizza is the size of little Caesars small pizza. The management is rude and their «not normal» according to the managers reasoning. I would steer clear from ordering from this trashy place.

I see most reviews on here deal with delivery; which I haven’t dealt with personally. This review deals with the visit me and my girlfriend had for dinner in the restaurant.
The atmosphere was very nice and open and quaint. The service was average, but what sold me on this place were the quality of the food AND the value.
We ordered a small pizza along with an order of breadsticks and our total was around $ 7! That alone for a Pizza Hut or Dominos would be a good deal, but this is some high quality pizza we’re talking here. The breadsticks were light and fluffy and full of flavor and everything on the pizza tasted fresh.
I recommend highly that if you had a bad delivery experience, go sit in for dinner or lunch because I think you will be pleasantly surprised. They get an A for me.

«Try something new!» I said to myself this afternoon. «Surely there are some great mom and pop pizzas out there I’ve missed.» I said to myself.
I should have just ordered Pizza Hut.
Ordered at 2 pm on a Saturday, arrived an hour and a half later at 3:30. A $ 4 delivery fee plus a five dollar tip. I ordered a taco pizza, thin crispy crust. An hour and a half later I got a pizza so undercooked that despite using a spatula, I couldn’t even get a slice without everything sliding off. Sad. Finished cooking a piece in a skillet and the pizza still sucks. I also ordered a pepperoni and sausage pizza which was… passable I suppose.
What is it with Cleveland pizza? It’s a sad state of affairs. In other areas of this state, every corner deli has pizza that is better than most everything I’ve tried in this city. The amount of times I’ve received a pizza with an unfinished doughy crust (and I usually order well done!) is downright pathetic.
It’s pretty sad when the Hut is the best option for delivery pizza in Ohio City. Sainato’s is very good but very pricey.

February 28: Ordered at 723pm. Told 1 hour and $ 5 delivery. Made follow up call at 853pm, told on its way. 926pm received call from driver for directions. Pizza arrived 15 minutes later. Cold food and grease over everything! Breadsticks doughy, not cooked all the way through. Wing «sauce» was wing grease. Pizza may be delivery but tastes like Di’Giorno. The one star is for the full refund we got today when we stopped in the store requesting one. Nice, although the Manager never apologized or asked us to give them another try, but rather made an excuse saying ‘Yeh, we were busy last night.‘
One of the most disappointing pizza experiences ever. If the food was good it would have been worth the wait… kind of. But both were horrible.

Delivery took 1 hr, shop is 15 min. away depending on traffic, Del. guy was very friendly But Pizza or Pie WAS Cold, outside temp. at Del. time was 40 degree’s had to heat it up in the oven to eat it!!!
This was our first time for this pizza shop for us, could have done better

The best wings in the Cleveland area. The Rush Inn in Lakewood comes close, but this is the real «Wing King.» The sauce is top-​notch (we ask for extra sauce each time). And the wings are big and cooked just right. The pizza is great. We always ask for extra sauce and sauce for dipping, but we’re sauce hounds. They also deliver to Ohio City which is well worth the $ 4 delivery charge (plus: the delivery bros are swell).

Ridiculously good. Open late, fantastic solid pizza. Crust has a great flavor. The bbq wings are addictive! Love the online ordering function. I cannot say enough great things, it’s the best pizza delivery option we’ve ever had.

They would not delivery to zip code 44 113, a zip code listed on their site. Apparently is depends on the actual address, not the zip code. I think every business should be aware of who they are trying to reach.

Great wings, good pizza, and fair prices. Can’t ask for much more. I’ve been ordering delivery from them about twice a month since moving to the area. The wings aren’t breaded :(but the sauces are good.

This place has been tossing pies since 1970 so I’m pretty sure they know what they’re doing. Our first visit to the little shop on Pearl Road only served to further prove the point.
We placed our order online and decided to pick it up. Not because we didn’t trust their delivery but because we live 5 minutes away and we didn’t wanna get socked with a $ 2 delivery charge. Their menu is expansive for a pizza place. They’ve got salads, wings, stromboli, sandwiches, and pressure-​cooked chicken. I think I even saw pork chops on the menu. The space is larger than you think it’d be. You enter beneath the marinara-​red awnings from the front, take a sharp right and another left. The counter is right there flanked by a couple of little pinball machines. Around the corner is a dining area if the eating there thing is more your style. Now on to the good stuff.
The pizza at Carmino’s is old-​school. You’re not going to find truffle oil or Peking duck on any of their pies and this is a good thing. Sometimes you just want a pizza. You know the kind. Thick, crunchy-​chewy crust, slightly sweet tomato sauce, fresh toppings. It’s a neighborhood pizza joint that wears its heart on its sauce-​stained sleeve. A large pizza is eight slices and plenty for two with room left for lunch the next day.
The breadsticks, lightly buttered, dusted with Italian seasoning and served with a small cup of marinara for dipping, were soft doughy and delicious. The turkey and bacon salad was not mind-​blowing but definitely more than expected — iceberg lettuce, sliced tomato, red onion, a couple of olives, crispy bacon and a few strips of deli meat turkey. Macaroni salad like mom used to make, simple, no-​frills. It’ll take you to a 4^th of July cookout in January.
Carminos does it right. While I can’t vouch for the rest of the menu’s offerings (I’m not sure I’d go to a place like this to order fried fish or chicken) the pizza won’t disappoint. Don’t waste your money on that sauced cardboard that Little Caesars is schlepping nowadays. Spend a couple more bucks, get the real deal and support local business.

This is the best delivery pizza in the Cleveland Metro area. They have delicious crust and the sauce is good. They have some good appetizers and sandwiches too. The meatball sub is especially tasty. We’ve been getting delivery from them for years and they rarely disappoint. A couple of times the crust was extra salty but that is out of dozens of pies I’ve had from them.

I ordered from here a couple weeks ago and was very surprised that you can order online and they deliver to Ohio City ($ 4).
The delivery guy was super friendly.
Stromboli: for the price, it was kinda skimpy. I also ordered French fries and the amount was ok.
Maybe I would repeat and try something else. The menu is huge lol.

This pizza is amazing! They have quick delivery and the Chx Bacon Ranch pizza is some of the best I have ever had. I get Carmino’s a lot and I have never had any customer service issues, delivery time issues, only excellent pizza! Crust is just right, cheese is melted to perfection and you get a bang for your buck. I highly recommend sampling the goods…