Catalina’s Pizzeria

So we order from this place at 10pm. After an hour we call. Supposedly they are behind so we say alright. Fine we’ll wait. 40 more minutes go by, still no food. I call. They lied and said the driver came and called 3 times. My boyfriend and I were sitting on the couch waiting, no call, no ring at the doorbell, nothing. Yet they call me and we call them perfectly fine. Next thing I know «the driver is too far and wants to cancel.» 2 hrs almost go by and it’s midnight on a Sunday. We were trying to feed 4 people that are now starving because this place can’t even deliver properly. How do you not ring a doorbell. Seriously. NEVER AGAIN. Pathetic.

The pizza is awesome, the cheese fries are fantastic, the fried mushrooms could use a little work, but 5 stars regardless because the owner/​manager really appreciates and cares about his customers! All that, and everything was really inexpensive and there are some really great deals. We’ll definitely be going back and exploring other items on this wide menu.

Heard of this place from a friend and it didn’t disappoint. Great customer service, Pizza was great and the Catalina burger was delicious. Will be returning soon.

Awesome customer service. Very friendly. First time here and it will definitely NOT be the last time. Food was very good. My kids are picky but was able to find them something to eat and they were happy with the variety as was I.

I ordered pretty late after I got out of work for pizza and had the fastest delivery ever I really enjoyed their pizza. Anybody who’s looking for a good pizza with fast delivery come here!

Profesional and friendly environment, really enjoyed my food. Ordered the Buffalo burger and some cheese fries. Recommend stopping by, and definitely coming back.

Pizza is so good the sausage is the best took 50 min 2 get pizza but well worth it. SO GOOD

This pizza place is alright when getting something last minute. I ordered a half cheese and half pepperoni pizza, and I got a half pepp and half sausage pizza. I didn’t make an issue about it because I know this happens. After repeating what I originally wanted and waiting patiently for my correct pizza, they once again got my order wrong! I couldn’t believe they got it wrong a second time, and having a hungry child there was no way I would wait another 15mins for my correct order. I ended up leaving. These people need to seriously pay attention to guest orders. The place wasn’t even busy which was even more unbelievable to get my order wrong twice! This will be my last resort pizza place to order from.

Very solid thin-​crust pie. Tangy-​sweet sauce, savory-​sweet sausage, good crunchy chew on the crust, just the right amount of cheese. Good stuff.

First time visit today I walked in very nice place small and cozy. Watched a little tv and had the best slice that I had in a while there sausage taste like old school pizza joints when i was kid. I will return with the wife and kids

Yum! I got a slice of sausage pizza
It was huge and crispy and gooey!
I added some jalapeños and I ate the whole thing– something I never do, but this was just too good to put down.

This place has great pizza and really helpful and friendly staff members such as Heather. I will be frequenting this fine establishment more and more now that I have had a taste of their sweet delicious pizza pie. YUMMY!!!

Should have order pizza hut… I mean the delivery was fast and the guy was nice but the pizza had no taste and the crust was a little doughy. never again

There was no taste to the burger meat we ordered nor the Gyros meat. All of the juices and taste were pressed or frozen out of them. Odd. The fries and pizza puff were ok, but then again it is pretty hard to mess up deep fried food. The food came quick and was of good temperature. I will give them that.

The pizza is mediocre at best. Ordered a salad to go with it. It was so drenched in dressing it was inedible. This place isn’t competing. There are much better pizza options available in this town. Don’t waste your money on this place.

(Did not try the pizza). I ordered rotisserie half chicken and chesse burger with side of mac& chesse and mashed potatoes thru grub hub. the food was horrible! Problem #1Raw burger and halfway cooked fries #2 rotisserie chicken seasoning and sides super bland no flavor both. Looked like it was the instant kind that you microwave and the chicken was barley cooked enough to not get you sick:-(never again not even to try the pizza.

Great people work there. They are very friendly and good at what they do. Joey took our order and the cook Jesus was awesome. Cant complain for dollar slices, gyro, and a philly. Loved it will be coming back again when we get free time or are in the area.

A nice little neighborhood spot on Belmont just east of central. This neighborhood (my neighborhood) is seriously lacking the wonderful culinary and drinking spots I so much crave. So I am constantly on the lookout for so called «hidden gems» that are close to home. I am not sure I would quite call this place a hidden gem but the pizza is the best I have found in this hood.
They have only been open for one month at this point. Catalina’s is clean, the customer service was excellent and a solid 14″ pizza for $ 7 is a pretty fine deal. In addition, on Tuesdays they have a $ 1 slices which is quite an awesome deal along with .50 wings. So far so good. The pizza is not the best I have ever had but it’s a solid option this close to home. The crust was quite crunchy almost like a breadstick, which is better than a gummy, doughy crust some places have. Their sauce and cheese tasted fresh and the sausage was good although lacking a spicy kick which I usually like.
Overall a very fine option for the neighborhood. Definitely a place I will come back to.

I ordered for the first time here because they left me a menu on my doorstep. Well DO NOT ORDER a shake. My sons wanted one and they got ICY milk no flavor. Really if you don’t know how to make shakes… take it off the menu! I had to throw it out. The pizza was good but I had better, Gyro was good but the Italian beef was not that great.
Don’t think I’ll ordered again sorry.

The service and staff here are awesome. I was in the mood for something healthy after an intense workout down the block. Needless to say there aren’t many options in the neighborhood. I walked into this place with no high expectations. Well, I was shocked, their menu is on point and cater to all walks of life. Although, what I was in mood for wasn’t part of the menu I decided to ask if they would make something for me. They were pretty helpful. I asked for two chicken breasts with broccoli and carrots. 8 mins later I had a banging custom dish in front of me.
Anyways, after eating my meal I was still hungry. Their pizza looked delicious and part of me felt like I owed them after they went out of their way to serve me, so I decided order a sausage slice (there goes my diet, lol). Once again I was impressed. OMG — the cheese is delicious and the ingredients are fresh. Now, I’m picky when it comes to pizza, you know, being that I’m from NYC. But it’s honestly great pizza.
Kudos to you Catalina’s Pizza. You’ve made me a happy and loyal customer. I’ll see you tomorrow for breakfast. Yep, they also serve breakfast.