Bogo Pizza

This place is good and cheap. Buy one get one and the guy behind the counter with the tattoos is a super nice guy. I took Kosher and not kosher eating ppl here and everyone likes it. Get the boureka if you want something delicious and a million calories.

Please note five stars because they are what they are, and stars are qualified by comments following.
This is NOT really a sit-​down restaurant, although they do have tables and chairs for about 20 people. It’s structured as a take-​out establishment, on a busy corner, with very little parking nearby. Call in an order and they’ll bring it through the back door to you in your waiting car — or run in and grab your take-​out order.
They give two pizzas «for the price of one» — but because they are kosher, the price is quite high. Two slices of «regular» are $ 3.50, compared with about $ 3.00 per slice at competitors, and you get two regular pies for $ 22, compared with individual pies at neighboring kosher pizza shops for about $ 18.00 each.
The pizza is excellent — non-​Jewish friends claim it virtually measures up to non-​kosher pies available at top spots in Brooklyn and Manhattan Sauce is flavorful and fresh, crust is the right thickness, and balance between crisp and chewy, with the only flaw being not-​quite yeasty enough, perhaps due to their high-​volume not slow rising dough in a retarder. Real (albeit kosher) mozzarella melts nicely, and is well balanced and not overdone so as to overwhelm sauce (unless, unfortunately, you order «extra cheese»). Since I have a very hot (600) home oven and a pizza stone, I usually order «slightly underdone and unsliced» so I can finish it at home, and I get fresh, delicious pizza somewhat better than I can make myself, despite years of practice.
We often order the real Margharetta pie, made with fresh mozzarella and basil, which does NOT come «two-​for-​one», and thus is considerably more expensive, but I think worth it.
A tiny caveat would be that usually pies with «toppings» (mushroom, veggie, etc) are reheated slices from a display case and thus suffer slightly from not being totally fresh, although if you order a whole pie you overcome this.
Staff is attentive and friendly, and despite crowds at times (especially Saturday night right after Shabbos) they do their best to get you out quickly.
In summary, it ain’t the «Ritz», but the pizza is terrific!

The most affordable pizza place in the 5 towns area, and not bad either. Can use help with customer service but not horrible, food items in the showcase also look good although we always get fries and bogo pie.
Clean and plenty of seating, pizza is fresh and tastes great.

Not a lot of space to sit down, but they have good deals, and their pizza to my opinion is the most healthiest pizza in 5 towns. Not greasy at all, vary tasty and I heard that they can make any pizza of any shape u want. Like a heart shape and all that stuff. Pretty cool!

We gotv2 pies for $ 20 and they were very good all of them, plain, olive, and spinach! Although I was so excited Pinapple! Please have it in stock next time says this pregnant lady!

I needed a couple of pies for my daughter’s birthday. I owned a business for 20 years locally and learned how important customer service is. I was happy to see you were busy. After waiting on line for 15 minutes the server apologized to me explaining that there are no deliveries today. Undaunted, I said no problem, I’ll take your number and call in an order later. I called in my order only to be told «I’m sorry sir but we are not taking phone orders». If you’re busy then staff appropriately. Obviously, I took my business elsewhere.

Love love love the pizza!!! I totally agree with Jeff N. as good as Brooklyn pizza!
As for the other comments, ALL new businesses have kinks to work out! I see a huge improvement with Bogo, now offering delivery.

Growing up in Brooklyn, eating non-​kosher pizza (as I wasn’t kosher at the time), I must say that BOGO Pizza is comparable to the best slices eaten in 1980s Bensonhurst, Bay Ridge, Sheepshead Bay & Canarsie!
And two pies for $ 20!
MINK!