Yogurtz

Updating from 4.5 star to 2. I still think this is the best-​tasting local froyo. But this place has been going downhill in the past year. This updated review is based on about six or more visits this year.
No longer are you greeted with a friendly hello when you walk in the door (I really miss the woman with the long dark hair who might have been the manager.) Now the young employees hang out in the back when they’re not ringing up customers at the register.
The floor in front of the yogurt machines are always dirty now. The drip-​catches under the machines are also always dirty. This place used to be the cleanest froyo place around — now the staff disappears in the back instead of keeping things cleaned.
There also are flavors out constantly. This never used to happen. Now every time we come, several flavors are out. Today was no exception — SIX flavors were out. Unreal.
Come on, Yogurtz — please get your act together. Train your employees to keep the place clean and the yogurt stocked.

Not that great. 4 – 5 of machines don’t have yogurt, very few fat free and non dairy options. Available flavors were mediocre. Tiny amounts of fruit that is there: table spoon of mango and 1.5 strawberries.

Favorite fro yo place! The employees are pretty nice and always say hello when you walk in – they also do a good job of keeping all the toppings really clean and neat. Plus it’s right across the street from our house – so that’s convenient!

There are about half a million self serve froyo places in Indy, and I’ve probably been to them all. This one is definitely in my top two.
Yogurtz has a great variety of flavors — just enough to try an interesting combo, but not enough that it’s overwhelming. They also keep the same flavors daily with just a few rotating options, so you know you’ll probably get your favorite when you go.
They have a huge selection of toppings, too. Just about anything your little froyo-​loving heart desires!
The only drawback I’ve found is occasionally in the service. Some of the employees have been extremely helpful and friendly. I have, however, had some strange experiences such as watching one guy sneaking handfuls of toppings while standing at the counter, or walking into a completely empty shop with no employees in sight as we waited several minutes to pay for our treats. Kind of strange but, overall, we’ll be back to Yogurtz.

Disgusting. Only half of the machines were working and the place is dirty. This place continues to go downhill.

Best yogurt… end of story
Best yogurt… end of story
Best yogurt… end of story
Best yogurt… end of story
Best yogurt… end of story
Best yogurt… end of story
Hopefully my word count is now high enough satisfy the request for a narrative. I said what I wanted to say in five words!

This place looks amazing. The layout is open and inviting. They had a lot more flavors to choose from than normal yogurt places. At first, I chose the dark chocolate and brownie batter flavors just because their pictures look so delicious. Both flavors were powerful and phenomenal, but I would suggest dividing them in your cup. They’re too amazing to handle at the same time. I also tried the strawberry, raspberry, and lemon. My favorite way to eat frozen yogurt is with lemon pound cake. Their luscious lemon was the best lemon I have ever had and would have gone well if I had that pound cake. I also tried peanut butter, which was on point as well as their Tahitian vanilla. The vanilla was the only let down of the experience. They should just call it vanilla as it tasted exactly like the vanilla soft serve at McDonald’s. Also, I’m not a toppings person, but they have the biggest selection by far. Awesome toppings layout and awesome flavors really propel Yogurtz to one of the best Frozen Yogurt places I have been to.

Best froyo in all the land! I’ve tried Orange Leaf, Huddles, and Yogulatte; Yogurtz blows them all out of the water. The froyo here is thicker and creamier than the rest. Not to mention a much wider selection of flavors — my all-​time favorite is salted caramel pretzel. Never seen it anywhere else. The peanut butter is also fabulous.
Great froyo, clean and bright storefront, attentive and friendly staff. Yogurtz is very deserving of 5 stars!
*Opening up a Fishers location near 116/​Allisonville summer 2015!
*New loyalty program involves an app on your phone.

How have I not tried this place before?
Decided to give it a shot with my wife tonight after dinner. We went in looking for a quick small treat and walked out with two ¾ lb bowls of dessert. As you approach the madness that is their line, you’ll find a wall full of ice cream or custard flavors to choose from. You can have as many as you’d like, they charge by the ounce. Once you’ve collected your frozen treasures, you’ll turn and find a three sided self serve bar full of treats. Cookies, candies, hot fudge, caramel. Once again, they charge by the ounce. You can load as many of anything as you want! What a great concept.
I’ll have to stay away from this place as much as I can, but I will certainly treat myself every once in awhile to a delectable bowl of diabetes.

Great yogurt, nice employees. Good kids. Online coupons help too. We visit almost daily!

I love their frozen yogurt and their staff, I haven’t had any bad experience with them so far, they’re always nice and smiling.
Make sure to signup for their text promos, you’ll save some money if you start going there very often.
The design of the place is really modern and colorful. I love it.

Ok, that salted caramel pretzel flavor is ridiculous. Seriously. Super good. That flavor alone is worth coming here. At least to try it out. If salt, caramel, and/​or pretzels aren’t your thing, no sweat. They’ve got a bunch of other flavors for you to try. They also have a good amount of toppings ranging from fresh fruits to mochi to crushed Oreos. The service here was good, too. I was greeted when I walked in, and so was everyone else that came in. And while there was a party in front of me with several people that weren’t done putting their toppings on yet, the cashier quickly took my payment from the next register. The place was also very clean from what I could see. Many times, the topping section is a mess with crumbs and spillage. Not the case here at all. Overall, pretty dang good! I’ll be back for sure.

One of the best places to buy frozen yogurt. The salted caramel pretzel flavor was out of this world. The toppings they have is a pretty nice variety.
The décor of this place is pretty modern. They use clean and simple lines. Speaking of clean, the toppings are lined up well and doesn’t overlap or has cross contamination. This is important for my OCD hubby.

A good place to go meet your friends. They have the standard fro yo flavors plus a million more and a million more toppings. It is also a very good price for what you get.

Did you know this is the one and only Yogurtz? Oh yeah, baby. It’s local AND delicious. Two of my favorite things. Throw in the salted caramel yogurt and I’ve decided I’m just going to set up camp there. No lie. Their salted caramel flavor can’t be beat. It’s got a very distinct flavor that is insanely good. Go. Eat.

Excellent frozen yogurt, great location. Two registers and topping stations prevents you from having to wait in a long line behind slower patrons. Nice people and always very clean place.

I think I’ve been here 9 times in the last couple of months. I’m guessing this because at least the first couple of times I went, I didn’t notice the little tablet screen where you can enter your phone number to register your visits and get free fro yo after a while, but then I did and the last time I went, the screen told me that I’d recorded 7 visits. (And I just want to mention that I love this so you don’t have to carry around and keep track of another one of those little punch cards.) I may be addicted…
Now to be fair, I started coming during a week when my throat was sore and it hurt to swallow un-​soft food. And then a couple weeks ago I got my wisdom teeth out, and now it still hurts to chew un-​soft food. I think those are pretty good excuses to go to Yogurtz multiple times a week.
I’ve been to several self-​serve frozen yogurt places, and most of them are pretty good, but to me Yogurtz is perfection.
The staff is super friendly and immediately says «Hi!» to you about 80% of the time. You can sample whatever flavors you want before putting them in your cup. I think they change at least one flavor daily, so if you don’t go there as constantly as I do you’ll get to try plenty of different flavors, not that they don’t have enough variety already. My step-​mom loves it too because they always have a dairy-​free option, and my dad likes it because it’s pretty much all low or no fat and there are healthy toppings.
Did I mention deliciousness? And variety? You can get just about any toppings you want. My non-​crunchy favorites (because that’s mainly what I’ve been eating) are hot fudge, hot caramel, marshmallow topping, graham cracker crumbs, and strawberries. And my indecisive self doesn’t have to decide which kind I want (every kind I’ve tried is yummy) so I just get like 8 different kinds in one bowl.
It’s right across from my office, and most of my office loves it as much as I do.
The atmosphere is all fun, they play popular music and it’s all decorated in bright colors with lots of light. You can sit inside or outside, or grab it to go. It’s all up to you!
The only downside is the price — my half-​full small cup usually comes out to $ 5+, and a fuller small cup is more like $ 7+. But it’s worth it. I’m not sure if they could do anything else better. Go to Yogurtz!

Great concept.
You get the flavor of yogurt you want and the toppings you want however you want and then you pay for your own creation by weight. It’s really like a dessert buffet. From a business perspective, they save some labor in the food preparation arena.
The furniture and decorations are colorful and whimsical. Whomever designed the layout stole a chapter from the Apple Stores and deserves some kudos.
We’ll be back.

This place is really close to my job so my co-​worker and I come here a lot. I love the fresh fruit toppings and the Asian influenced ones (passion fruit popping boba, mochi pieces). Sometimes the frozen yogurt comes out a little on the soupier side so it melts really fast. I miss the mango sorbet, but the favors have never disappointed me. Definitely a better (aka healthier) dessert than running off the nearby dunkin donuts or panera bread. The inside is super clean, bright, with modern furniture, and a playful color scheme. Love this place :)

Yum! My new favorite froyo place. I used to drive all the way to Orange Leaf but now that this place open up… yay! Closer and lots more toppings!!! The owner seems like a nice guy. We hit up this place twice in one week! In freezing cold weather even.
I love their décor. It’s pink and green! Reminds me if Yogurtland in Cali. There’s a cute lil kid area to keep your tots occupy while you stuff your face. I’ll post pix of the place. This is definitely one of our favorites now. Can’t wait to go again.