The fat sandwiches are amazing !!! Perfect for a Sunday afternoon. Will definitely be coming back
MaryCatherine T.
Tu valoración: 3 West Caldwell, NJ
I love the food and have been ordering from here for years. But the new girl who answers the phone is completely incompetent and has messed up really expensive orders(70 $+) many times. If you want to keep customers it would be best to not mess up their orders(especially for long time customers). If she cannot handle big orders please put someone on the phone who can.
Gina I.
Tu valoración: 5 Caldwell, NJ
Can always count on a quality plain slice here. The owner is incredibly friendly.
Michelle K.
Tu valoración: 5 Caldwell, NJ
This is my family’s go to place for take out pizza. We always get the Casanova pie with prosciutto, fresh tomatoe slices, and black olives. It’s just really good thin pizza. Also a plus that they’re open on Sunday evenings! A few other pizza places in the area are not and that’s always the day we want to be lazy.
Allison L.
Tu valoración: 5 Wayne, NJ
I’ve never had the pizza here, but the«fat» sandwiches are incredible. Yes, they will destroy your waistline, but they will simultaneously change your life for the better. The guy behind the counter is really sweet and knows my order whenever I walk in(which means I probably need to cut back… It’s just so good!)
Marc S.
Tu valoración: 5 Verona, NJ
Cedar Grill is awesome! Call up and order your fat sandwiches!!! The owner, Rodger is very friendly and always accommodating to the customer’s requests. Definitely recommend Cedar Grill!
Brendan H.
Tu valoración: 1 Caldwell, NJ
Unfortunately I can’t recommend this place for pizza. Ordered a meatball pie tonight and the meatballs were just cut in quarters and tossed on top and it was very bland. It was also delivered with half of the cheese shifted off of the pie into one side of the box.
Joseph L.
Tu valoración: 5 Caldwell, NJ
Cedar Grill is our go to pizza place in a town full of pizza. My mom always wants me to order their«everything» pie when she comes. The various«fat» sandwiches also bring back great memories of my time at Rutgers. Gotta love this place.
Chris T.
Tu valoración: 4 Jersey City, NJ
This is my go-to spot. They have everything and almost all of it is solid. The pizza is my favorite in town; the crust is crispy without being hard. It can be a little inconsistent based on who’s working. The subs and fat sandwiches are good. The burger is a good value.
Sven S.
Tu valoración: 2 Caldwell, NJ
The pizza is okay, but it would be a lot better if they’d crank up the oven a little. They keep it at about 400 °F, which isn’t hot enough for the crust to set up properly.