Tony’s Pizza On Nostrand

I have been coming here for years! The owner is Brooklyn born and raised, working in one of the last black-​owned buildings in a swiftly gentrified neighborhood. He is a good man, an honest worker and I don’t have a complaint in the world.
This is EXACTLY what small, local business looks like: small staff to keep YOUR costs low, (homemade cookies 2-​for-​$ 1, $ 7.00 personal pizza) open for almost twelve hours a day and they are usually extremely busy; there will be mistakes and the more entitled someone is (i.e., calling for [delivery] mistakes during a STORM or frivolous attacks causing one-​star reviews) the less they realize it is a sheer PRIVILEGE to even be able to afford a meal; spend your Mom’s money somewhere else.
**Any time you order delivery, from anywhere, the risk that something will not be to your liking is extremely high… don’t be a moron and expect piping-​hot food in single-​digit weather.
I love this place and will continue to visit — any actual problems will be addressed in person… like humans and adults do. Period. New Yorkers aren’t rude, they say it straight up and to your face, which most transplants can’t handle. This is still Brooklyn.
**The last time I checked, every apartment comes with a stove. Don’t like it, have ridiculous expectations? Stay home and learn to cook.

Had their pizza twice and ended up regretting it and was just angry about it the whole time. The crust is like cardboard, the cheese is like plastic, and the sauce is too sweet. Its worse than the pizza they served when you were in school. I’ve heard their jerk chicken was good and if that’s the case, their store should be renamed Tony’s jerk chicken on Nostrand.

Ordered pizza for delivery and took 1hr 45min, and when pizza arrived it was cold and hard! What a disgrace, will never order from here again and definitely NOT worth the wait!

They straight up did not bother to even deliver our food. Don’t ever bother with this awful place.

Awesome! The Margherita pizza is awesome! The Meatball sandwich is sooooo good! Very happy with everything I have ordered so far. The pizza and wings deal is a great value and feeds a group of hungry teenagers. It’s all good with Tony’s :-)

45 minutes after placing the order, I called to check on estimated delivery. Man who answered the phone was ruder than anyone I’ve encountered in a long time. 75 minutes after I placed the order, my pizza showed up cold. That’s what I get for straying from Mike’s Pizza up the road.

It’s my go to neighborhood spot. I like the wings the best, particularly the sweet and spicy! Believe it or not their jerk chicken is really good as well. Pizza is a meh and I don’t eat it anymore as its too thick. But it’s s good go to spot in the ‘hood.

The slices here are pretty good and they have a couple types to choose from. I usually get a pesto slice with bbq wings which are DELICIOUS. good size and flavor. Not many places to find great wings in Brooklyn. The jerk chicken is Okay. Def not your uncles chicken made in a barrel but good in its own right.

The place was clean, the staff are friendly and the service is very quick. I ordered a buffalo chicken slice– the chicken was big chunks and the sauce was amazing! They’re reasonably priced @ $ 3 for specialty slices and $ 2 for plain cheese… can’t go wrong!

I’ve ordered a margarita pizza before, but my last order was just horrible.
(No impact on rating)
I ordered on seamless for me to pick-​up, and did not leave until I was notified that my order is ready. I don’t know why I received that notification, because I ended up sitting in the HOTTT pizzeria for an extra 20 minutes.
(Impact on rating)
I received a gross margarita pizza! The tomato sauce was very tangy. I’ve never had a pizza from them that was so acidic. And, the pizza could’ve cooked longer. (I was upset I had to wait longer, but did not rush them. I simply said OK when I was told it will take longer)
Hopefully this doesn’t happen again, but this order was terrible!
I wish I could’ve given a 2.5, but rounded up to 3 since I’ve had good pizza before. If I have better luck when I order again, the rating will increase.

Generous portions, reasonably priced plain slice, and good jerk chicken.
The plain slice is $ 2 which is cheaper than a lot of other places around the area which charge more for less. The crust is a bit thick and hard to chew once the pizza cools down, but at least you know they don’t skimp on the dough.
Jerk Chicken is super spicy. I once had a small order during the summer and I went through like 2 bottles of water in one sitting.
Calamari is good when its fresh out the fryer, but for delivery, it gets soggy because of the container they use (aluminum tray and plastic cover). Their fish in their fish and chips dish is actually pretty good compared to a lot of other places in the area.
Clean place, but a bit hot inside especially during the summer.

One of my favorite slices of pizza ever! Been going to this place weekly (sometimes multiple times in a week) because of the great pizza! Tony is great; restaurant is awesome; service and workers are solid as well. Glad to live right around the corner from such a great eatery!

Very clean, nice place to grab a slice of pizza. They deliver. Nice and friendly staff. Good and fast service. They now sell jerk chicken. Its not bad. Make sure to add some BBQ & jerk sauce. Its a combo sauce the store have. The jerk chicken is extremely spicy.

Awful and rude. I ordered from semless, my food was ready 2 hours later and on top of it, they made me pick it up. What’s the point of getting your food delivered then? And then they refused to give me napkins and cups.

MAKE IT HOW YOU WANT IT
In a city that is a home to more than 8 million people you have to have your favorite spots. This is one of those spots that is good for ALL cultures. Surrounded by Caucasian, African American, Mexican, Australian etc the food fits the bill for taste and convenience. PLUS they DELIVER (rain sleet or snow)
If you are just a regular kind of Joe the Lasagne is a wonderful blend of meat, cheeses, tangy sauce and pasta. If you’re into something different they offer chicken and mustard pizza (sounds like an odd combo but worth it) and various types of oddities that you really don’t expect a pizza place to offer. (Jerk Chicken, pineapple pizza, various kinds of lasagna and pastas (vodka penne cooked with real vodka… who does that?)
Atmosphere is clean and customer service is on point. Located in the heart of Brooklyn and easy to get to …(2 train president st or 3 train nostrand ave)…plenty of seating. Good for a cheap date that you’re not to sure if you should introduce to mom or dad just yet. Cops are always there (Dunkin Donuts across the street Nuff said)
Drawbacks…Margarita pizza they blend the leaves into a sauce kinda kills the flavor a bit. …Took out the restroom for patrons… tend to want make certain items fresh, so if you’re in a rush may make you a bit late.
Top 5 pizza spot in Brooklyn for a bachelor or bachelorette.

The pizza is great. I’ve been ordering from them for a year and am happy everytime. Had a big party and everyone was asking where the pizza came from. I also order other entrees from them and haven’t been disappointed. It’s not gourmet but still satisfying red sauce Italian. Also, the mini cannolis are delish and the perfect small dessert for a sugar craving.
The delivery is consistently on time.

Seriously this pizza place is awesome. This place is serious about Catering to the community. One major thing Tony’s does is serve jerk chicken, baked Mac and Cheese and other items that people who are from the West Indies will enjoy. Every Labor Day they serve these items and most people who leave here after a quick meal are not disappointed. I especially like their jerk chicken. IT MIGHT BE THE BEST JERK CHICKEN in the AREA!
Check it out!

My first time here… I didn’t enjoy the pizza. The crust was a bit too hard for my liking. My son and I only ate half of a slice and threw the rest away which I normally don’t do. I will definitely try it one more time before I swear it off.

Okay. Wow. Wow wow wow. My review is based on a delivery order, but all I can say is wow.
On July 5^th I was so hung over I was bedridden for the whole day and couldn’t keep anything down. However at dinner time, when my stomach settled and realized I hadn’t eaten anything all day, I got so hungry so fast that the only thing that would suffice would be pizza. A really, really good pizza.
So I went on seamless, found Tony’s, saw their menu, and promptly ordered the bacon cheeseburger pizza. The delivery time said an hour, it got here in basically a half hour, and was super hot and super fresh and I was SUPER excited to eat it. It was the mostly glorious thing I’d ever seen. It came with hamburger, bacon, mozzarella AND American cheese, onions, and ketchup… my mouth is literally drooling just thinking about it.
The pizza was so big (a large) and was being split between two people, so we would each get four slices. However, I could only eat half of my serving because it was so filling… and I had eaten literally nothing all day.
I can not WAIT to order from these guys again because all of their pizzas look delicious, with fun ingredients and interesting combinations. Best pizza in the area hands down.

No thanks! We tried Tony’s by way of our somewhat limited Seamless options in our new pad.
My pizza was so soggy and floppy, looking like a $ 5.00 umbrella after a thunder storm. My boyfriend didn’t even bother finishing his calzone. The calamari or shall I say rubber bands with marinara sauce, well they speak for themselves. Barf!