This is by far my favorite Pizzeria. Not only is it decently priced but the food is to dieeeee. I am not over exaggerating. Their riceball parm. MMMMM. I’m drooling right now thinking about its deliciousness. Seriously, you want some amazing pizza, this is the place to be.
Stefanie R.
Tu valoración: 1 Brooklyn, NY
I ordered from & added special instructions under items I ordered(one of which was please give me a little grated cheese), which were not followed at all. They didn’t even call me to ask about the special instructions(I would’ve paid extra if I had to) even though They already nickle-and-dime you for every little thing and the delivery guy kept repeatedly hitting the bell as I was walking to buzz him up(and I walk pretty quick I’m 30, not 80). The food itself, was ok. Like 2 – 3 stars imo but they really need to work on their customer service skills
Lung M.
Tu valoración: 5 Brooklyn, NY
This is my neighborhood pizzeria. I have been coming here regularly for about 5 years now. The owners are extremely nice and respectful. I usually order slices and the rolls. I would recommend the sausage and pepper roll. It smells amazing. They have a nice cable TV setup where you can watch tv while waiting for your food.
Reda L.
Tu valoración: 4 Brooklyn, NY
Food is good… every time I go they have great food… nice place…
Lyubomir T.
Tu valoración: 5 Brooklyn, NY
Great food, I had the Alfredo pasta chicken and it was really tasty, the food is great overall.
T G.
Tu valoración: 4 Manhattan, NY
It’s decent pizza, but a little pricey. The Marguerite has lots of garlic. I like the Zepoles, but only when the owner makes them. Nice and light and fluffy. Otherwise, dense and greasy. The deal is pretty good — two regular slices and a can of soda or bottle of water for $ 5.50. The chicken roll is also not bad. I always ask for sauce on the side to dip. A bunch of pizza joints have come and go and Nicky’s survives them all.
Alyssa T.
Tu valoración: 5 Bath Beach, Brooklyn, NY
My family and I love Nicky’s. We have been getting their pizza every week for about 10 years. Great pizza, great sandwiches/rolls, but the best garlic knots you will ever have.
Dan S.
Tu valoración: 3 CORDOVA, TN
The pizza is ok… which would be alright if it wasn’t so overpriced for what it is… if you don’t mind dumping toppings on semi-bland pizza… Go ahead.
Tom m.
Tu valoración: 5 Brooklyn, NY
Great pizza, nice people. Makes living in this neighborhood that much more pleasant!
Jessica B.
Tu valoración: 5 Brooklyn, NY
The best eggplant parm! What makes them better than others is the cheese they use, it’s not cheap! Must try their margheritta pizza for those garlic lovers! I can eat a whole pie!
Big D.
Tu valoración: 4 Bath Beach, Brooklyn, NY
They really have great pizza, I order from them a lot. Just had there pizza today. Good garlic knots and sandwiches too. Clean place owners very polite and respectful. Not many places like this around here for the food and service they offer.
Gloria W.
Tu valoración: 4 Manhattan, NY
Sadly, this is my weekend place for brunch. I love their pizzas, rolls and garlic knots. I usually buy it from them cause its convenient. Half the time, they don’t have the knots! I get frustrated when I have the craving for it and they dont have it.(I’m not prego, its my princess syndrome) my boyfriend made a few complaints about it when he tries to be sweet and bring home knots and they dont have it. Guess it’s not our lucky day !
Rita L.
Tu valoración: 4 Manhattan, NY
4 stars for the tasty & burst of flavor in the garlic knots! The caesar salad with grilled chicken is pretty bangin’ here too, but not worth the price. I mainly come here for the garlic knots.
Austin N.
Tu valoración: 2 Bensonhurst, NY
Delivery was quick, but food was disappointing. The pizza along with the calamari were bland. The mozzarella sticks were good, but it included a «marinara» sauce that they added tabasco to which was pretty off putting. There are too many spots serving similar food in this area to come back.
Brietta Y.
Tu valoración: 4 Brooklyn, NY
Definitely the best garlic knots I’ve ever had as recommended by a friend but the beef patty with cheese and philly cheesesteak were only ok.
Justin P.
Tu valoración: 5 Brooklyn, NY
The only reason why this is a bit disapointing for me is because it took 40 minuets to get to my house. Other then that the pizza was amazing, and the pepperonni roll tasted excelent. I never ate more then 1 slice of pizza from a pizza place but this place i ate 3 i am a fan and will be back for more
Stanley W.
Tu valoración: 4 Brooklyn, NY
Good pizza. Service is good. Nice people.
Alice W.
Tu valoración: 5 Troy, NY
I pretty much grew up eating at Nicky’s. The pizza is your typical Brooklyn pizza, which is absolutely delicious, and they do have some pretty great garlic knots! Everyone is always friendly and willing to cater to your liking. I like having broccoli and chicken rolls, and though they don’t usually make those, they’ll make one for me if I ask for it. Great service. Great pizza. What more could you want? :)
Boris J.
Tu valoración: 5 Brooklyn, NY
Indeed, its your typical pizzeria. However, Its been my neighborhood Pizza spot since I was a kid. Many memories, many pizzas, never unsatisfied. Family run business who’s always friendly. I usually get a chicken roll or crispy slice.
Louis P.
Tu valoración: 4 Brooklyn, NY
I used to get penne with vodka sauce from here when i worked in the area and i have to say it was simply amazing! Their pizza is good too they have the usual varieties that other pizza joints do in the area but i can’t rave enough about the penna vodka.