Mike & Tony ‘s Pizza

The Best pizza in Prospect Lefferts Gardens. Great guys too

How do you mess up an order of fries? Lol
My mom said the fries were burnt and soggy all at the same time. I would be embarrassed to even sign off on sending an order like that with my name behind it. My boyfriend ordered the Philly cheesesteak and was beyond disappointed; he couldn’t even try to eat the second half. Only good thing was they arrived in good time.

Waited for 1.5 hours. Made with cheap oily cheese. Sauce is bitter sour. Crust was comparable to cardboard as it was stiff soft chewy. Looked like it was carried sideways as the cheese was all to the side.

delivery was fast!!! pizza is fantastic. definitely will order again.

Review based only on delivery.
I’ve ordered from them 3 times. Eggplant parm with pasta is really cheesy and tasty. Huge portions enough to share that evening and still have some leftover for lunch the next day. I also ordered a house salad. Salad size is large with a fair amount of toppings including cucumbers, red onions, olives and tomatoes. The buffalo wings are also really good and come with plenty of blue cheese to dip. I wish the celery was served on the side because the wings were so hot that they were a little wilted by the time I got them.
Delivery time is about average, ranging from 30 – 50 minutes but I find that’s generally to be expected.

This is the first pizza I ordered when I moved to Crown Heights. I ordered a pepperoni pizza and salad. The delivery was pretty quick for a Saturday. The pizza was good. It was cooked just the way I like it and wasn’t too greasy (as far as pizza goes). I will be ordering from this place again.

I’ve been getting pizza delivered from Mike & Tony’s for the last couple of years, and it’s been hit or miss. There are times when it’s really good, and times when it’s not that good. I’ve rarely been disgusted or anything like that, but I wish the pizza was more consistently good. Sometimes their delivery times are really long, like over an hour, but on average they are between 30−45mins. Tonight I ordered a pizza, and was surprised that it came in a CostCo Food Court box. Not really sure what that was about, but the pizza was different in texture and all the cheese had slid to one side. I hope they didn’t send out for a pizza from Costco, but I found the whole thing peculiar.

I would like to thank Mike and Tony’s for the following:
1: Thank you for having a busy signal and never picking up your phone
2: Thank you for having caveman customer service.
3. Thank you for showing me why you will never get my money again.

When this place first opened, the pizza was phenomenal. Really, really good. Free soda, too. The staff seemed happy to have your business. So they get two stars because one is for their legacy and the fact that they still seem to care, just not as much.
The last three times I walked in, I did not see anything I would eat, much less pay for. The pizza looked like old leather boots with sauce and cheese on top. I’m from Brooklyn. Pizza must look and be fresh and good, or I’m walking back out. Period.
Bring back the old, wonderful Mike and Tony’s!

I wish I could give it no stars at all. I ordered a wrap, buffalo wings and zeppoles. I was sooooooooo disappointed. My food took 1 hr and 15 mins to deliver and I live 4 blocks away. The grilled chicken wrap is disgusting the chicken was burned instead of grilled with no sauce the wings tasted alright and the zeppoles had no powered sugar on it when I specifically asked for extra powder.

Just moved to the area — saw them on Seamless — thought I would give them a shot as my new go to pizza place. Was pleased they offered a pepperoni/​pineapple pie. The delivery was fast — under 30min. The garlic bread was very good but the pizza was a disappointment. A 3 year old could count the number of pepperoni slices on the pie and the pineapple slices were cheap and more of a mulch then chunks. They can maybe serve this pre-​made pizza in store by the slice for a dollar but if someone is paying over $ 25 more care should be taken. Disappointed.
I’ve attached a photo — I will be trying out some of their competitors.

Sad to say that Mike and Tonys has gone downhill. Hubby and I had dissapointing delivery experiences with them as the pizza takes a very long time to arrive. The one occasion that the pizza arrived at a decent time, the crust was chewy and tasted old as if it was made a few days before and left out all day. Hubby came to the conclusion after witnessing in the shop that they precook the bread first and then put it on a rack until ready.

The pizza is a little less than mediocre. Called and had it delivered — took about 50 mins to arrive which is fine. I just thought it tasted like cardboard. I won’t be ordering from M&T’s again as there are so many better options in the neighborhood.

Mike and Tony’s prices are extremely reasonable. But the caveat: you get what you pay for.
If you are into burned, overcooked pizza, this is the place for you. If you enjoy waiting an inordinate amount of time for delivery, ring them up. If after waiting for said delivery and you expect for your order to be messed up, don’t worry. Mike and Tony’ s Pizza will gladly drop the ball.
I have no problems with getting lots of food for very little money. This place is good for that. However, my experiences — save one — have been terrible.
Forty five minute quotes on delivery have stretched out into being 2 hours. I have had to ask that they not overcook the pizza (no matter which kind) to always having it delivered looking like morning toast. The deliverer forgot parts of my order, etc.
I kept giving them chances. But at this point, I just have to accept what is plainly evident: this pizzeria is simply not for me.

I’ve had one or two slices from MIke & Tony’s that were RIGHT ON. I’ve had four or five that were greasy cardboard. This joint is just an on-​the-​walk-​home-​from-​the-​train stop, not a delivery choice. (Mike’s on Bedford, right?!) They give you a can of Coke every time you order two slices. I’m saving them up to use as a cleaning product.

Pizza is ok, but the last two times I ordered delivery, the pizza looked like it had been carried under someone’s arm (all cheese and toppings on one side of the box). I called and said what had happened, the guy said he’d make a new one, and here I sit well over an hour later, and still no pizza. Let’s hope they don’t make it three in a row with the cheese consolidated on one quarter of the box…
Edit: pizza was delivered an hour and and a half later, and instead of it being a pepperoni and mushroom pizza, like I ordered, it’s a cheese pizza. I have a mound of cheese, pepperoni slices, mushrooms, a sliced pizza dough, and a cheese pizza.
DON’T GO HERE.

Stay away, I don’t think Mike and Tony’s Pizza is all that but Mike has always been very nice and helpful and when ever I’m around I stop in for a slice. After today I will never be back… I came in order a Hawaiian and regular slice and I wait and wait and wait. Finally I approach the counter and as soon as Tony sees me he tell the bus boy my order, I’m like really?
I’m still willing to accept it so I tell the guy give me one of the warm slices and I’ll take the Hawaiian to go and he looks at me like a deer in headlights. So Tony takes over I explain again and he tells me those are delivery pizza and you have to wait 5 to 10 minutes after I’ve already been waiting for 10 minutes.
I tell him in not going to wait 20 minutes for a slice to cancel my order and that I’m going to order from somewhere else. I tell Tony I’m just going to pay for the soda I opened and I’m not going to drink.
Tony comes up into my face and tells me it’s my choose not to wait for his food that his creation take time. I tell him I don’t need your permission I simply didn’t want you to make it and have it be for nothing. Rather then be apologetic or nice or understanding.
While he’s in my face he said goodbye, why are you still here? I’m look straight into Tonys eyes and tell him «you know this place has really gone down hill» and he becomes enraged and belligerent and tells me to get the hell out of his store. I never paid for that can of soda I left it on the counter I refuse to deal with savages.
Never again Tony will I step foot in such a establishment that doesn’t know how to treat customers, the services here is wakeful stay away!

This is New York, there’s no reason to deal with such terrible service and such mediocre pizza. I ordered a pie from Mike & Tony’s and was quoted a delivery time of 30 to 45 minutes. After an hour, I called in and was assured that my pizza would arrive momentarily. After another half hour I called in again, and was again told that food was mere minutes away. Finally, after TWO HOURS of waiting, my pizza arrived. The delivery guy, who said that he was the owner (Mike? Tony?), was not apologetic, perhaps because I had pre-​tipped with Seamless.
The actual food was not very good, and the overall experience was terrible. One star.

Sadly, this is probably the best pizza place in Prospect Lefferts Gardens. It’s not bad but it’s not that great. The pizza is inconsistent, sometimes it’s well done and cheesy, other times it’s not cooked enough. The crust is thick and usually a little too well-​done. They are generous with the toppings though, and I enjoy their meatballs and mozz sticks. Occasionally delivery has been super fast but more often it’s unacceptably slow — yesterday (Sunday) it took over 2 hours. I had to call twice to get an update and of course it’s always «on its way.»

Although there’s not much to choose from, this is easily the best pizza and wings n the neighborhood
A lot of people gripe about the wait time for delivery. That’s easily compatible by using grubhub or seamless