Luke’s Lobster

Ordered at the counter and brought our Taste of Maine out back, enjoying it on some odd tables overlooking some very questionable wiring. Cool that they bring the food back to your buoys and play some solid tunes.

I finally made it to Luke’s Lobster. First off, I would like to say the staff was very nice and accommodating to me and my cousin.
We had a really big appetite that day and so my cousin ordered The Taste of Maine and I ordered a lobster tail with a side of Jonah Crab claws. Welllllll first of all. We had no idea that our food would be cold. The only thing that was warm was the butter that we got as an condiment. The food was so-​so/​blah. After eating we were still hungry and so we ordered the lobster bisque soup. That was probably the best thing. I feel like for the $ 70 that we spent, we could’ve went somewhere else and been more satisfied. Sorry Luke’s.

Wow this place is a diamond in a rock, the food fresh and really good, the customer service is really good, I’ll be back

Stopped in here because it was along the way and parking was easily available for lunch during the week.
I was happily surprised with the freshness of the food. It was refreshing and I easily saw myself wanting to order more to go. We ordered lobster rolls, cole slaw, chips, and sodas. The food was lightly seasoned. The cole slaw was nice and crisp, not heavily dresses with mayo like most cole slaws are presented. Definitely somewhere I would go again.
The staff was friendly and it was very clean.

Really, really good lobster yamyyyy, yamyyyy but very small and no Green leaves. Very simple, no design on food. And I got crabs, good also.

I don’t know what all the hype is about. I had the lobster roll and it was just overly salted lobster on a small roll. It was awful. I’ve had better lobster rolls at a supermarket (stew Leonard’s).

Whenever I’m in Park Slope at lunch time I try to come here, which isn’t too too often, since it is pretty expensive.
$ 16 for a delicious lobster roll. The bread is thick and soft and ideal for the lobster that they pile high and season perfectly each time.
$ 2 for a side of cole slaw. It’s not the best but it is a good lighter side to go with the rich lobster roll. I like to add the hot sauce they have on the table to give it some extra flavor.

I ordered 2 crab rolls and 2 lobster rolls too goo. My opinion the crab rolls are better than the lobster rolls!!! Delicious even thought the crab meat was chilled it was still good. The bun is nice and toasted and then the butter makes it even better. After I ordered it only took about 10 minutes to get it. The staff is friendly and helpful. Definitely would come again but will eat in

The guys never looked so happy the few times I have been there, when I go to any place I immediately love to feel the energy of people, and see their smiles…
BUT I know it must be sad to see all those poor delicious lobsters leave every day the cold Maine sea to reach that boiling hot pan. I am sure that is the reason why they are not smiling.
I have tried their rolls combo, with half roll each of the lobster, shrimp and crab .
Then I have tried one whole each.
And Now I know that from Luke’s My favorite is The Crab Roll. Yes. My favorite Lobster roll so far is in another lobster joint.
Luke’s is always too cold to me, and it loses the lobster flavor of the meat and of the special sauce in the roll.
The shrimp roll is ok.
The crab roll is tasty, juicy. Good.
Yesterday I also tried for the first time their lobster cheese sandwich. Nice but too expensive for the price and with too little meat.
Luke’s, I know you can do much better with that cheese sandwich !!! Add some more pieces. Come on.

This review is for delivery only, since I actually have never been to the actual restaurant.
The food is delicious! Very pricey, but good. I’ve got the lobster roll and ½ crab roll. The crab roll is actually better than the lobster. However, it is TINY. It’s about a ¾ hot dog bun (maybe because it’s toasted) for $ 16 for the lobster roll. So, –1 star for the size/​price & –1 star for the delivery guy. Not a good evening, nor a thank you or a bye, even after I greeted and thanked him. Kind of rude.
I’d order again (or would stop by for a bite), but in a day I can splurge.

I went here around 8PM on a Monday night. I was craving lobster for about a week and Luke’s lobster delivered ! It was empty because it was the first work day after the snow storm and I assume people didn’t feel like leaving the house. The staff was very nice and attentive and answered all questions.
I ordered the lobster roll combo which came with Cole slaw and a root beer. It cost $ 16 plus tax. The lobster roll was delicious! It was seasoned perfectly and the lobster texture was perfect. The Cole slaw I was not a fan of. I like mayo in my Cole slaw but this one had vinegar or oil (I’m not 100 certain). My companion got a shrimp roll combo which costs a little less. She did not like her shrimp roll, it was pretty bland. She opted for BBQs chips instead of Cole slaw which was good.
Overall, the experience was great. The staff was attentive. I was also able to find parking across the street on 5^th Ave. Just expect to drop $ 30-​$ 40 for two people to eat, but the lobster is so good it’s worth it!

Meh, not as good as the one in fi-​di. No seating space, just take-​out. And even though I ate it right after getting it, the lobster roll was lukewarm at best. Also forgot to give me any cutlery for the slaw.
I’d rather go to one of their other branches than come back to this one.

Loooooove the mini lobster rolls.
Edited to 5 stars!
I find no reason to take that one star out so here you go. I come here probably every other Saturday, I love this part of town and they are very friendly, serve the best lobster rolls, I usually get the Taste of Maine and a clam chowder, or I stick to the lobster roll. If I was to come with a friend, the Arc is the way to go.
There’s so much flavor in the bun, crispy, buttery in taste, the mayo does not overpower and the seasoning! Please give me the secrets! I bet I could swallow three toasted buns without the lobster, their lobster meats are not the most chunky, but marinated just the perfect way.
I love the interior here, although I prefer doing takeout, today I actually sat down by myself and took a good look around, the ocean theme is not too touristy but very artistic. They play great music and serve great drinks, that pickle on the side, I would eat two no problem!

I love lobster, and when I want a quick, no-​hassle quality roll, this is my go-​to place.
They have crab and shrimp rolls, too, but here I stick to what I know I like.
Fresh, huge chunks of lobster are stuffed into a warm, buttered roll, then sprinkled with black pepper. Delicious as it is, it tastes even better with the pickle.
When I get it with chips and a beer, it’s a refreshing weekend lunch for summer.

I love lobster, I love lobster repeat 10 times click your heels and I am standing in Lukes Lobster. Well I wish it was that easy, but Lukes does offer some fine fare.
Been a fan of the original location in L.E.S but being in Brooklyn decided to check it out before heading to Prospect Park. I usually get the combo and today decided on some grilled cheese with the lobster.
Really wasnt impressed with the grilled cheese could have been much better. Overall the Lobster was good, cold and mouth watering. The location is very spacious with outdoor seating.
I did click my heels under the table as I devoured this delicious delight. Come on who has time to boil and crack a lobster. And if you can do that find some split top buns… they are hard to find… come on.
P. S. — Dont forget your mobster lobster card. free lobster when you fill the card.

I’ve been to their east village location and that location was very small. This location is a lot bigger. There’s plenty of space and there is even a backyard. It’s casual, dark, with wooden décor. I had the lobster roll and it was quite small, but very fulfilling. I like the bun they use. It’s lightly toasted and buttered. The lobster was chilled, lightly seasoned, and mostly importantly fresh, and has a great taste to it. You really taste the natural flavors of the lobster without it being overly seasoned. And the roll was stuffed with chunks of lobster meat. They could definitely use a bigger bun.

I visited Luke’s Lobster during the 5^th avenue festival. They put a stand outside their store. I am a huge lobster fan and I had the lobster roll with butter. They use a hot dog type bun and there is about a pound of lobster on the roll, it was juicy and delicious and not overcooked. I liked it and will come back again.
They also have crab and shrimp rolls.

I waited so long to have a lobster roll from here, they took forever to open! When they finally did it was still cold out, i don’t know I like lobster rolls when the weather is nice and hot, it’s a mental thing lol… after a very long walk back from target I decided to drag my mother in law in and have some lunch, it was great to see they have a very nice spacious backyard, so we sat back there. It was very empty, it was also very early for lunch. I ordered us the combo meal (lobster roll, chips, and soda) it was expensive $ 36 for both of us… at first impression I thought the roll was very small, the size of a hot dog bun, it did have a lot of lobster… and although small, it was still filling, especially with the chips & soda. The lobster tasted great, big huge chunks, lightly seasoned on top, toasted bread with a little mayo… just wish it was a tad bit bigger, because you know… I like to pig out!
I will most definitely be back, and it will save me a trip to red hook lobster pound, which I believe has bigger lobster rolls, but to be honest they taste exactly the same! lol

I just love it. It’s lobster roll, crab roll and shrimp rolls. That’s how they roll!
can’t wait to try their soups! No more trekking to the city, thanks for coming to PS!

Typical Luke’s Lobster — which means it was good! :)
I decided to splurge on myself and get the taste of Maine — half of a lobster, crab and shrimp roll, pickle, drink and small bag of chips. The crab roll was very good, as was the lobster roll and the shrimp was fine, but nothing I would write home about. Got this all for $ 20 here and now they have the taste of Maine with 2 claws for $ 23.
The Park Slope location is more convenient for me than the city so I’ll stop by when I’m craving again!