Captain Midnight Fishing

Crazy Eddie is the man! They took care of us and were always available to get out the tangles and replace hooks and sinkers. We didnt catch anything, but people we went with caught a big ass Cod and lots of «cango eels» (not sure how to spell). The price was gair and it was an all day event. We left at 7:45am and didnt get back til 4:30pm so plan accordingly. The bathroom was out of order and pretty gross. Overall the staff was great and we had fun! Bring food, drinks, and sunblock!

Ive gone on this boat each year using the available Groupon, and have had great experiences each time. This year however, I did decide to go with a large group of friends on the weekend, and I can see why everyone may say it’s overcrowded then. If you go on a weekday, there will only be a handful of people including yourself. Just so everybody knows, the Groupon does say 8:30 — 2:30, but it is actually until 3:30. Like someone mentioned earlier, the crew is very friendly in a rugged way. They will filet your fish that you are able to keep for you. I would definitely recommend this boat, and will be coming back soon.

When i first went out with this captain i was amazed that everyone was catching fish but then when you are fishing go porgies that travel in schools that would be the norm. I fished with him a second time and noticed that when certain people came aboard and entered the pool he would not move the boat if that one or two people are catching multiple fish and the rest of the boat is hit and miss or nothing. They say 3 strikes and you at out. Well the captain of this fleet of boats including the Admiral Midnight struck out as I witnessed the conversation between one of the guys who was strangely helping a guy who said (he was not part of the crew but the captain allowed for him to collect the fare) to one of the regular fishing guys, «he is gonna put you on them all day» sure enough as my hand is white the captain did just that this guy was on the fish all day and once AGAIN THE OTHER PATRONS WHO WERE IN THE POOL CAUGHT 1 – 3 AND THE GUY WHO WAS ON THE FISH CAUGHT AND CAUGHT AND CAUGHT AND CAUGHT. so why didn’t the captain move to another location if only one person was benefiting? HMMMM, sorry folks but he struck out with me and my group.

Just want to point out there are so many odd five star reviews. Been to the boat myself, main complaint is that we hang very close from the shore. I was expecting that we would go out into the open sea instead of 40 meters away from Brooklyn shoreline for the entire day.
P. S. Bring a jacket, it might get cold.

Always a good time on Captain Midnight, everyone from the Captain’s Jeff & Timmy to the mate Kyle and rwr of the crew top notch!

Always a good time. he always puts you on the fish and gives you extra time. The mates are on time with baiting and netting your fish. I would recommend this charter to other people
Roy S

This can be hard-​core fishing. It it not always pretty, or clean like most yachts, but the captain put us on fish most of the day. Jigging and some people dunking bunker for blues, over 100, a few dogsharks and even a keeper fluke were taken on board. Great Memorial Day of fishing when you catch a bunch, lose a few, and catch the pool winner! Almost more filets than I could carry.
Mate Kyle, I still owe you, for your help and cheerful support. Will see you soon! Lil

We booked a Groupon deal and this fishing trip was way better than the fishing trip (or better yet, non-​fishing trip at the Angler Fleet). We got to the dock early. It was me, my 2 siblings, and 3 other guests. Based off of reviews, I thought the boat would be crowded but surprisingly wasn’t, so it was nice to have all of the right side of the boat opened. We sailed for an hour before they dropped anchor. I don’t get seasick but unfortunately most of the guests got sick. My siblings were ok until the boat stopped, as the boat rocked alot. Fortunately, I was fine and I manned all 3 of our rods. We rented 2 rods at $ 5 each and when my line got tangled, 1 of the guys helped me detangle it. After 2.5 hours out on the water, I got a good size black sea bass. I was very happy with that! Even though I was the only fishing in our party and only caught 1 fish, I still tipped the guys on the boat. They helped me detangle my line and took the fish off the line for me. I bet fishing on the Captain Midnight during the summer would be amazing!

First time going fishing on midnight star and loved it! Will go again.
We purchased a groupon and was well worth it.
Only con — boat was packed, not much moving around room.

The mates were very helpful, especially when it came to getting lines untangled. Caught a few fish :) The captain could lay off the horn though if your a believer in noise scaring the fish. Bring your own cooler with whatever you want to drink and eat. Also something to store your catch !

I am baffled by the positive reviews. We went there today and it was a shambles. No staff, no service, boat overloaded with people, and toilet filled with ooze. There was no space to fish, people were complaining all around us, so we did a runner when the engines started. Horrific boat and more than happy to have written off the money.

No complaints. Staff was attentive, and always available to assist with rods and bate. Friendly, prompt, and fun. Went on a Wednesday evening. There were about 6 others on board. The boat was quiet and relaxing. Great experience.

every week for the last 4-​years i go fishing on this boat. never had a bad experience yet” captain jeff is the best always catch fish, great mates bobby, kyle, tommy. they will help you if you need help. meet me there any thursday chuck’

Terrible boat. Terrible crew. I do not understand having these many crew members when they do absolutely nothing, but hang out inside and once in a while come out to ask — any luck? No! No luck! Because instead of going to Rockaways like I was told on the phone by the captain himself, the boat just set on the side of the Verrazano bridge for 3 hours with absolutely no fish. When I made a sarcastic remark about it, the crew members laughed among themselves saying: «I ain’t going out there again! Waves are so big we be the only once not sick!» So if the conditions are bad why not be honest and cancel the trip. You guys new ahaid that no one will catch anything! To top it all off when my husbands line got caught on the bottom and afyer trying for five minutes to loosen it up we called a crew member to help his answer was :“well, loosen it up!”, I said «we have been trying for five minutes, can you help!», crew guy“well I am not going to do anything different then he is doing!” Are you kidding me! You are there to do all those things! That is what we pay for… And like a few people have mentioned the boat is gross, dirty and no fresh running water.

My First fishing trip ever in my life with my fren Charlie Choi. I couldn’t even handle the Rod, now after couple of trip in the water got that down as well. Captain Jeff knows where to stop the boat and throw your reel in and also the team goes around to help people untangle the hook or support the novice guys. I really like them boats. They are great no complaints. Very friendly crew !!

Out of the sheepshead bay fleet this is probably the worst one. Smaller boat that packs on people with the groupon /​living social vouchers. It’s alright if you just want to get on the water and drink some beers, but don’t expect to have first class service or a wonderful experience fishing. You may catch some fish but more than likely you’ll catch the line of someone who’s shoulder to shoulder with you.

This is a down and dirty fishing boat. The boat isn’t as dirty as people are making it out to be, by the way. I had a great time even though I got a little seasick. Caught a few fish, even got a keeper. Tommy, the mate on the boat was seriously helpful and a lot of fun. There were a few seasoned fishermen on the boat who made it a blast, as well. Once I get my sea legs I’ll definitely be coming back. If you want an honest to goodness fishing trip, use this boat.

We bought a livingsocial deal for a full day of fishing for two, and it expired last week. We never had the chance to use it. Why? We went the second to last weekend before it’s expiration date and that boat was PACKED. While we were walking up to ask if they could fit two more people in, the people by the dock were very enthusiastic about getting us a space in the cramped boat, but… that was until my friend decided to inform them of a lil suttin suttin. He told the crew «we have a livingsocial deal for 2, do we show you now?» and one member of the crew immediately said «oh. you have the deal… i don’t think the captain will let me squeeze you two in then. Come next week instead.» REALLY? I still PAID, but these people just wanted cold cash (more cash too) upfront. I even told him that was our ONLY day available, or else the coupon would expire on us — Nope, didn’t give a flying f*ck. Now what, captain midnight? Use my deal for the face value and pay full price for my companion? When it was you guys who refused to let me on your boat because I had a deal.

There are so many fishing boats to choose from… unless you’re a pro and know who’s who and what’s what… which do you choose?! Thank you Living Social. I’ve always been hesitant with the fishing boats… you never know if they’ll rip you off or just might not want to deal with plain rudeness. While the crew here isn’t exactly Uncle Jack’s waiter material, they’re still pretty good. They’re friendly, in a rugged kind of way, and service is pretty good. The captain even stayed out a little later for us because people began to start catching «keepers». People here have complained about «cleanliness»…It’s a fishing boat… with fish… and bait… and fishing-​type people… how «clean» do you really want it? I don’t see fish guts or dead things anywhere so it’s plenty clean to me! With this said, I’d give this place a try again.
Oh, on this trip. all I caught were 2 claims, a mussel, and a fluke that’s way too small…
*sigh*

It was ok. i went there last sunday and it was SUPER CROWDED!!!
My advise: never go on the weekend. it was like 100 people on the same boat and half of the people ended up throw up everywhere… it was super nasty and smelly…