Katonah Pizza & Pasta

Awesome pizza I’d say I frequent this place about once a week. My favorite slice they have is the Cajun chicken slice, however you can’t go wrong with the buffalo chicken or the ground sausage slice. Everyone who works there is really friendly and their slices are HUGE!

I think they deserve a solid 4 for food and service. It’s probably the best pizzeria in the Woodlawn area. Some of my favorites are the whole wheat veggie slice and the bacon, tomato and American cheese pie – this is an absolute must try! I also quite enjoy their shrimp parm hero and blackened shrimp salad – this salad is super yummy and my go-​to option when I’m trying to be good and not eat too much pizza. I’ve also tried their wings but they weren’t that memorable. The desserts can be hit or miss. I had the tiramisu once and I did not enjoy it but the zeppoles are consistently good – not too oily or too doughy.
Everyone behind the counter is friendly. The location is literally a five minute walk from my home, so I usually like to place an order and pick it up. This is always a great option when we end up entertaining and need a quick meal. Our friends never complain when we order from Katonah Pizza.

Well they do have a lot of variety. I like their caesar chicken salad. Their pizzas are good but not great. I go get a slight stomach ache when I eat here. don’t know why. But I like the fact they can make any kind of pizza.

I was extremely underwhelmed by the pizza here. I ordered the white pizza and was initially impressed that it was a pretty short delivery time– 35 minutes. There was sooooo much ricotta on this pizza that I couldn’t even lift up a slice without it collapsing on itself and falling apart. It also had very little flavor so it was pretty boring. They’re such a great location but I have no interest in ordering here again. Also thought I’d mention that I don’t feel well at all… Just like a bunch of reviews warned.

Chicken+Bacon+Ranch+Pizza= Amazing

The Baked Ziti in this place is to die for. AMAZING! I couldn’t get enough, this place would get it right every time.

Whenever I can’t find my daughter, sure enough she’ll be in here. She loves their bacon chicken ranch slice and fried Oreos. They are very friendly; if they see you on the street they say hello. Very family oriented business. I usually get the buffalo wings with sauce on the side. Pretty darn good. I’ve also had their chicken Caesar wrap. And their Tiramisu hits the spot. Thank you Pizza & Pasta!

Ordered for the first time from here tonight. We order white pizza which was very tasty, also ordered mild wings and BBQ wings which were terrible!!! The wings were tiny and the meat was dark. Seemed like poor quality of chicken. I didn’t expect topnotch wings from a pizzeria, but these were unfortunately terrible. My friend ordered a cheese calzone and he liked it.

Simply the BEST!!! I live in Woodlawn and walk past 2 other pizzerias to get to this one!!! Always great friendly service and the food can’t be beat, always fresh.

Love this place! The do an amazing pizza– chicken bacon and ranch dressing! It’s addictive! The guy who owns it is usually behind the counter, super nice!!! It’s lovely to see all the family photos on the walls of his daughters etc. Makes it feel homely. I get delivery from here a lot, delivery is always quick, deliver guys and the woman are always really nice too.

This place will make you sick to your stomach
So we moved to the neighborhood a few months ago. Being a huge pizza aficionado, eating it at least once a week, I tried this place. At first was so excited at the variety of slices but then I noticed something. Everytime I ate a slice here of any kind, I spent the night with painful stomach cramps and sick to my stomach in the bathroom. So I completely quit this place. Tried this place again the other day after thinking that perhaps I was being too hard on them or else how could they still be in business… Ordered 2 plain slices and alas spent the night with the worse stomach cramps in the bathroom I wouldn’t wish on anyone.
After reading other reviews of the lack of hygiene used at this place and also other Unilocalers who have reported spending the night on the toilet after eating here– please avoid for ur own sake– unless your looking to lose a few pounds in water weight the next day

This place is a dump. A true dump. While visiting family in Woodlawn, I dropped in one night because I had seen the sign in window advertising gluten-​free pizza. First impression, 4 «good old boys» types, all acting «too cool for school» taking a long time to do nothing. Second impression: old looking «lamestream» (cross between lame and boring mainstream wanabe copycat) pizzas sitting looking dry in display case (e.g. breaded fried «buffalo» chicken” sitting atop pizza drenched in some nasty white sauce on type. original guys…). Third impression (the kicker): I order the g-​free pizza. The owner proceeds to turn his back to me and begin saying to the guy making the pizza «have u tried the gluten free pizza, it’s DISGUSTING… Friggin’ disgusting…» (and on and on, describing particularly nasty texture etc.). Unbelievable. Keep in mind I am about 5 feet from this guy. I SHOULD HAVE WALKED OUT. However, being hungry, I decided to wait. 25 minutes. When the pizza came, it looked ok. Brought it home, ate it, spent the entire night on the toilet, no joke. For the love of God how does a place like this stay open? Woodlawn, not a lot of options, people have never ventured into NYC and tried a real slice of pizza? Idk. My relatives drive 10 minutes away to buy their pizza and now I understand why.

So the man puts the toppings in the pizza, then a customer comes in and is ready to pay for his order, he takes the money and gives him change and he went back making the pizza again without washing his hands or wearing gloves. Then his helper did the same thing. I was watching them hoping they would wash their hands while waiting for my pick up pasta… but disappointed. Then when my food came, the helper, still without washing his hands, started bagging my food and put a roll of bread, with his bare hands to go with my order. I just threw my order in garbage

I order from here almost once a week, and the ONLY reason that I keep doing so is because the food truly is great! However, ALL but TWO TIMES that I have had food delivered from here the following have happened without fail!:
–Delivery time is OVER 1 ½ hours
–Having to call to see where my food is once the 1 ½ hour mark rolls around
–When the food FINALLY arrives the delivery guy has a smug attitude like he’s doing you some huge service by showing up at all
–To top it all off, when you finally sit down to eat practically starving to death from the wait, the food is as if though it has been sitting in the back of said delivery guy’s car for the entire duration of the extensive waiting time. UNBELIEVABLE!!!
It is extremely frustrating to not only wait for nearly 2 hours for your food to be delivered, having to call to check the status of your delivery, dealing with a rude delivery guy, all for cold, and I mean COLD wings and pizza that you then have to reheat in your oven! So again, without fail, every time I get the food I am then so furious that I have to call a THIRD time to complain. A manager is never present, but instead a very sweet girl who proceeds to apologize for the inconvenience and then credit my account for next time. As appreciated as that is, I just want my food in a timely manner and still at a reasonable temperature when it arrives. Not a lot to ask but nearly IMPOSSIBLE here at Katonah Pizza. GOOD FOOD, BAD SERVICE!!!

The white slice, like others have mentioned, is legendary. I usually go for the white, tomato and garlic. It’ll knock your socks off. They also make a deep dish slice with tomatoes, garlic and roasted red peppers that’s pretty awesome too. I have ventured too far off these two items on the menu. Overall: quality pizza and reasonable prices. Best in the neighborhood!

Living right around the corner, this is my go to pizza place. I go here not only because it is close, but also it is pretty good. Its not the perfect pizza, but it is my eyes its some pretty darn good NYC pizza. Large flabby slices, good sauce, not plastic cheese, and in my eyes some good crust– flowery, not too hard, and good texture.
What is even better is that offer a plethora of pizzas, ranging from Buff Chicken– actually pretty good– to slices with fresh motz and veggies. Also the chicken rolls are pretty good as well. Plain slices will set you back 2.50, Sicilian– 2.75, and specialty– 4 bucks. If you are feeling frisky you can get some Eline’s cheesecake to take home with you.
Who knew I would have to live in an Irish Neighborhood to get good pizza?

I could eat their chicken parm all day ‘erry day. A few times when I’ve gone in someone behind the counter sends a deep-​fried oreo my way. Not sure how they knew I could be bribed into loyalty so easily…
When I’ve had a few too many the night before and I’m curled up on the couch with a fan blasting on me watching re-​runs of Pawn Stars and wondering what I’m doing with my life, Katonah Pizza always pull through. Delivery is fast and they never judge the state of our apartment.

Now this is pizza! Portions are huge and many delicious toppings to choose from. My absolute favorite is the bacon chicken ranch ! Yummmm

Everything I’ve tried here is great — I am a total regular and real fan — they have large variety of great choices of unique pizza slices, their pasta is terrific and so are their salads. They have great other items, panani’s etc. and all of them great too.
On top of that — they are all really nice, friendly and helpful — you always feel like a great customer whether you get one slice or larger meals!

Solid prices, Delivers. Overall a stand-​up Pizza joint.
Home of the «Great White Slice». I don’t know what it is, but their version of that particular slice of pizza is the best I’ve had. Maybe you’ll disagree. Maybe you’re just a jerkface.
They got these spinach wheels and pepperoni wheels. They’re really cheap and greasy and so damn good. If they got’em, get’em.
They also make a pretty frickin’ good bacon cheeseburger. Sometimes the fries are soggy, most times they’re not. But that disjh hits the spot when I am in mood to face my oven.