Anthony’s Pizza and Pasta

Best pizza in town. Recently it seems the service itself has greatly improved. Very commonly come to eat here with my family and the rare occasion a mistake is made, they are very good about making the problem right and taking care of us. But overall, my favorite place in town.

I gave them another shot after my last negative experience, hoping it was just a bad day. I ordered online and picked up at my designated pick-​up time. When I arrived the counter girl (very friendly& apologetic) said the web portal was malfunctioning again. It seems like this is a constant issue after reading other reviews. So, they had to run my card again, even though I had already paid online, and they hadn’t even started my order yet. I specifically reminded them that my order said «light sauce» but my order was still made incorrectly. The counter staff was friendly but the system seems broken. The teenage guy standing in the open kitchen watching the dining room, eating a slice of pizza, then going back to doing his job, didn’t make me feel like steps for cleanliness are taken seriously. We probably won’t be dining here again.

Our go-​to for pizza in all of metro area. This location is especially great with the friendliness of its staff and professionalism. I have never had a bad meal here and especially love the sicilian, if you would like a nice lunch grab a slice of it or if you like leftovers are real hungry or have a big group get a full sicilian. They always go out of their way to make sure their patrons are very satisfied here.

Can’t say that I was too excited, AFTER waiting an hour, (which was expected!), to get a HORRiBLY BURNED Pizza! Can’t even believe the cook let this out of the kitchen… Mistake on part to order from here. ALSO… The Delivery Driver got an EXCELLENT Tip. I feel TOTALLY BURNED with this experience/​transaction!

If the place is empty, and the staff are having a good day, an in-​store meal is on par with grocery-​store quality frozen pizza.
The pizza is not ground breaking.
The locals invent ways to make this tiny dining room uncomfortable, a favorite among local construction workers and stay at home parents-​on-​playdates.
I had to stop somewhere for lunch in-​between meetings and two self centered moms (under disciplined bratty kids in-​tow), actually placed their metal marker over mine at a table where I was about to sit and just sat down, offering a weak apology but not moving.
The staff said nothing.
Typical Brighton. Selfish, small town, a Ghost Town by 2025. The next President will make sure people can again afford to buy in Denver, eliminating the only reason people buy in or near Brighton.
Anthony’s Pizza isn’t good enough to go out of one’s way for. A Mexican restaurant that shared its parking lot closed within a year.
Parking: really, really bad.
Phone Orders: Read other’s reviews. Not Good.
The drinks dispenser is always low when I go in.
*When their delivery staff has nothing else to do, I’m pretty sure they respond to Unilocal reviews… :)
It’s a franchise, folks. Do it better. Anthony’s Pizza doesn’t suck everywhere.

Let me be the first to say — I love New York style pizza. Especially from Anthony’s. I especially love being right across the street from them. However, I have a few issues with it.
The pizza for one is bland sometimes and undercooked. Would it kill them cook it a little longer and actually have spicy Italian sausage? I have to say that I would not get Italian sausage again.
The second issue is the price. 40 cents for a substandard topping? And the cost of the salads — huge for how small they are.
My last problem with it is their website. It’s always malfunctioning and not letting me order, saying it is too late. I call and they send it out, saying the website malfunctions often. It’s not that expensive to fix a website — why haven’t they?
Otherwise, I like them. They’re close, friendly, and fast.

Great little spot we found while driving around for something to eat. Apparently not many restaurants are opened on Mondays in this area, so that is what led us all the way to Anthony’s.
We ordered an 18″ Neapolitan, with white sauce, fresh veggies, and a couple of kid servings of pasta. The kids, scarfed up their pasta immediately. The 18″ pizza we ordered was much LARGER than 18″, and come to find out from their website when you dine in you receive a 24″ pie instead as thank you for eating there. I only wish we had known, since we would have then ordered the 12″ (Dine in is actually 22″), since we were heading to the Airport and weren’t in need of left overs. Other than that, the pizza pie was amazing.
If I lived around this area, I would definitely make this my go to place. We might have to sneak by on our way to the airport next time, just so we can try something different.

I love their pizza! I used to work at the one off Colorado and 7^th for about a year, eating the pizza everyday. I still go to Anthonys because of how good their pizzas are!

Love the calzone and always great service when we come here and not to mention the great deals they offer. 2 slices and a soda for only 5.50. Wow. If yiu want great pizza in Brighton yiu need to come here.

Good pizza, easy price. Mainly we order here because they deliver to our address but we are pleased with food.

I usually love this place. The pizza is great, but the deal was that the Brighton parade was going on and I ordered pizza at 630. I call 3 times and they say they are busy we had a parade yeah I know I was there and that was 2 hours ago. Rude girl over the phone so I requested the manager he was rude as well saying we told everyone over an hour which is not what I was told. I had guest at my house and we’re waiting and all they can say is there was a parade and closed streets. I live 5 min away and there are no closed streets. Every person was ridiculous and rude to me and I was just wanting them to know the the lady was rude and that it’s not okay. I won’t go to this place anymore no matter how good there pizza is. You don’t even deserve the one star I’m giving you but Unilocal requires it!!!

Best pizza and best service in Brighton!!! Awesome thin crust and fresh toppings and the staff is always on point!

Get the neopolitan, worth the money, but it takes time for them to cook it, as it’s 18 inch pizza…

The ONLY place to get GOOD pizza in Brighton!

Anthony’s Pizza is our favorites! But do not eat there much because a little pricey. I ordered for New Yeas Eve, and was pleasantly surprised, the pizza I always order was $ 9 cheaper than in the past. Keep it up and you’ve won me back! The best in town! Thank you! Happy New Year!

It’s a friendly place but the food wed was bland and i waited 40 minutes.

I enjoy the food here but the trouble I just went through ordering over the phone with a coupon for delivery was ridiculous. I had a coupon for an 18″ 2 topping pizza for $ 14.95. All I wanted was half pepperoni and half cheese. The girl on the phone was rude about it and said I HAD to order 2 toppings or the price was $ 16.95. I don’t understand why she couldn’t just honor the price. I ended up having to order double pepperoni on the whole thing and ill just pick the damn things off half.

Good pizza, great crust, very skimpy toppings. I got probably 8 tiny pieces of sausage on my huge pizza. Also ingredients are canned/​prepared. I guess jarred garlic is what you get from a chain. Wings were slimy — but the brownie was amazing!

Know idea what happened to this place but it has totally turned around for the better!!! Great service hot crispy pizza and the freshest salad I’ve had at a pizza joint in a while! And they have a feed the family deal for 20 bucks salad pizza and drinks!!! My nephews loved it!!!

These guys make some pretty good pies and offer several styles which is great. The downside is the price. They are defiantly the highest priced pies in the area. The service is so-​so, usually high school kids.