Brewster Square Pizza

First, the only reason why I would give this 4 stars is because they’re the only pizzeria in the area that delivers otherwise I’d give them 3 stars.
Expect the food to take about an hour to arrive and to also be cold. The food is pretty basic and all one note.
If you’re hungry and can’t run out then this is your only option.

The pizza is mediocre for the area. I also got a chicken Parmesan hero and a spaghetti and meatballs for the kids. The sauce on both was totally bland. The spaghetti was swimming in an inch of water in its togo tin and meatballs were waterlogged. My kids wouldn’t eat it and that says a lot. The chicken on my sandwich was definitely not cooked fresh and had to be at least a day or 2 old.
Wings were good. Delivery was fast and they are on grub hub so you can order online with a credit card. It’s convenient to order delivery online if your short on cash and they are the only place around that I can find for that.
3 stars is probably a little generous. Would get pizza and wings delivered again if I can’t go pick up somewhere else. Definitely avoid any dish with marinara sauce.

This place saved our lives. Megabus broke down on th I-​684 in Brewster, NY at the Brewster truck stop. When the group of 80 people that were stranded finally found out where we were, we called Brewster and spoke to Tony. He knew exactly where we were, took our order and had a large delivery in 30 minutes to the middle of NOWHERE!!! Thank you so much guys for your delicious pizza. My party was traveling since 3am from Florida and had not eaten all day! Everyone was so grateful, because we were starving. You guys are the best!

Update: Nothing has changed, they are still fantastic and I love their food and great attitude.

Best pizza in Brewster IMO. Great spicy wings served dry, so they keep their crunch.

Well I gave this place another shot and they were so much better. The pizza was delicious of course but this time the service was good as well. I will definitely be ordering pizza from here again. Hopefully the service will continue to be good.

Delicious food, good prices and always welcoming !!! Definitively recommended.

We recently moved to Brewster Heights in the fall and this place is right down the hill from our house. So far we have never been disappointed the pizza is always fresh and hot, the crust is even cooked well. Much like my grandfather I like the crust well done and not doughy, like he used to say «Burn two for Lou!» It is cooked perfectly every time and lots of toppings if you so choose. The white pizza with tomatoes is awesome!
Their entries and appetizers are also good and your get plenty of food. Generally my wife and I order a dinner with an app and it is plenty of food for me, her and my 3 year old daughter. The Garlic Knots are good too, not greasy and loaded with garlic.
For the most part delivery is fast, arrives in the time frame they promised and the food is hot and fresh. You can even pay by credit card with the driver! The only slow times are Friday or Saturday nights, but to be honest I don’t think anyone is on time on a Friday or Saturday.
Finally if you go in the restaurant to pick-​up they are extremely pleasant and the place is always clean. After a few trips they even start to remember who you are.
This is definitely our new favorite pizza and coming from Goldens Bridge with Portofinos around the corner from the old house that says a lot. If you are in Brewster this is the place to go for good Italian food!

Tasty crisp pizza. Has a nice flavor.