Supreme Pizza & Subs

Went here last night to grab a bite to eat after a night out. I can’t say this meal was my sharpest memory, but I definitely enjoyed it.
My friend and I decided to go with the Brooklyn pizza – it took about 15 minutes to come out, but it was very good. Lots of pepperoni and sausage, along with some garlic that really gave it a nice kick.
Overall, this place is popular among the after-​hours crowd and they serve up some good pizza at a reasonable price.

Decent pizzas for decent price!
Ordered: 2 large cheese, 1 large pepperoni, 1 large 2 toppings ham & pineapple
Total: $ 53.05 about $ 20 bucks cheaper than a couple other places and no delivery fee! We added a tip! Delivered at the expected time. No plates or napkins included, forgot to ask for them?!? Lest you think we’re animals and ate with our hands… wait a minute, we did eat with our hands!
Pizza was all you could ask for at midnight! It wasn’t as cheesey/​gooey as I like, but it had good flavor and it wasn’t overly doughy or super thin, had a good amount of toppings. I’d order from them again!

I was visiting from Phoenix a couple days ago. I had chicken pizza from here two nights in a row and I loved it!
The price was cheap compared to other pizzerias I have visited in the past.
The portions of the grilled chicken were comparable to none I’ve had before.
The restaurant was clean and the service was good as well.
I would recommend this little neighborhood spot to anyone.

Terrible, I’ve ordered here a hand full of times, first 2 time food was great.
3 times now I’ve had to send my food back, the people that answer the phone do not know how to take a order or the guys cooking just don’t know how to read.
Super unsatisfied and will not make The mistake of giving them a chance again.
Everyone save your money!

Really good subs, their steak is also really good.
Pricing is good too! Pretty cheap

I like pizza, especially east coast pizza but I have to say this place has an amazing slice of fucking pizza. It’s perfect size, folds nice, cheese is prime, and the dough and sauce are perfectly made. I will add that majority of the folk who work here are typical shit heads who have a cold personality that tends to come with the Boston vibe. Learn to smile and appreciate that you live in a blessed country. I can’t get over the fact how shitty of an attitude some people have here.
Oh and I forgot to mention, keep it simple. Cheese, pepperoni, etc.

Supreme is the bomb, some good ass food. I’m a college student at Berklee right by from Supreme, and I go all the time or get delivery when I’m at my dorm late at night. Pizza is awesome, Sandwiches are great, fries are good too. Some delicious food right there. Definitely recommend

Yeah just got food delivered from here. I got a the apple and walnut salad and a steak and cheese. The steak and cheese was alright. And I think the flavored in the salad would have been good, however after I dressed my salad with the raspberry vinaigrette I had the pleasure of finding out you guys packed my salad with a tub of hot sauce instead of the dressing. That is why im reviewing one star. I mean come one how do you mess that one up.

Quick Greasy pizza any time of day or night? Yep. This is where to go. Delish.

I’ve had the best cheeseburger sub here, and an Italian this week, which was also delicious. Every time I go in there, people tell me how great the pizza is, so that’s next on my list. The guys who work in the day, are friendly, courteous, and make your food exact to order. I definitely recommend trying them out. Best compared to some pizza shops in the area. And I’ve worked around here almost 8 years.

Terrible experience the guy pulls up to my house on his cellphone and then forgets the soda that i purchased. I call the pizza shop back and they say «we dont have a soda on your list». After i told him i am certain that i asked for a soda he says «oh okay yes yes i see now you did ask.» …this is extremely minor but i am someone who has worked in the customer service business for over ten years. Not to mention the careless delivery driver returned back with the soda and was STILL talking on his cellphone. Like wtf is that. After waiting an hour and a half for my delivery to have to wait another half an hour was pretty annoying.

Pretty darn good pizza. Went with one that had ricotta cheese on top and was a bit much for me, but otherwise was excellent. New York style. Grub hub certified which allowed for delivery was also a plus.

Really great pizzas. Just the way i like. Crispy crust and bottom, and the perfect amount of chewiness.
They don’t skimp out on the meat on the meatlovers pizza.
Standard menu offering you will see in Boston area sub shops.

The delivery man arrived driving fast and hard, clearly sure of himself. He drove like he could handle large objects. He smiled as he got out of the car, a nice touch to an already pleasant exchange.
«Thank you,» I said, winking. He left.
My friends and I ate the pizza slowly, letting the gooey cheese tear from each slice as we pulled it gently from the box. Drip, drip went the cheese, hitting my chin, forcing us all to laugh.
«Mmmmm hmmmmmm,» was all we could say.
I’d order from Supreme Pizza again, and again, and again, one more time, multiple times actually.
Thank you Supreme Pizza.

I’ve only had their margarita pizza, but if the rest of their food is as amazing as their margarita pizza is, then Supreme Pizza is my new favorite local pizza place! My roommate and I have ordered from here several times through GrubHub and they’re always kind and deliver on time.

Hi I said I was going to review Supreme Pizza and it did take me a while. I ordered nine days ago and decided to wait then try it again to see if it is consistent.
First off I was told 30 – 45 minutes for delivery but it arrived at my door in about 20 swift minutes. HOT in a fun «happy holidays» box is just one reason for my tasty sophomore odyssey.
I always have a good feeling about a slice when I pick it up and just when it’s nose dives down just enough when it’s THAT hot. Nice typical pizza crust, perfectly cooked with corn meal bottom.
The plentiful number of sausage rounds are very flavorful and full of real Italian style sausage including fennel. Must have been formed in a ball to keep it delicate and juicy.
The Pepperoni is superior in it’s own right, bit spicy as it should be makes me feel it’s a good quality product.
At the end of the day? Nothing original or jaw dropping here by any means however it left me asking for more. T.M.C’s only complaint could have been left in the oven just a bit longer this time.
Price wise the price cannot be beat so come claim your prize Supreme Pizza & Subs, 5 stars because the good beats the bad noted by a crowded belly.
T.M.C

Usually a sub place is pretty straightforward. Most have the same fair. The only thing that sets sub shops apart are if they screw things up. Ordered from here 3 times. First two times the subs were good, but made incorrectly. This time we ordered mozzarella sticks for the football game and they came in a broken down huge ball of stuck together cheese. Reluctant to order from here again.

Had a really tasty Italian sub here last night. Good enough that I’d definitely go out of my way for another, next time I’m in the area.
Nice bite of tang from the vinegar and the salami, and the saltiness of the pepperoni came through without drowning everything out. One thing to note, though: They will add mayo to an ‘everything’ unless you say otherwise. Normally I loathe mayo, but it worked surprisingly well here. I’ll probably get it again.

The 1 star rating does not reflect the quality of the pizza but rather the sanitary issues that were plainly displayed by the woman making pizza today. I ordered my slices of cheese pizza and honestly, it was good pizza by Boston’s standards. Then, however, I noticed the woman in the kitchen constantly coughing with her mouth uncovered WHILE MAKING PIZZA! Unbelievable. She was coughing all over the pizza. Multiple times I watched her cough and blow her nose into a paper towel, which she clearly thought was good enough, and the go on to cook food and knead pizza dough. She only had a glove on one hand and never changed it or washed her hands. I couldn’t continue eating, I was horrified. I’ve never seen such a blatant disregard for cleanliness in my life. I will NEVER be back. What a shame, the pizza was actually good.

I am OBSESSED with the pizza here. By far my favorite place in Boston. It is SO crispy and delicious. It’s that kind of pizza that you hold up and it doesn’t flop over from being soggy — even when it’s loaded with buffalo chicken (their best type, in my opinion).
They are open late and you can order by the slice! Great service too.