Jersey Mike’s Subs

Since I happened to be hungry on that side of town, I stopped in for my favorite…#43. It was a little skimpy on the meat which tells you not all Jersey Mike’s are the same. They seemed a little unorganized, so I’m happy they weren’t too busy when I came in. This was the first time I felt I over paid for a sandwich.

I went to Jersey Mike’s with my parents yesterday. I wasn’t expecting much, but it was next door to my dry cleaner and close to the office, so I thought why not. I was pleasantly surprised by the experience and give this restaurant high marks!
To start with, the interior is clean and has an almost perfect health rating. The manager and staff were friendly, which is always a nice bonus. We ordered chicken Phillys (you can tell from my other reviews that I am obsessed with them) and they were great!
There was quite a crowd for lunch, and not many available seats. You are probably better off ordering your food to go during peak hours. We got there a little bit early and there was a steady flow of people through the line. The staff worked quickly and got people in and out. This is great if you are trying to get back to the office.
The portions were good, but I can’t comment on the size of the cold-​cut sandwiches (a few people on other reviews commented on this). Overall, I think this is a good, clean place. The staff worked hard and I enjoyed it!

I came upon a very rude manager/​owner! I ordered the BBQ roast beef sandwich and requested the sauce on the side. The price on the menu for this «special» was 6.95 reg size. Now, the PLAIN roast beef on menu was posted at 7.45. So when I get to the register he rang me up at the higher price and when I complained he said they didn’t have that sandwhich. Meanwhile the young lady walks up with my sandwich and cup of sauce on the side. His response: I was trying to make him GIVE me the food free? WTH. I took a picture so he can’t dare dispute… see for yourself.

4 for parking — can get a little busy during lunch hours
3.5 for seating/​space. It’s not THAT tiny, but definitely don’t bring a big lunch crowd with you
4 for the speedy service. The folks who work here really try their best to get everyone’s orders.
Why a 3 star rating…
The past few times I’ve been here, I ordered the meatball sub. Just b/​c it’s quick and easy. And… because I like that kind of sauce in general. The way your sub is handled really depends on who makes it.
The first few times I had some people who can’t get the concept of ‘adding extra’ stuff to my sub even though it’s a hot sub. I just asked for pickles, jalapenos, and onions. At least twice when I opened my sub back at my office, I saw nothing in there OR the extra stuff was bare. As in — only 2 of each items were there. :(
The last few times the other guys (new I assume?) were able to add my extra stuff, but added WAY too much cheese when I asked for less.
I can’t win. :(

This Jersey Mike’s has the best roast beef in town. The staff is very friendly and efficient. Their bread is very fresh every single day. Excellent!

Like Jersey Mikes, just not this location. Their portions are extremely small. When i order a $ 10 sandwich i want more than 3 thin slices of meat. Been there several times before i stopped going. I was tired of being completely disappointed everytime i finished a sandwich from here. Even brought it up to what appeared to be the manager, who responded with «this is the way all JM make the sandwiches…»
I’ve been to other JM locations and this is not true. It’s the way this location practices. Save your money and frustration.

Funny friendly owner, decent food. I got the steak Philly and it was good. I thought it could have had more meat but I haven’t been to another location to compare. They regularly have a 100 health score. 2 regular Philly’s one drink and a bag of chips was under 20 dollars. This did seem to be a cut above Subway. I’ll go back.

Literally got about 3 slices of turkey on my sandwich. I blame the manager since other jersey mikes locations hook it up. Can’t believe I paid 7 bucks for bread and vegetables. Worst JM experience ever.

«I’d like the number two, Mike’s Way, please.» And that’s almost as long as it took to get my sandwich ordered, prepared and wrapped up.
One of the great things about Jersey Mike’s is that they slice the meat to order. There isn’t a stack of meat separated by little bits of paper that the «sandwich artist» stuffs onto your bread. What’s wrong with fresh? NUTTIN!
It’s a simple concept. There aren’t eighteen different kinds of bread and cheese to choose from. They don’t have a buffet line of veggies to add to them. Why is that needed when what they do have — lettuce, tomato, onions, hot peppers, pickles and olives — is plenty good?
Oddly, my receipt says «20 ounce bottle of water» when the bottle was actually only a 16. Oh, well.

I had never had Jersey Mike’s Subs before till last week. They have nice big subs, but I find their meats are very highly processed and rather bland. They seem overpriced for the quality.

Quality of food is awesome. Owner is super friendly. They were open in snowstorm last week when most businesses shut down early. The staff greets you when you walk in. The tvs are a nice touch during lunch.

These guys are awesome! They are the only restaurant in the area that stayed open all night long during the snow storm. We went in the following day (still being the only restaurant open) and the owner and one other employee had been there working for almost 30 hours straight. They are great people who care about their community (which is rare to find these days) and I am now a lifelong customer after what they did. The food is on par with any other JM, which is great!

First visit in me and my girlfriend ordered the Big Kahuna a very large sub and for 12 dollars

I don’t think I’ve frequented a restaurant more often in a 3 month time span than THIS specific Jersey Mike’s. The staff here has to handle some of the craziest lunch rushes I’ve ever seen with the office parks nearby. And even on a day or two when the CC machine was down, they still kept customers moving and satisfied.
This may start sounding cheesy, but I think the folks here have really good teamwork. I haven’t seen them change staff at all so everyone who works here definitely already knows what they’re doing.
I will definitely miss them when we leave Atlanta at the end of the summer!

Very classic sub sandwich with fresh ingredients! They slice the meat as they make it for you.

Been to alot of these, but this one is by far the skimpiest on meat I have ever seen. Only 3 slices cut extremely thin on a regular size sandwich.
Go to another location for better value and some actual meat on your sandwich
Cheap Cheap Cheapo! I have noticed maybe some places think no one will notice if they skimp on things and they will get away with it.

Worst customer service ever. Hadn’t even left the parking lot and went back in to get my cup filled and the owner himself yelled at me about their policy for not allowing people to fill their cups after they left the front door. I understand if I had driven off, came back 2 hours later and expected a drink, but seriously? Also on how I wasn’t allowed to use the restroom for longer than 5 minutes. I’m never going there and the whole experience has put a bad bitter taste in my mouth for all JM stores.

I love Jersey Mike’s. I always get the Big Kahuna sub. And it’s always made to perfection. This particular store is alway clean. The workers are efficient and genuinely nice guys.

At least three of my friends worked at a Jersey Mike’s in high school. I hadn’t eaten at one since then (12+ years ago), until now. I stopped by this Jersey Mike’s for lunch on a weekday around 12:45pm. The place was buzzing with people. Barely a seat was open and the atmosphere was a bit hectic as the workers were busy trying to fill orders as fast as possible. After 1:00pm, the traffic died down significantly. There are several office parks nearby (e.g. Wildwood) so this place gets a lot business from office workers.
Jersey Mike’s is an underrated sub chain IMO. Jersey-​style subs are my favorite because they tend to be the tastiest. Baldino’s, which also makes great subs, is the only other sandwich shop I know of in Atlanta that makes these. The subs typically include shredded lettuce, tomato, onion, oil, vinegar, and other seasonings (here they call it’s «Mike’s Way») which really add a lot of flavor to the sandwich. Expect to spend about $ 6 – 7 for a regular size sandwich (half a roll of bread — almost as filling as a Subway footlong) and $ 10+ for a giant size sandwich (one entire roll of bread). Breads are baked fresh on-​site daily and meats are sliced-​to-​order, something you won’t find at most other chains.
Jersey Mike’s menu can be confusing if you don’t know what the numbers next to each of the sandwiches mean. The numbers aren’t sequential. I was told by a former employee that each number represents the order in which each sandwich «recipe» was released. So the #56 Big Kahuna Cheesesteak must be the 56^th sandwich released by the company. They have cold sandwiches, hot sandwiches, and wraps. You can get any wrap as a sandwich and you can get any sandwich as a salad, i.e. no bread. They call it «Sub in a Tub.»
I tried two of the restaurant’s most popular items, both hot sandwiches on wheat bread: #43 Chipotle Cheese Steak and the Buffalo Chicken sandwich (wrap converted in sandwich). They were quite good. The Chipotle Cheese Steak is Jersey Mike’s regular Philly cheese steak with added chipotle mayo. The mayo stood out, rich and flavorful. The Buffalo Chicken sandwich came with a side of ranch dressing, which was great for dipping the sandwich into. Both sandwiches come with a lot of sauce, so be careful while eating. I really liked the bread, which was warm and soft.
The staff did a nice job handling the lunch rush as sandwiches were prepared swiftly. Friendly service and 100 restaurant inspection score too.

I love going to Jersey Mike’s for lunch. They are fast and they slice the meat after you order your sandwich. The only thing that I don’t like is that they can’t heat up your sandwich in the microwave because of some corporate rule. Really? I hate cold sandwiches and my favorite sandwich is actually on the «cold subs» list. I just have to take my sandwich with me and put it in the microwave. But I still have love for Jersey Mike’s.