4 – 5 stars for the quality 1 star for the length of time and all of the headaches along the way. this is the 6th contractor i have worked with over the years. most of them have been around 3 stars with the only exception being heath neill in new orleans who rebuilt my house there. started digging early july. its november now. 3 weeks of no one showing up. multiple missed appointments. trash bin sitting in front of my house driveway destroyed landscape lighting cut off for months. now pier light cut holes dug and left in yard for a week– filled with water from rains. my pug fell in one of the holes and would have drowned if hadnt been standing right next to her. he builds a quality pool though so if you can wait for 5 months of building and 2 months of permits then it would probably be worth it to you.