Andy’s Hometown Pizza

This place is great! We come here once a month or so, often enough so they know us when we walk in. :). He pizza here is always great and we do have a tricky order at times. We get the meat lovers pizza– which my friend always loves! He loss it up with lots of meat and cheese. The thin crust is also what we get and is the best option!
I typically get the taco pizza, with no meat and half of the toppings on the side. Or the Mac and cheese pizza with some added veggies. I have also got these two combined and they are more then happy to make my request.
We have never had a bad experience here and always are stuffed when we leave. I would recommend joining the rewards program for extra offers and free items every few months. Great service, great pizza and always friendly staff… I would also recommend his place to anyone who wants some good local pizza.

We stopped by while on vacation. It was terrible! When we walked in, we were greeted by 2 employees at the front counter. We were given menus and cups and told to sit anywhere and a waitress would be out shortly. After reviewing the menu and waiting 10+ minutes, our waitress came out. No introduction, just a brief «what can I get you?». We ordered a special from the menu that included a large pizza, 12 wings and cinnamon sticks. We also ordered bread sticks. The bread sticks came out after about 5 minutes and were pretty good. About 10 minutes later our pizza and wings came out. After going back to the counter and asking for Parmesan and then back again to ask for red pepper, we were ready to eat. The wings are baked, not fried. They were mushy and the sauce (teriyaki) was subpar. The pizza was downright bad. The crust was mushy and not crisp like you’d expect. The toppings were lacking. This is the first time I’ve ever left a restaurant with my husband and not finished a pizza or at least taken the leftovers with. I’ve written this entire review after finishing dinner and we are still waiting on those cinnamon sticks, although I highly doubt they will change anything about this review!

Good, basic thin crust pizza. Liked the nachos the best. Food quality was ok for a pizza joint, but the plastic utensils and foam plates held me back from rating it any higher…

This is the best pizza in town. Always good, fast but not too fast. Delivery drivers very professional. Fresh toppings (you can always tell by the mushrooms which are not canned like most places). Just as good as Pizza Factory in Monticello, which is what I use as the reference as it is excellent as well.

It’s very hit or miss with this place! We have ordered a few times its never consistent. When my family orders pizza we order a lot and Andy’s is very expensive for the quality! I love delivery but not from here anymore !

Best pizza in the city, bar none! Faves are the Hometowne Supreme and the boneless buffalo wings; pastas are great too. Staff and the owner are always friendly.